Should I keep Bluebear or replace her with Marina?

[Milady]

Help, she’s in my campsite today but I love both :[
I already have one peppy: audie and 2 normal: flurry and molly

Edit: quick questions can i get gifted items back from villagers?

 

[EtchaSketch]

definitely keep bluebear, marina may be cute bur she’s so boring

 

[brockbrock]

Keep Bluebear!! Marina is so easy to find nowadays!

 

[Alicia]

I'd keep Bluebear, she's really cute!

 

[Le Ham]

definitely keep bluebear, marina may be cute bur she’s so boring

I have Marina, can confirm. My Sandy is more of a character than she is.

 

[Milady]

Thanks for all the answers! It’s just I want my skull mask back from Bluebear, but you’re right the normal villagers do lack personality

 

[senbeiiscool]

If you decide to kick Bluebear out, there's a chance you can get the item back but as far as I can tell, what you see in the recycling box is random. You usually get a cardboard box and 1 item that the villager previously owned. The item they leave behind is usually something you gift them, if you haven't gifted them anything then they'll leave behind one of their original furniture