Rosie or Tangy?

[Snap Crackle Pop]

Felicity is moving out but I want to replace her with a villager that has the same personality and is a cat. So I’m stuck on these two options, both of them are really cute but I can’t decide which one is better

 

[LuluLove]

I’d say Rosie cause she is so cute and lovely! But I’m biased, I don’t really like villagers that look like food/fruit. I’m more for natural looking villagers

 

[hakutaku]

I think it depends on which one suits your island better? For example, I picked Tangy as a villager because I got oranges as my native fruit lol.

Tangy is great btw, her fruit themed house is adorable and her house is bright orange. But if Rosie suits your island aesthetic more then you should totally pick her!

 

[Roxxy]

I have to go for Rosie, don’t have her on my island atm but have in the past. She is a cutie

 

[Fye]

I'd go for tangy! She's super cute and apart from being an actual orange, she actually looks more natural to me since cats can be orange but obviously can't be purple but they're both cuties!

 

[Bulbadragon]

I have Rosie and I love her! Personally I think she's cuter than Tangy but I think they're both great picks. I just prefer Rosie's looks and house better.

 

[saucySheep]

Rosie because citrus aniamls look freaky

 

[Heartcore]

Rosie all the way. She's a classic AC character. Also one of my favorite villagers of all time. I'd definitely go for her over Tangy.

 

[DinosaurDumpster]

I love them both, but I definitely would say Rosie if you want a sweet, innocent goofball. If you would like an orange demon cat where you can eat their kind right in front of them, go with Tangy. She's sweet as well, but I definitely find her as a demon cat sometimes.

 

[Dunquixote]

I vote for Rosie since she’s a favorite of mine and I like her design better, though I still think Tangy is cute. This is your island though, so pick whichever one you like their design better or which fits your island’s theme better (if that matters), and more importantly who you think you’d be happier with in the long run.

 

[mocha.]

Aw, I love tangy! She was one of my ACWW villagers and I grew so attached to her. Rosie is super cute too though, I’d say flip a coin!

 

[xlisapisa]

They’re both absolutely adorable! I haven’t met either of them in new horizons yet, I’ve had Rosie in past animal crossing games so I probably would choose Tangy since I’ve never had her in any of my games. I love the fact that she looks like an orange and the little leaf on her head is so cute!

 

[Marshmallows]

I love both... maybe Tangy a bit more, but you can't go wrong with either. My favorite peppy cat is probably Merry, though.

 

[Uffe]

Tangy is the OG. Definitely Tangy.

 

[Nunnafinga]

Gotta go with Tangy.I had both Rosie and Tangy in New Leaf but I always liked Tangy more.It's the fruitiness.

 

[Che5hire Cat]

I don't mind Rosie, but personally, I would go here with Tangy. I just love her design and she's also one of my favorite cats. Besides, her smile is adorable.

 

[Serabee]

Tangy! I don't normally like super themed villagers, I tend to gravitate to more natural looking ones, but I had Tangy as a kid and I just have a deep love for her. She's so delightfully random and weird I have her on my island RN and I love how she kind of looks like a pumpkin at the right angle- perfect for Halloween!

 

[Mezzanine]

Deleted

 

[Aquilla]

Rosie recently moved in on my island and I really enjoy her. Her house interior and exterior is adorable, she sings and dances all the time and since watching the animal crossing movie (yes, that's a thing) I love her even more.

 

[peachycrossing9]

I'm saying Rosie, but that's purely because she is one of my favourite villagers,

She is really cute though, and her house is nice