Rosie or Merry?

[Sudsofsplash]

I'm thinking of maybe replacing Moe with Rosie or Merry! I know....so many cats and wolves but I'm loving it LOLOL
It's just Moe is lazy and so is Bob and I like Bob better LOL
I love Merry's double chin but I also think Rosie is SOOOO cute but I dunno they're both peppy, both cats, and both adorable !!!

 

[Santana]

I love merry, but rosie is too cute

 

[Jam86]

merry is cute but i've loved rosie since i was a child, she's my 2nd favourite villager ♡♡♡

 

[cheezu]

Honestly, I find Merry cuter than Rosie especially in New Horizons.
I do think Rosie is very cute though but I love Merry's double chin and those little pointy teeth and cute pink nose.

 

[Vextro]

Rosie was one of my childhood villagers in wild world, she is great!

 

[kojuuro]

Personally I would pick Rosie, but honestly Merry is so cute too so you can't go wrong with either! Totally get you on the cat and wolf island... But that won't stop me, I love them too much!

 

[Sudsofsplash]

Honestly, I find Merry cuter than Rosie especially in New Horizons.
I do think Rosie is very cute though but I love Merry's double chin and those little pointy teeth and cute pink nose.

This image is why I was considering getting Merry, so cute!! But I thought Rosie would go well on my island especially since I feel like her and Bob match lol

 

[FireNinja1]

I have Rosie in my town, so I'm personally biased towards her. Merry is cool though.

 

[jiojiop]

Honestly, I find Merry cuter than Rosie especially in New Horizons.
I do think Rosie is very cute though but I love Merry's double chin and those little pointy teeth and cute pink nose.

Wow this totally changed my opinion. Like I literally changed my vote. I had Merry in a previous game and didn't really like her look - I also generally don't really like animals with hair plopped on top of their head.

But she looks WAY better in NH.

Too cute!

 

[Sephiroth]

I have both. I was actually planning on replacing Merry with either Kid Cat or Punchy.

 

[Sudsofsplash]

Wow this totally changed my opinion. Like I literally changed my vote. I had Merry in a previous game and didn't really like her look - I also generally don't really like animals with hair plopped on top of their head.

But she looks WAY better in NH.

Too cute!

omg that pic of her with the doughnut, so cute ;0; i dont know if id like having three peppy since i already have audie but im almost tempted to try and get both rosie and merry LOL

 

[AquaMarie]

Hard choice, they are both really cute! I'd have to say Rosie though, I have a big attachment to her since she was my best friend in WW.

Even though I do think Merry is very cute... for some reason I've never been able to get past her upward cast eyes. It just really bothers me for some reason.

 

[alias]

I had no idea Merry has lil fangs.............................I need her now alskfjasdlkfasdfgd

I'm not overly attached to Audie so thank you for unintentionally helping me find a peppy I want! <3

 

[Sudsofsplash]

I had no idea Merry has lil fangs.............................I need her now alskfjasdlkfasdfgd

I'm not overly attached to Audie so thank you for unintentionally helping me find a peppy I want! <3

haha! i'm glad to hear that! i hope u find merry !!

 

[Gaby]

Rosie... no offense to Merry lovers but she’s kind of creepy to me xD

 

[Sudsofsplash]

Rosie... no offense to Merry lovers but she’s kind of creepy to me xD

Is it the eyes? cause I can see that lol

 

[fallenchaoskitten]

I have never been on the Rosie hype train. It is one of those I don't really get.
I prefer Merry because her look is more sweet/simple than Rosie who does look more hyper/excitable.

 

[elphieluvr]

Is it the eyes? cause I can see that lol

seconded that she is creepy and yes for me it is the constant upward gaze.

 

[Rosewater]

Rosie. Merry looks unsettling and she's not as cute anyway.

 

[Sudsofsplash]

Rosie. Merry looks unsettling and she's not as cute anyway.

;0; thats harsh (LOL) But I can see it!