Really? -_-

[Dinosaurz]

So I just spent an hour trying to get a horned Hercules for Freya. I got one, gave it to her.
And she gave me a Cardboard Box.... Really? I mean come on...
Anything like this happened to any of you? I wanna know

 

[Celty]

I spent hours trying to catch a goldfish for Lucky in my old town. Finally caught one and gave it to him.

He gave me a toilet.

 

[Mick]

All the time! Which is why I don't usually bother. I did once catch a coelacanth for Antonio though, because I expected a picture, and I did get that.

 

[Song]

I hate when they ask me to catch a bug or fish. I kinda feel bad when I turn them down though. Sometimes I will accept if I know it's something I can get fairly easily.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Yes!
I accepted to hopefully get her picture, and what did she give me?
A cardboard box...

 

[Taj]

Yeah, the fish/bug kinda ruins their house. I only do big things so I can get pics easily. Which I do

 

[CrossAnimal]

I spent hours trying to catch a goldfish for Lucky in my old town. Finally caught one and gave it to him.

He gave me a toilet.

Maybe he was trying to tell you that you gave him a dead fish. "Here, you can flush it down this."

 

[Mick]

Yes!
I accepted to hopefully get her picture, and what did she give me?
A cardboard box...

That's kind of pushing it for a horned hercules, usually they ask for something very rare before they actually give their picture away.

 

[Dinosaurz]

That's kind of pushing it for a horned hercules, usually they ask for something very rare before they actually give their picture away.

Oh, well I thought it was one of the rarest bugs xD.
But ok,
I really want the pictures so bad..

 

[Mick]

Oh, well I thought it was one of the rarest bugs xD.
But ok,
I really want the pictures so bad..

Yeah, the pictures are a pain, if you're not letting them move.
And it's pretty rare, yes, but not way up there with, like... Scorpions?

 

[visibleghost]

spent hours trying to catch one of those sharks for poppy. she gave me a regal lamp i think?? it's so weird because when croque asked for a river fish and i got him a carp he gave me his pic, but when i give poppy one of the more rare fish in the game, she gives me normal furniture?? like?? thanks a lot

 

[Dinosaurz]

Yeah, the pictures are a pain, if you're not letting them move.
And it's pretty rare, yes, but not way up there with, like... Scorpions?

Don't you dare mention the S word.

*cries*. Been trying to get a scorpian for a long time now. :/ I keep getting tarantulas, like 12 of them, not even kidding.

 

[Mick]

Don't you dare mention the S word.

*cries*. Been trying to get a scorpian for a long time now. :/ I keep getting tarantulas, like 12 of them, not even kidding.

Oh I went there. Don't worry, I thought of you when I saw a scorpion today. <3
I would help you if I could, really.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Oh I went there. Don't worry, I thought of you when I saw a scorpion today. <3
I would help you if I could, really.

:/.
Thanks for the offer, I'm hoping to get one next month, if I can.

- - - Post Merge - - -

OMG FREYA REALLY. I CANT STOP LAUGHING
Freya just said 'I got a little pest I want to get rid off in my house, oh eww not roaches, it's my Flea.'
Omg xD. Freya is so Derpy.

 

[DoctorGrunge]

I kinda dislike when villagers do that, but at the same time I find it funny. I gave Graham a Shark yesterday and he gave me a Trash can in return.

 

[FelicityShadow]

I think I gave Snake either a Coelacanth or an oarfish. I don't remember which one. Then he said (paraphrasing), "Here's how I'll show you my appreciation by giving you one of my most treasured items." I watched the exchange happen, hoping it would be a pic of him and then he tells me, "a portable toilet." So for river fish like the goldfish we get a toilet. For ocean fish, we need a portable toilet!

 

[Serif]

...Isn't that a good reward? It's part of the cardboard set, right? That hella rare set?
You should be honored o-o

 

[Song]

I think I gave Snake either a Coelacanth or an oarfish. I don't remember which one. Then he said (paraphrasing), "Here's how I'll show you my appreciation by giving you one of my most treasured items." I watched the exchange happen, hoping it would be a pic of him and then he tells me, "a portable toilet." So for river fish like the goldfish we get a toilet. For ocean fish, we need a portable toilet!

That made me laugh a lot.

 

[xiaonu]

yeah ;v; this is why I stopped really bothering to do those requests, because the rewards are random regardless. I'll always offer to grab them fruit and such though.

 

[Dinosaurz]

OMFG I JUST CAUGHT A SOCRPION....
Arghh yessssss
I snuck up on it and grabbed it! Omg I'm so happy