Th Most Overrated Villager?

[Becca617]

OH! I forgot about Stitches! He showed up in my campsite one day and he's creepy looking in my opinion! I don't get the attraction! He looks like a broken stuffed animal that was sewn back together and then magically brought to life! He creeped me out and I could not imagine having him in my town.

This is actually exactly how I feel! But the most overrated I'd say is Marshal.

 

[Heisenberg]

I am always gonna dislike Stitches. It's just....outta place go me to have a creepy life sized teddy bear walking around, especially since he has no eyes. I can understand why people like him but yeah. Also there are too many of these posts but I suppose new people will always show up and everyone has their own opinions. I also am meh towards Ankha, her expression is just...depressing, lol. Although I absolutely love the furniture in her house.

 

[MetaTriforce]

First off, I'm not gonna lie- I really like a lot of the popular villagers. Most of the villagers in my town are pretty popular. But I guess I'd have to say that I don't understand why so many people like Fauna and Fang. They just seem kind of plain to me.

 

[Splinter]

Julian. I've always hated the horse villagers and sticking a horn on one doesn't change anything for me, glitter.

 

[mob]

Merengue and Stitches

 

[Cory]

Marshal, Stitches, and Tia.

 

[budewarmin]

Julian

 

[BungoTheElf]

Marshal and stitches

 

[Mary]

Marshal. He's white. And small. So? I don't see the appeal.

Coco is a freakazoid.

Genji- Same.

Stitches. OK, he's a teddy bear. We get it.

I don't think any of Julian's hype is stupid. He's a unicorn. That in itself is amazing.

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Julian. I really dislike unicorns.

 

[Jarrad]

Meringue and marshal

 

[FireNinja1]

3. Tangy

Please, an ORANGE?! I just don't get it, she's so ugly, and her concept is equally attractive as Beardo's.

2. Merengue

I thought everyone hated the hippos, but NOPE, everyone loves her just because she looks like she's made of cake.

1. Julian

This one is self explanatory.

 

[Jarrad]

3. Tangy

Please, an ORANGE?! I just don't get it, she's so ugly, and her concept is equally attractive as Beardo's.

2. Merengue

I thought everyone hated the hippos, but NOPE, everyone loves her just because she looks like she's made of cake.

1. Julian

This one is self explanatory.

Sir, Merengue is not a hippo. She is a rhino.

 

[Alienfish]

Yea, Tangy is overrated, never liked her much.

Love Beardo though

 

[Jarrad]

Yea, Tangy is overrated, never liked her much.

Love Beardo though

beardo?
what really? I'm not a fan of popular villagers; I quite like the occasional ugly villager.
But Beardo is just too ugly.

 

[Alienfish]

Nah I love his mustaches. Fav smug after Marshal

 

[oak]

Definitely Beau. He seems like the most plain of the deer.

 

[heichou]

i kinda feel like marshal's a bit overrated,,,, but he is a cutie
whispers i have him living in my town so i guess my opinion's a bit biased

 

[Born2BWild]

Beau: way too generic
Marshal: way too cranky-looking
Julian: WAAAAAYY too over-the-top.

 

[Coolio15]

i understand how some people don't like popular villagers, but when you group together and just keep constantly putting down every single villager that is a top tier just smh get on with your lives.

The only thing that really annoys about the popular villagers is that they get so much attention drawn to them, especially on the Trading Plaza and it makes me just wish that every villager, even TIFFANY, could get the same amount of love and popularity as the rest. But people have preferences, and Lunatic is right, we should dedicate a thread to praising the popular villagers just to even it out