Rowan or Rolf?

[in-a-pickle]

So, I love both of these tigers from what I've seen of them in screenshots and the like, and yet I can't seem to decide which one is better. I already have a cranky and a jock, so it doesn't matter to me If I have another of either one.
I really like Rolf's coloring, and while Rowan is the more natural tiger he isn't quite as cool, but is cuter than Rolf. Need help?

Rowan Rolf

 

[Gizmodo]

ROLF IS ABSOLUTELY AWESOME. my favourite male villager in my town, even just above Stitches
one of my original 5, and i have his pic, hes just so cool
Rowan looks derpy

 

[georgeshair]

I love them both, but Rolf is my favourite. Rowan is obsessed with his 'guns' (muscles), while Rolf writes surprisingly soppy letters for a cranky tiger.

 

[Moon]

I say Rolf as well. I just think he's cute, and different. Rowan's great too, but Rolf takes the cake for me.

 

[Solar]

Rolf! Had Rowan in my previous town...He wasn't exactly my favorite...

 

[BitterCoffee]

Rowaaaaaan <3 He's my baby.c: I got more attached tobhim than I thought I would xD He's a total sweetheart:3

 

[radical6]

get rolf
i love rolf
rolf is great ok you'll love him

 

[-strawberry]

rolf is amazing! i love cranky villagers (my second favourite right after lazy) but i've never liked any of their designs. so when i found out there was a cute white cranky tiger it was a dream come true~~~~~~ go for rolf, he's flawless. <3

 

[in-a-pickle]

Rolf does seem to be the popular choice! I debated and found that with so much love for this tiger, he must really be worth it.

Hope to have him as a part of my town one day!!!!

 

[PinkWater]

Rolf! He's cute in his own lil way, plus white tigers are awesome!

 

[Saphy]

Rowan, the pink bit's round Rolf's eyes weird me out

 

[Wychglade]

I'd go with Rolf as I much prefer the cranky personality, plus I think it suits the tigers more, jock doesn't fit but isn't funny enough to make it cool either (like a jock penguin is hilarious).

 

[Sheepish]

I prefer Rolf's design. Rowan just doesn't strike me as a jock, I guess.

 

[irisubunny]

Rolf<3 he used to be in my WW town, and Rolf's just awesome and adorable overall!

 

[ShinyYoshi]

I like Rolf's black lines on his forehead and his mean look is kind of cute