Reneigh or Plucky?

[RedRum2514]

I need a Sisterly/Uchi villager on my island and I can't decide, I like the chicken villagers but I'm not sure I like pluckys' design, reneigh looks ok but I have Winnie on my island and I'm not sure I like the horse villagers (tall villagers kinda freak me out tbh lol chickens are the only exception) I'm just not sure. what do you guys think?

 

[Feferily]

I think if the horse villagers freak you out it’s probably best to go with plucky! ^^ or maybe a totally different uchi if you really don’t like either design?

 

[Altarium]

Out of these two I prefer Reneigh, but you don't seem thrilled about either of them... may I suggest Deirdre? <3

 

[DawnAri]

I think Reneigh looks so good! a friend of mine has her and I low key want her to move to my island lol

 

[Globes216]

Had Plucky in New Leaf and she was one of my starters for this game, highly recommended. Of the chicken villagers I think her and Ken are by far the best looking. This saying I also really like Reneigh too

 

[N a t]

I'm a little biased because I like horses better than chickens but Reneigh cute as heck

Edit: Had to reread your post, if you already have a horse I would choose Plucky instead so that you can have more variety.

 

[BluebearL]

This is a really hard decision! I am a big fan of both of their designs so you can't go wrong either way. I have a slight preference for Reneigh, she just has a lovely design that is quite unique.

 

[Xara]

you don’t seem all that interested in either of them ;w; might i suggest fuchsia, deirdre, katt, hazel, cherry or pashmina?

 

[Arckaniel]

I personally like Reneigh better but Plucky's cute too, just not that fond with chicken villagers

 

[lieryl]

i mean if either aren’t your style tammy is kind of a vibe

 

[Blueskyy]

Reneigh is awesome. I’d also choose Cherry, Fuchsia, Pashmina, or Shari before ever going for Plucky.

 

[suzume]

I personally prefer Reneigh(I love the reference to Rihanna), but if you're not too thrilled with either of their designs maybe you'd be happier with a different villager? Shari and Muffy are also pretty cute! What kind of aesthetic do you gravitate towards? Maybe we can help you find a villager you'll like more!