Arithmophobia17
Senior Member
rosie - merry is cute but i don't love the brown bit of hair on her. rosie is super cute imo though
Rosie or Merry?
- Thread starter Sudsofsplash
- Start date
Sudsofsplash
Pocket Egg
dang rosie is winning by quite a bit! rip merry LOLOL
rosie's pretty iconic when it comes to the AC series so i usually think of her as an ac staple and kinda prefer her for that reason.
both are good tho, but ill lean on rosie. i also think she's a more fitting peppy. ;; good luck picking.
both are good tho, but ill lean on rosie. i also think she's a more fitting peppy. ;; good luck picking.
senbeiiscool
Could you pass the senbei?
To be honest, I'm not a huge fan of either, but if I had to choose one, Rosie... but Merry isn't bad either after talking to her at one of my friend's islands.... a tough choice
I've always liked Felicity as my peppy cat when I had a cat village on one of my cartridges for New Leaf. The more I have seen of Merry lately, I do find her more appealing now. I was never a big Rosie fan, but I find her more appealing than Tabby and Tangy for sure personally.
brockbrock
♬ jeg har ikke lyst til at dø ♬
Rosie is one of my favorites of all-time, so I choose her. Merry is cute, too, but she's no Rosie. 
moon_child
Senior Member
Rosie is proper cute but Merry is funny cute and I have her in my town and I like seeing her face because it cracks me up. She’s often walking about talking like she’s had 10 cups of venti americano with two extra shots each. Lol.
I love both of them so much and just went through this dilemma. Rosie has been one of my favorite villagers since I was a kid, I had her in my GC town. But for this game, I had Rosie and swapped to Merry and honestly, she's really cute and I feel like she suits me more. Plus she has two cute little teeth and a double chin. She's my chonky girl. But both are good choices. I'd probably have both if I didn't have Audie.
Not a super fan of any of them (though they are cuties), but I have to go with Rosie, I don't know if it's the eyes, because for example Ankha doesn't creep me out and she's looking upwards too, but Merry does creep me out a little ^^U
NH literally made me fall in love with Merry and I'm not even sure why! I actually disliked her back when I used to play CF, but since the day I found her camping on my island and invited her to move in she's become one of my favorites. So, definitely her!
Currently in the same dilemma. I have Merry and am trying to get Audie but... Rosie is so classic.
Yep. Rosie is definitely an AC staple. Easily one of the most recognizable of the entire series. But I think Merry is super underrated and I'm glad she's getting some more love in New Horizons. She's easily become one of my favorite villagers in my town.
