should katrina come back? & other things

[Bluebellie]

I think she should!
I loved Katrina in new leaf. She’s one of the darker NPC and I would love if she became permanent in the future.

 

[Neechan]

Another idea could be that the lucks affects the rocks. Good luck could mean doubling the amount of bells you get in the money rock, or increasing the chance of finding gold ore. Bad luck could mean reducing the bells in the money rock or maybe your tools breaking faster. Just a thought

Thats how it worked in NL (don’t know how if It was present in previous games), if you had bad/good luck, you got less/more money respectively here’s the article for luck https://animalcrossing.fandom.com/wiki/Luck

I’m all for Katrina only if it brings the luck system back

 

[Miele]

Thats how it worked in NL (don’t know how if It was present in previous games), if you had bad/good luck, you got less/more money respectively here’s the article for luck https://animalcrossing.fandom.com/wiki/Luck

I’m all for Katrina only if it brings the luck system back

Oh! I never realised it cause I never did the money rock thing in NL. That’s really cool and it would be really interesting how luck can be implemented in NH.

 

[minimoon]

I really want there to be good luck and bad luck in the game and for it to actually mean something. I don't know why, I just think it's a really cool aspect that other games don't have.

I read that Feng Shui doesn't affect luck, only your HHA score and if that's true it's so sad. I don't care about my HHA score but with RNG being such a big factor in this game I like the idea of trying to improve my luck a little bit through funny superstitions, like wearing lucky clothes etc.

I hope it's true that wearing DAL clothes gives you better mystery island luck because I always do that. Please don't tell me if it doesn't!

 

[Hirisa]

I wouldn't mind seeing Katrina return, but my question is when should my wife Luna come back? There is nothing about her that I do not miss.

 

[mayortiffany]

ABSOLUTELY!

... Can you tell that I miss her tremendously? She's been a staple of the game in every series so far, and I think that she is a very cool character.

I think there's so much they could do with her in this game too! She could start showing up as a travelling merchant, then if you visit her enough times (like in New Leaf) or complete certain tasks for her, you could invite her to set up shop on your island. She could sell special fortune-telling related items or DIYs and/or give them out once you've visited her enough.

And luck is just such a cool mechanic, I'd love to see it come back.

 

[Jacob]

Um yes! Miss her

 

[JeffreyAC]

I never really used her services back in NL, but I want her back because I miss this phrase

 

[SleepyMimeko]

I really want her to come back. Katrina was always my favorite. Hopefully she'll have the same fortunes she did in population growing. The one where your villagers follow you around is hilarious!

 

[Feferily]

Oh man, complicated thoughts on this one. On one hand, I loved her personality, her style, her quotes, and I absolutely adored the luck system sometimes. On the other hand, the racism around her got a little tiring for me personally whenever I had to see people use the G-slur for her because it reminds me that stereotypes are still accepted sometimes....

Ah, overall I would like her back. There’s some I would prefer more (GIVE ME THE DANCE NEW HORIZON) but yeah!

 

[*The Oakboro Mayor*]

I liked Katerina! I tried doing the good luck charms or items every time she came around at first (even though I literally never knew how it worked and was just so clueless). At the end of my New Leaf era, I did the charms less and less often. Never the less, they were a fun thing to try and hunt for, and I loved her iconic style! I think bringing her back would be cool, but it would be totally understandable if Nintendo didn't want her back because of backlash and whatnot, with all of these new players paying attention. (also the wall of chakras and stuff in the plaza was COOL and brought a great feel to the ally-like building, change my mind )

 

[Xara]

i would love for her to come back! i miss being able to get my fortune read instead of having to guess for myself whether i have good or bad luck lmao ;u; if she does come back, i hope luck will play a bigger part than it did in new leaf!

 

[Sephiroth]

I would love Katrina back, but sadly it appears luck was removed from the game so her use is kinda pointless in NH. Getting her shop in NL was rewarding. I loved the predictive elements of the game.

A few of the NPCs will likely not return, Shrunk, Harriet(unless she brings new hairstyles), Copper and Booker(got replaced by a box), Porter, Digby.

Cyrus and Reece could still get a more permanent spot with retail rather than event purgatory. Would be cool if we could customize locked furniture like the Rattan set and be able to sell items to villagers and visitors again.

I have a feeling we will get Luna back. Lyle or Lottie could even return for the HHA. Kappn also has a high chance of returning.

 

[John Wick]

If the graphics and dialogue with her are good, sure.

 

[Noel_in_Sunrise]

I had the lovely phone in New Leaf and called her most days after I got it. I was super into Feng shui and daily luck. One of my major complaints with New Horizons is not knowing if luck exists in a meaningful way and not being able to check daily luck.

I used to look for rare fish only when my luck made it easier.

 

[FishHead]

Only if they remove either kicks, labelle, or leif from the NPC cycle and make one of them permanent. So if leif or kicks is taken out then she can be a guaranteed NPC.

 

[niko2]

No thx

 

[SpiritofAce]

I could see her coming back in August. Seems like an easy NPC to add in.

 

[Solio]

I like her design, but the luck-mechanic I didnt care for. Revamp "luck" and Id love seeing her back.

 

[JellyLu]

I wouldn't mind! I like Katrina and all, but if she were to come back I'd love to see something different added. I like what others have said about what would define good luck and maybe an exclusive furniture set with her!

I'd still rather have Brewster though