Replacement suggestions?

[MochiACNL]

(this probably will be really confusing)

So I wanna replace Tammy with a cuter villager.

I don't know who, although, I've been considering Maple.

I currently have 2 normals, 2 smugs, 2 uchi (including Tammy, who I want to get rid of), 2 snooties (soon getting rid of Becky for Chevre), and 2 lazies.

In the end, that'll leave me with 4 normals (if I get maple), 1 uchi, 1 snooty, 2 Lazies, and 2 smugs.

I'm lacking a cranky, jock (don't really like jocks) and peppy but none of them really interest me.

Any suggestions?​

 

[Drew1234]

My personal favourite uchis are Pashmina and Deirdre.
For cranky, many popular ones are Chief, Fang, my favourite Wolfgang, and I think Butch my fit your towns looks..?
My all time favourite jock is Teddy, he's super cute. Also Bill, Poncho and Rudy....
But hey! It's your town, and so what if it's got four normals, if that's how you like it great!
If you want a Peppy, maybe Bluebear, or Cheri cause she's a bear cub like Maple and cute cool colour like Tammy.
I dunno if that's what you were looking for!

- - - Post Merge - - -

The struggle is real.

 

[mermaidvivian]

I know you said peppies don't interest you, but maybe check out Merry (I know, I rant about her way too much)..? For whatever reason, I feel like she's kind of a cuter, more toned-down peppy... Dierdre (or any other deer) may be a good and cute replacement too! But like others said, if you want normals, go for normals! It's your town and your choice.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I really love maple, but I had 4 normals at one point and it was too much for me. They're not the most dynamic personality, so I got a bit bored. I'm happy enough with 3 or 2
For other suggestions, what about getting a cute cranky? One of the wolves (fang) would be a great choice.
Poncho for a jock? I know you said you don't like them, but he is really adorable in game.
Bruce is also a very cute cranky, but he isn't as good as fang fang is just beautiful. He's been in my town a longtime and will never leave

 

[drowningfairies]

If you were aiming for a normal, I like Flurry and Tia.
A jock I have is Bam, and he's adorable. Teddy is as well.

 

[namiieco]

Octavian is the best-looking cranky I'd say.
If your looking for something cuter you'd have to pick a peppy.
Dotty, Carmen, Rosie, Felicity?

 

[Xara]

If you wanna replace Tammy with another uchi, I suggest one of the following; Muffy, Hazel, Cherry, Fuchsia, Deirdre

Personally, I feel like 4 normals would be a bit overwhelming, and they do tend to get repetitive (take it from someone who currently has 3 normals)

But it's your town, and you're allowed to have whatever villager you want. Might I suggest looking at the villagers that have your favourite personality, and choosing one that you like, and don't have? Or maybe look at some pwps you like, and if it's a project that can only be suggested from a specific personality, maybe try to get a villager with that personality?