Rate the villagers of the person before you!

[Chungus]

Hey, everyone! Make sure you either list your villagers in your post or in your signature.

Post your honest opinion of — including anything between a number ranking out of 10 or a detailed description — the user above you! You can participate as many times as you want, so long as you rate the person before you. Make sure you’re not posting just a number or a single phrase. Be detailed in your feedback!

I’ll start with my villagers, who are also listed in my signature:

1. Kevin
2. Maddie
3. Shari
4. Drago
5. Dobie
6. Walt
7. Purrl
8. Caroline
9. Graham
10. Dom

 

[Sidney]

These are some fairly solid villagers, nothing too exciting or out of the ordinary- even the dragon seems to fit with the general theme. If i had to guess, your island is kinda home-y and welcoming. Gives me good, non-judgement vibes! (mine are in my signature)

 

[Chungus]

These are some fairly solid villagers, nothing too exciting or out of the ordinary- even the dragon seems to fit with the general theme. If i had to guess, your island is kinda home-y and welcoming. Gives me good, non-judgement vibes! (mine are in my signature)

Homey and welcoming sounds good to me! Thanks, good sir or madam!

You got some good boys! Audie, Deirdre, and Lolly are among the cutest of the cute. Only thing I’d be worried about is having too much of one personality type or species. For example, you have three deer and three normals. I would prefer to balance it out, especially with personalities, but if you are a big fan of normal villagers, by all means, go for it!

 

[Darcy94x]

Hey, everyone! Make sure you either list your villagers in your post or in your signature.

Post your honest opinion of — including anything between a number ranking out of 10 or a detailed description — the user above you! You can participate as many times as you want, so long as you rate the person before you. Make sure you’re not posting just a number or a single phrase. Be detailed in your feedback!

I’ll start with my villagers, who are also listed in my signature:

1. Kevin
2. Maddie
3. Shari
4. Drago
5. Dobie
6. Walt
7. Purrl
8. Caroline
9. Graham
10. Dom

10. Kevin
9. Walt
8. Graham
7. Caroline
6. Drago
5. Purrl
4. Maddie
3. Shari
2. Dobie
1. Dom!!

this was tough because I love Shari she was one of my starters but I looove Dobie and Dom is one of my dreamies!
...
My villagers are
1. Raymond
2. Audie
3. Dom
4. Reneigh
5. Coco
6. Peanut
7. Bam
8. Megan
9. Octavian
10. Cyd

 

[niko@kamogawa]

10. Kevin
9. Walt
8. Graham
7. Caroline
6. Drago
5. Purrl
4. Maddie
3. Shari
2. Dobie
1. Dom!!

this was tough because I love Shari she was one of my starters but I looove Dobie and Dom is one of my dreamies!
...
My villagers are
1. Raymond
2. Audie
3. Dom
4. Reneigh
5. Coco
6. Peanut
7. Bam
8. Megan
9. Octavian
10. Cyd

Here's my ranking for you. (Please take note that taste is subjective.)

1. Dom
2. Reneigh
3. Peanut
4. Coco
5. Bam
6. Octavian
7. Cyd
8. Megan
9. Audie
10. Raymond

I can definitely tell that we don't have the same taste when it comes to picking villagers. I am considering Reneigh before though. She's definitely a keeper. But it's alright! Every villager is special to someone. You have a good mix of personalities too which is quite ideal to a lot of players. Hopefully, I will see your entire dream lineup in the future.

I used to have Audie in my island. But she's more of a "jock" for me. My previous jock, Antonio, can barely keep up with her exercising spree. It's quite a big turnoff! Otherwise, she's pretty adorable in terms of design.

As for Raymond, he's a smug. I am having issues liking that type of personality. I tried bonding with Marshal who shares the same personality like him. But it didn't pan out. I gave him away to a friend last week.

I kinda like Dom despite being a jock villager in terms of design. He's severely underrated.

My lineup is in the signature. My apologies that I have to edit a lot in this post.

Hey, everyone! Make sure you either list your villagers in your post or in your signature.

Post your honest opinion of — including anything between a number ranking out of 10 or a detailed description — the user above you! You can participate as many times as you want, so long as you rate the person before you. Make sure you’re not posting just a number or a single phrase. Be detailed in your feedback!

This is a good idea!

 

[Darcy94x]

@yatsushiro

10. Penelope
9. Muffy
8. Skye
7. Lily
6. Chrissy
5. Pekoe
4. Olive
3. Felicity
2. Rosie
1. Diana

you have some of theeee cutest villagers. I don’t really like mice in general but Penelope is cute! Muffy is a bit scary lol Skye I had her on my island but I really found her so boring the rest I would have on my island for sure. Diana is one of my dreamies!

also ~ off topic but I have francines amiibo if you ever want me to scan her in and out for you (no charge of course) let me know☺

 

[niko@kamogawa]

@yatsushiro

10. Penelope
9. Muffy
8. Skye
7. Lily
6. Chrissy
5. Pekoe
4. Olive
3. Felicity
2. Rosie
1. Diana

you have some of theeee cutest villagers. I don’t really like mice in general but Penelope is cute! Muffy is a bit scary lol Skye I had her on my island but I really found her so boring the rest I would have on my island for sure. Diana is one of my dreamies!

also ~ off topic but I have francines amiibo if you ever want her to scan her in and out for you (no charge of course) let me know☺

It makes me wonder now who are your dream villagers. I know that we are both looking for Judy.

I totally agree with you about Skye. Her communication really needs some work. But I guess this is a common issue with normal villagers.

Thanks for your offer! It will take some time though.

 

[Xara]

My villagers are
1. Raymond
2. Audie
3. Dom
4. Reneigh
5. Coco
6. Peanut
7. Bam
8. Megan
9. Octavian
10. Cyd

since the person above didn’t list their villagers, i’ll just rank these ones

10. reneigh
9. dom
8. cyd
7. peanut
6. octavian
5. megan
4. raymond
3. coco
2. bam
1. audie

here’s my villagers:

kid cat
tammy
shep
zucker
beau
margie
audie
vivian
henry
dobie

 

[sunnybear526]

1. Audie
2. Zucker
3. Kid Cat
4. Beau
5. Vivian
6. Tammy
7. Margie
8. Shep
9. Dobie
10. Henry
I had Vivian and Tammy I still have I would have them I love the top four villagers.

Marina
Julian
Diana
Felicity
Bones
Reneigh
Gloria
Hans
Blaire
Tammy

 

[Chris]

Please use The Official Rank My Villagers Thread for this. Thank you!