Rank Your Villagers!

[Airen]

10. Apple - She's not cute enough to be this annoying.
9. Del - I love crankies but I don't care for his design.
8. Buck - Never cared much for jocks but he's one of my original 2 so he's still kinda special.
7. Bianca - She's cute, I love tigers but she will eventually go.
6. Walker - I love dogs but eventually he will go as well. He's lazy which I love but I have other lazy villagers I like more.
5. Marina - Super cute. So nice. Love normal villagers! Unfortunately she was my starter normal so her house is plain. She will move eventually, too.
4. Zucker - Takoyaki octopus. Need I say more?
3. Julian - He's a unicorn. And he's smug. His house is AMAZING.
2. Diana - Originally thinking about adopting her out (still might) but I love her design and Snooty is my favorite personality. I just have so many snooties I want in my town
1. Whitney - My favorite species (wolf), my favorite personality (snooty) and she's absolutely gorgeous! My first wolf in NH so she's special to me.

 

[Pixiebelle]

So far:

6. Lopez only because he's just moved in. forced smug camper so could be much worse
5. Mac starter. don't hate him but nor do I care about his muscles
4. Agnes starter. ehh. she's okay? tied with Mac, placed higher because she's not a jock
3. Jeremiah so sweet when he sings omg
2. Maple lil cutie. also quick to forgive after I accidentally hit her with my net lol
1. Flora FLAMINGO. LOVE HER. won't ever be letting her go

8. Snooty left it too long before inviting someone else. go away
7. Lopez looks nice. says nothing. move out whenever x
6. Mac grown on me slightly but can still go
5. Agnes ^ same
4. Jeremiah shut up about bugs
3. Maple fine
2. Octavian octopi are my favs so
1. Flora still my girl

 

[Zura]

Currently rn without adding/removing any of my dreamies.

10. Stu this guy is legit creepy asf. Told me multiple times that he stalks my house and that he has "bug" friends that he "talks" to regularly
9. Coach ehhhhh don't really care for him but I guess he's alright because he reminds me of my old FB coach
8. June this girl joined my island pretty early on and has refused to leave. I dont have any real problem with her but dam do I want her gone asap
7. Sproket is a robot which makes him a little cooler than the rest but I really hate his design. Also, he is a jock and they're super annoying (Especially because he's a robot jock talking about nonexistent muscles 24/7)
6. Vivan sorta middle ground for me considering I don't really like her and I don't hate her. She's got an older lady vibe to her but not much else.
5. Lopez same with Vivian and I really have nothing wrong with the dude but I also don't care for him
4. Mira is a pretty cool superhero rabbit with a mask and everything. I really like the star on her head because it makes me think of JJBA
3. Ribbot freaking legend! Im just gonna throw out everything I said about Sproket because come on, it's Ribbot! He has an amazing house and his design is amazing. So much to love about this guy.
2. Agent S my girl from NL! She was my NL best friend and as luck would have it, she's currently in my town. BLAST FROM THE PAST!
1. Tabby the queen among mortals. She is gorgeous and my new best friend! Id hates to say she takes Agent S's place at least just in this game experience. Tabby gets so much hate for absolutely nothing and I think she is amazing. nough said

 

[nerfeddude]

Well, why not?

10. Billy. I don't have anything against him, but he's my jock starter with extremely boring house, so I want him to move out
9. Winnie. Same here - starter peppy villager, boring house, want her to move out. But I like peppy villagers more than jock sooo she's not at the very bottom
8. Beau. Now I realise how unlucky I am. I love Beau, he's an adorable boy. But he's a lazy starter with dirt floor in his house...
7. Bettina. She was my first non-storyline camper so I used this opportunity to replace any of my starters(and it happens to be my uchi starter Diva). She's okay I guess... Just not a big fan of her species
6. Robin. I don't have much to say about her. She likes to make fun of my clothes
5. Octavian. I really wanted a cranky villager and I ended up finding Octavian on my last mystery island trip before an empty plot could randomly sell itself(I ran out of nook miles at that time). I don't really like an octopus villagers but he's slowly growing on me
4. Iggly. I like penguins. And he's a jock penguin. This is just lovely when he talks about his musles while being a chubby boi
3. Olaf. I don't like anteaters that much but Olaf stands out to me. He's both cool and cute. I didn't liked him at first(he's my storyline-forced camper) but now I adore him and his style. Also he looks like he's wearing pants. And he likes to talk about pants. Huh
2. Katt. I don't care what others think she's ugly. Katt is my baby! I encountered her for the first time in a mystery tour while looking for a cranky villager(I ended up finding Octavian lol). But I skipped her. Long story short - my last empty plot was randomly sold to her. And now she's one of my faves. Katt was the first villager I saw dancing and singing. She's doing it anywere - in my orchad, on the beach, at the plaza. And sometimes I see others joining her. Literally yesterday I for solid 15 minutes watched Katt, Winnie and Purrl singing together at the plaza. That was wholesome
1. Purrl. Ironically, I got Purrl the same way as Katt - an empty plot just became her house without my influence. Sometimes I doubt she's a snooty. Purrl is just so sweet and nice to me. I love how she looks. Plus I love her house interior. She's mocking other villagers for literally any reason. How she cannot be the number one?

 

[DarkSlayer1331]

Hippeux is moving out, so I'm not going to rank him. Now with him out of the way, let's get to ranking the rest of my villagers!
9. Groucho - Seriously, this guy has got to be the epitome of horribleness in a cranky villager. I cannot stand him and I want him gone.
8. Soleil - Honestly, she's not the absolute worst, but I'm really not fond of her. Her snooty self comes off so uppity I kinda want to put her on a wheel and make her run on it for the rest of her life.
7. Canberra - Really not that bad, but I don't like her as much as I like most of my other villagers. Very much a "meh" from me.
6. Rex - This guy is not bad by any means. I kind of like him, but we're not as good of friends as I'd like to be with my villagers.
5. Marina - I know a lot of people absolutely love her, and she is adorable. But I had her in NL and wasn't completely smitten with her there either.
4. Lobo - Given more time, this guy would probably climb the ladder a couple more spots. I love wolves, but he's my newest villager, so I haven't had quite as much time with him as with the others.
3. Coach - One of my originals, and he's a pretty cool bull! I didn't think I would like him, but he's pretty swell. Love having him!
2. Merry - She's only ahead of Coach because she's always just so dang happy to see me! Absolutely adorable! I love her so much!
1. Katt - This one really surprises me. She's my other original and as soon as I saw her I wanted to bash my head into the table. But as it turns out, she's a real sweetheart! And with the cute skirt/shirt combo outfit thing that I gave her, she's even more adorable!

 

[raqball]

Tough as I have a few that are my #1... I'll break mine down into groupings instead of rankings.

Might swap at some point / maybe not as she could easily be in the Staying group
Daisy

Staying on my Island but not close to the 1st or 2nd groupings
Twiggy
Ribbot
Raymond

My second favorite group. Both are close to # 1 rankings
Lily
Molly

All probably tied at #1
Zucker
Ozzie
Lolly
Marina

 

[eminyan]

I love all my villagers wholeheartedly but if I had to rank-

10. Ellie - An absolute sweetie! I love her so much and she's like a mom to me! She always has such nice taste in clothes and gives me super cute gifts! Wish she saved more confidence for herself because she's so pretty.

9. Apple - A darling and I support her dreams of becoming an ultra-famous and star. I know she can do it.

8. Stitches - He's so cute I literally love him so much. Wish he wore the dress I got for him more doe...

7. Rex - So so sweet. I love his letters so much and how kind he is! I regretted having him in the beginning, but I've come to appreciate him much much more.

6. Tammy - I wasn't that big of a fan of her at first- she looked alright but nothing amazing. She didn't even like me that much at first! But after a month of playing, she always sends me letters and I always feel warm reading them. She's so kind and I'm glad I kept her.

5. Deena - Listen, I thought this duck looked moldy at first but I've come to see her charms, her care and concerns for me, how cute she is in glasses, and how timid she can be so I totally love her now. She looks adorable in the detective coat.

4. Judy - I fell in love with her colors at the very beginning! She was cute, but that was all there was to it. I even planned to sell her later on. But seeing how big sisterly she's like and how cute she is I'm definitely keeping her! She's such a sweetie.

3. Pietro - My son... my son!!!! His letters about appreciating me is so overwhelming and I love em so much. I cried out when I got him in campsite at first but now? I am so sorry for disliking you babie boo... He's so sweet and I don't care if you dislike his looks you have to give his kindness a chance.

2. Raymond - What is there to explain... He's awfully cute... seemingly professional... a sweetie... lowkey attractive as a gjinka... heterochromatic eyes... I love him!! At first, I didn't catch onto why people wanted him so much. Sure, he was cute- sure, he had glasses- sure, mans looked cool but that was it. Then I saw the fanart.
And that is how I fell in love with some dumb cat and poured hours of stress into getting him. (he's so cute on the pet bed with his vampire costume I SWEAR)

1. Marshal - breathes... it's... it's my babie. He's so so so so so so so so so so so so cute... what is there to say...? I fell in love with his design and realized he was a must have in ACNH. He's super sweet with a touch of arrogance but come on, he's so fantastic that if I were him I'd boast too. I miss him dearly and he looks great with the grey octagonal glasses... and the young royal top... or kindergarten shirt... He's so cute

 

[senbeiiscool]

This is going to be so tough but I'll try, I love all my villagers though so any of these could change easily

10. Audie - The newest addition to my island, I haven't really befriended her yet but I'm really excited to. Agent S was my old peppy and I really wanted to keep her, but her not original house made me let her go. Hopefully Audie will fill her spot!
9. Beau - My next newest villager, waiting to be better friends. Super adorable.
8. Julian - I actually like him a lot! But the smug personality isn't my favourite in NH. I can totally see why he's a fan favourite
7. Pierce - My birthday buddy! He was one of my OG villagers in NL and my favourite jock! The only reason he isn't higher is because he only moved in recently and we're still getting to be friends! Waiting for him to call me brosephine like old times~
6. Fang - I've got a bunch of crankies and Fang is the "newest" on my island. He's an old man that loves to read and super sweet! Could easily swap places with #5
5. Lily - Lily I've really grown to love! I originally had Poppy, but I promised her to a friend so I got Lily as another normal. On her first day she pissed off Roscoe and I was determined to kick her out. But while TT to cycle out villagers, I accidentally landed on Roscoe's bday. Who was there to celebrate with him? Lily! They've also sent gifts and stuff to each other so I think they're friends now!
4. Roscoe - I told this story already on the forum, but TLDR I was looking for a cranky (mostly Chief) and I used a bunch of NMT looking for one. It was pouring rain on my island and the NM Island so when I finally met him, all I could see was glowing red eyes. I decided to take him as my "demon horse" to counter all the cute villagers on my island. I really grew to love him! He's still hard to see at night, but he's not scary (anymore haha)!
3. Vivian - Honestly, of all my villagers, I feel like I've bonded with Vivian the most! I feel bad though because I didn't really understand her at the beginning when I had her and gifted her some stuff that looks horrible at her home, thinking that she would like it. I'm trying to get her to swap stuff out but it's a long process
2. Marshal - My AC love from NL (along with Pierce). He's so cute, adorable and loves to sing. He's a little different from the Marshal I remember in NL though (his sloppy furniture vs nicely kept cafe). He would probably take the #1 spot if I enjoyed the way the wrote smugs more in this game. Could easily change with #1
1. Chief - My only dreamie that I didn't have in NL. Along with Roscoe, he was my first 2 crankies. I learned that cranky is my absolute favourite personality type in this game too! Also a singer

 

[Yoshisaur]

10. Cheri I like her just fine but she's boring compared to my other villagers. She replaced some ugly hippo I hated.

9. Reneigh Similar to Cheri I don't dislike her- she's just not interesting to me

8. Goldie I don't like dogs very much irl. She's very cute but not overly special to me.

7. Merengue She looks SUPER cute but isn't the type of personality I prefer.

6. Stitches I really like him I just think his house is ugly.

5. Skye I like that she's blue! Also she's a cute wolf. What more can I say?

4. Rosie She has a wonderful personality and I quite like the cats. Her cute interior on her house is great!

3. Ankha I have just received her. I already really like her personality and her home. I think she will stay in my top 3.

2. Peanut She is so cute. I love her. Did I mention she is cute? Right before I got offline she told me she likes to run in circles and scream to wake herself up in the mornings. ADORABLE! She is usually my #1.

1. Octavian Octavian moved in today. Peanut will probably dethrone him but we will see. I've ranked him so high because he has an entire UFO & alien in his house. LOL

 

[Snek]

10. Fuchsia - She may be a deer villager but I really hate that purple. Also, I already have an Uchi that I like. I really really want her in boxes.

9. Benedict - The chicken villagers in this game are strange. They always run around and it gets annoying after awhile.

8. Boone - Not a fan of ape and monkey villagers but he was one of my starting two so he is tolerable.

7. Norma - She is too normal for me. Her villager personality and name suit her.

6. Vic - His viking theme is pretty cool but thats about it

5. Tangy - My native fruit is the orange so its just natural that she would be on my island. The preppy villagers in this game are adorable.

4. Lucha - I like his masked wrestler theme. He gives me a lot of good items too.

3. Blanche - I love her! She gives me the best recipes. I lot of them gold items so I want to keep her around. I love her Japanese crane theme and I really want her kimono haha.

2. Erik - Just adorable. A moose villager with a winter theme. His furniture is amazing. I really can't wait for winter! Just absolute perfect.

1. Phoebe - My phoenix villager from New Leaf! I celebrated her birthday today. I got her an imperial screen and she loved it! Her house is really cool with the lava floor and volcano wall.

 

[nikachu]

1. Blanche -

She really surprised me, she moved in on her own accord as villager #5 and I loved her ever since. Her snootiness, amazing sense of fashion, and overall elegance makes me jealous of her and want to know what she's doing at all times.
2. Apple -

What a fun pick. I got her on accident and haven't looked back since. I don't know whats going on in this person's brain. She wants to be a superstar, but in a lazy, sleazy way. The other day she was sick and sent the whole town into hysteria. I thought she was dying the way she was acting and the way people were overreacting about her. It was so much fun.
3. Zucker

He will very likely end up being my #1, but I just had him move in today and he is still unpacking so I haven't been able to experience him just yet. I fought really hard to get him, he was #1 on my list of villagers I want and I am so happy I finally have him and see him develop on my island.
4. Pom Pom

Two weeks ago I had a horrible copyright issue with my youtube channel involving a clip with pompom. It was a bit part of my own fault and I felt very embarrassed by it. The day the issue was resolved and the copyright strike went away, I was so relieved. I went on animal crossing and bought a ticket to an island, and BAM! Pom Pom was there. Full circle moment, and she is so much fun I love her.
5. Shari

She was my first villager and has been like a big sister to me. She asked me to leave last week and I nearly cried. Although she isn't my favorite, I don't think could ever get rid of me, she is as much a vet on my island as me and tom nook are. We've been through everything together and she is my rock.
6. Sylvana

I did not really want Sylvana when I saw her at first, but she was villager #4 and at that point in the game I desperately wanted more and more villagers, so sylvana came over. I don't dislike her at any point. That's her biggest plus. She has never annoyed me or made me question her at all. She is very sweet.
7. Broccolo

Broccolo is a weird guy. All he cares about is food and smells, he's a big weirdo. He was my 3rd villager, and honestly, I can't think of a world without him either. His weirdness is a constant laugh for me, although it does get a bit old.
8. BlueBear

Here's the thing with BlueBear. Bluebear is one of my favorite villagers of all time and if she came in my island naturally and near the beginning, I could see her being top 3. I really did not like one of my villagers, so I used my bluebear amiibo card to evict him and have bluebear come in. Little did I know Bluebear would be my 4th peppy personality. Having my entire island talk about how they want to be famous has started to turn stale and a turn off for me. While Bluebear was one of my favorite villagers for new leaf, and still is one of my favorites, timing and competition has made the return of bluebear,who was my 10th guest, underwhelming. I can see her rising,especially when Bubbles leaves and there's only 3 peppy villagers, but for now she hasn't given me anything unique.

9. Keaton

Keaton is pretty loved and his design is awesome, with that said his personality has been so dry on my island and Im definitely ready to see him go. I recently put fences around his house. I don't know why, we just haven't click

10. Bubbles

I loved Bubbles at first. We talked all day and she told me she wanted to be best friends forever. But her personality fell like a brick since her first day. She never is really out and about, and now that I have FOUR peppy villagers, the peppy personality is starting to get on my nerves and I really need a peppy villager to go, and she is the first to be booted.


And there you go. My extremely intensive ratings of my Animal Crossing Villagers. I am very invested in the game and how it is shaping up and I can't wait to see what happens to my island in the future. As of right now, I am actively looking for Keaton and Bubbles to leave. I wouldn't say no to Sylvana and Broccolo leaving. The rest I'd keep for now.

 

[chibski]

1. Olive - complete random island pickup and I fell in love with her, literally the sweetest thing

2. Fuchsia - one of my OGs, didn't like her at first but she's grown on me so much, constantly sending me letters and running around the plaza

3. Rex - another random island pickup, he's hilarious and always talking about food, always gives me medicine when I need it

4. Phil - my first camper, couldn't stand him at first but his smugness is the funniest thing and I've come to adore him

5. Kid Cat - the other OG, not a big fan of the sporty personality but he's chill

6. Static - the cutest lil grumpy thing

7. Roscoe - just got him so don't have much to judge but I love his aesthetic

8. Caroline - thought she was cute so I picked her up but honestly she's pretty bland

9. Bangles - accidentally invited her when I didn't know any better, she's obnoxious

10. Anchovy - moved in without permission from a friend's island, he's disgusting and I want him in boxes

 

[Tako]

1. Marshal
   He has been my favorite since New Leaf, and that has never changed. In fact, I think I love him all the more now that he sings so much on my island. <3
   
   
2. Molly
   Molly, Molly, Molly... I don't think I've come across anyone who doesn't love her yet. She's easily one of the cutest villagers out there, and she's just so sweet! I'm always looking forward to talking to her everyday.
   
   
3. Maple
   Maple grew on me after she moved onto my island. I found her on a mystery island tour when I first started playing, and invited her to stay since she was cute. But as I got to know her better, I've started to realize just how caring and sweet she is.
   
   
4. Clay
   The newest addition to my island! He just moved in two days ago, and I already love him because my island tune sounds amazing when I talk to him. I haven't had much time to interact with him yet, but I think I would want to keep him on my island for as long as I can!
   
   
5. Zucker
   Zucker has always been a dreamy of mine, but I'm gonna have to put him at #5, simply because he talks about bugs too much. I found it endearing at first, but almost every single conversation with him is about the bugs under his floor, or his bug friends, and it's just... too much. lol
   
   
6. Vesta
   Vesta is sweet! I love how different she looks compared to the other sheep villagers. And I think she's easily more expressive too, because it's so easy to put expression on her. :'D
   
   
7. Lily
   Lily is cute, but not a favorite. For some reason I like to troll her. A lot. Ever since she moved into my island, I've been gifting her tadpoles and frog hats, and she's always super happy to accept and display them in her home.
   
   
8. Ozzie
   Again with the bugs. Sadly, he's not super cute to me so I probably wouldn't keep him if he decided to move out. I would trade him for Melba in a heartbeat though!
   
   
9. Cyd
   He's cool, and I like his house interior. Sadly, it doesn't really fall under the list of aesthetics I'm into so he's pretty low on the list.
   
   
10. Olaf
    Uhhh. No. I'm sorry, but I'm just not into his design, or his house.

 

[skogkyst]

Updated ranking:

10. Agent S
9. Marina
8. Cherry
7. Octavian
6. Huck
5. Blanche
4. Bill
3. Zucker
2. Bruce
1. Fauna

About two weeks later, I was going to once again update my rankings when I realized they hadn't changed much

It does get harder to rank villagers over time, though. Perhaps I would switch Blanche, Bill, and Zucker around a little, but overall I like all my villagers and the more I get to know them the harder it is to place one about the others.

 

[lieryl]

my island is really basic but here we go!

10. Maple - nothing wrong with her in particular, found her on an island and said why not, but normal personalities are so boring to me which is a shame because they have some of the cutest villagers. wouldn’t miss her if she moved away

9. Reneigh - her design is cute and she was one of my starters but for some reason i’m just not clicking with her :,( i don’t have an urge to run and talk to her at least once a day when i see her around and idk why

8. Chief - i love cranky villagers but i never see chief around? like every time i decide to play he’s nowhere to be found?? i hope he shows himself more so i can talk to him because i love cranky villager dialogue. i did catch him singing once and it was the cutest thing so chief please show yourself more

7. Diana - she’s another personality type that i love and i also found her on a mystery island. she compliments my outfits and i feel really validated every time i talk to her lol. she’s chill but i don’t feel overly excited every time she like pings me or something

6. Beau - oh gosh he’s just so cute. he’s always looking at flowers with a magnifying glass and then he will pull out a book and study the plants. i put flowers in front of his house and he waters them everyday. my taste is basic but he’s for sure one of my favorite lazy villagers!

5. Julian - one of my starters in NL and will always have a spot in my heart. will probably be keeping him on my island forever no questions. and not to mention his room is gorgeous and he repeatedly wears everything i give him ^_^

4. Sherb - another flower enthusiast on my island and i love him so much oh lord he’s always at home and talking about his bugs and honestly i can relate man. his catchphrase is also so cute i think i almost cried when i first talked to him. we like to sit on benches together and just vibe so he’s definitely one of my favorites :,)

3. Marshal - i got his amiibo card years ago and never really thought much of it. i was really surprised to find he is as popular as he is. he’s been in and out of my island (i’ve been giving him away and then scanning him back in cause i missed his dumb face lol). didn’t think he was gonna be a permanent resident on my island but i changed my mind T^T every time he’s on my island he sings and does stupid exercises and has dumb dialogue with other villagers and i love him for it. might still give him away a few more times so people can experience the package that is Marshal lmao

2. Raymond - ngl i only wanted him because he was really popular, but he grew on me man. he will wear anything i give him, he sings with Marshal, and wears glasses. what more could you want?? i go out of my way to talk to him because i like seeing his fangs when he smiles and he reminds me of the kindness that’s still in the community because i got him for basically nothing

1. Dom - if you told me that this pink jock villager sheep dude would be my number one i would’ve have laughed in your face. would never expect him to be a jock but i got him in a trade because i needed a jock and he looked really fluffy. as i talked to him more i fell in love with his earnest love for working out and his adorable facial expressions. he’s so cute no matter what face he makes?? i don’t understand?? and when he’s lifting weights it’s actually the cutest thing. i find myself spamming his dialogue just to see his eyes move istg. would 10/10 die for this sheep

 

[mitfy]

just kind of throwing this together... not sure how accurate it is cuz a lot of my villagers im sort of neutral on

10. gigi. didnt even give me time to find someone to put in that plot
9. soleil. also didnt ask for her, but i ended up really liking her interior house and her personality is nice
8. gayle. i love her design but i'm not super close to her.
7. katt. i Love uchi villagers but i would probably prefer a different one
6. coach. i also Love jocks and he's ended up becoming my best friend, but i still would probably prefer other jocks
5. tangy. i like her n apparently shes rly popular but im sorta neutral
4. kyle. hes cool.
3. stitches. he was the first villager i saw on an island and im happy to have gotten him so soon, first time ive had him too!
2. avery. he was a first in my new leaf town and i love him.
1. bob. he's really cute and fun and i didn't know much about him other than him being a meme, but since he got on my island i've really grown fond of him for his personality.

 

[Danoa]

10. Roscoe - A random move in that decided to glitch so at this time I don't like him because I can't even talk to him.
9. Drake - Don't hate him, but I don't love him either. He's just kinda there.
8. Chadder - I like his look and name because I think they're funny, but talking with him just isn't really enjoyable.
7. Friga - She's not been on my island to long so I feel I haven't really gotten to know her to well, but so far I've enjoyed her more than Drake and Chadder.
6. Samson - He's okay.
5. Cyd - Love his look, but compared to my other cranky he is sorely lacking.
4. Peanut - Like her a lot more than I originally thought I would. Would be better if she didn't have the default peppy house. It was also funny when she got fleas and then denied it. lol
3. Skye - She maybe would have beat Marina or at least tied if she wasn't my first normal and her house wasn't the default.
2. Marina - She's adorable and I love her house too.
1. Walt - Color me surprised. I wasn't sure if I'd like Walt or not when I invited him, but I have absolutely loved having him. At this time I have no intention of letting him move out. I love his house, his clothes, and his dialogue. I only invited him because I kind of wanted a kangaroo and I don't like the female ones. The little ones in the pouches are kinda creepy to me. Plus I feel like they should be named unless they're not real, in which case that makes it creepier because they emote when the big one does. I feel like I'm going down a rabbit hole or should I say a kangaroos pouch, so I'm going to stop there.

New villagers so updated list!
10. Drake - Lower spot, but my feelings are the same as before.
9. Chadder - Lower spot, but my feelings are the same as before.
8. Ursala - Just moved in today, but I think she is cute. We'll see if I end up liking her more or not.
7. Friga - I've gotten to know her better and I like her okay, but she hasn't went up or down. Her shirt is kinda blech though. Doesn't suit her. I thought it'd grow on me, but it hasn't.
6. Samson - I kinda like him better, but not enough to move him higher up on my list.
5. Drago - Fairly new resident so I haven't gotten to really know him yet. Love his design and house though!
4. Skye - Switched spots with Peanut. Still really love her though.
3. Peanut - I kinda like her better than Skye now. Still really like her and I loved her comment when she gave me the mistaken reaction. One of the best conversations I've had with a villager so far. Still think she needs her actual interior though. She also needs to stop talking about maglevs when crafting, but at least she crafts for me!
2. Marina - Still number 2!
1. Walt - Still number 1!

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

10. Apple - Oh Apple, she's so dense. She was a random move in the day I wanted to go island hopping. I've tried gifting her hamster cages, toliets, poop hat, caging off her and she's still here. I'm afraid I've gotten attached to hating her.

9. Slyvia - In my original two (or does her baby count?) villagers. She's alright, but a bit rude sometimes. She's like the island's resident hippie that never bathes.

8. Antonio - In my first two villagers. I like him and his design, but his personality is kind of bland. He's almost interchangeable with any other jock.

7. Stitches - I never really got his popularity until I saw him in this game. I think the updated textures work well in giving him a more 'plushie' look. He's always reminding me he can move and buy the fleas I catch on other villagers. He might be a cursed teddy bear.

6. Julian - He has a unique design and house. He likes to walk around flaunting his shopping bags. He might be a bit too boujee for my island though.

5. Cole - A cool little rabbit guy. Always looks surprised to see everything. He shares a name with a family member of mine, maybe thats why I like him more

4. Apollo - Just a cool dude. I like his retro house.

3. Marina - Never had her until this game, always wanted her. She's just a reverse mermaid trying to live her life on land. I like finding adorable outfits for her to dress up in~

2. Vivian - Vivian really grew on me. I know she uses the wolf model, but I'm pretty sure she's a german shepard. She also calls me her best friend on the island.

1. Static- He was in my Wild World town, so I was surpised when he was a random move-in on my new island. I like his style, his colors, design, everything. He loves singing in his deep man voice which is hilarous.

Other villagers:
O'Hare - Had a good house design and personality just didn't see him around much
Peaches - Similar to Stitches, I think she's supposed to be a plush? I liked her but wish her colors were more pastel
Peggy - Unexpectedly adorable, probably should of kept her instead of Apple
Brococlo - Didn't care for his design previously, but he was okay

 

[BellBrokeGirl]

if Maple decides to move and you don’t want her anymore lmk!

Post automatically merged: Apr 27, 2020

if Maple decides to move and you don’t want her anymore lmk!

my island is really basic but here we go!

10. Maple - nothing wrong with her in particular, found her on an island and said why not, but normal personalities are so boring to me which is a shame because they have some of the cutest villagers. wouldn’t miss her if she moved away

9. Reneigh - her design is cute and she was one of my starters but for some reason i’m just not clicking with her :,( i don’t have an urge to run and talk to her at least once a day when i see her around and idk why

8. Chief - i love cranky villagers but i never see chief around? like every time i decide to play he’s nowhere to be found?? i hope he shows himself more so i can talk to him because i love cranky villager dialogue. i did catch him singing once and it was the cutest thing so chief please show yourself more

7. Diana - she’s another personality type that i love and i also found her on a mystery island. she compliments my outfits and i feel really validated every time i talk to her lol. she’s chill but i don’t feel overly excited every time she like pings me or something

6. Beau - oh gosh he’s just so cute. he’s always looking at flowers with a magnifying glass and then he will pull out a book and study the plants. i put flowers in front of his house and he waters them everyday. my taste is basic but he’s for sure one of my favorite lazy villagers!

5. Julian - one of my starters in NL and will always have a spot in my heart. will probably be keeping him on my island forever no questions. and not to mention his room is gorgeous and he repeatedly wears everything i give him ^_^

4. Sherb - another flower enthusiast on my island and i love him so much oh lord he’s always at home and talking about his bugs and honestly i can relate man. his catchphrase is also so cute i think i almost cried when i first talked to him. we like to sit on benches together and just vibe so he’s definitely one of my favorites :,)

3. Marshal - i got his amiibo card years ago and never really thought much of it. i was really surprised to find he is as popular as he is. he’s been in and out of my island (i’ve been giving him away and then scanning him back in cause i missed his dumb face lol). didn’t think he was gonna be a permanent resident on my island but i changed my mind T^T every time he’s on my island he sings and does stupid exercises and has dumb dialogue with other villagers and i love him for it. might still give him away a few more times so people can experience the package that is Marshal lmao

2. Raymond - ngl i only wanted him because he was really popular, but he grew on me man. he will wear anything i give him, he sings with Marshal, and wears glasses. what more could you want?? i go out of my way to talk to him because i like seeing his fangs when he smiles and he reminds me of the kindness that’s still in the community because i got him for basically nothing

1. Dom - if you told me that this pink jock villager sheep dude would be my number one i would’ve have laughed in your face. would never expect him to be a jock but i got him in a trade because i needed a jock and he looked really fluffy. as i talked to him more i fell in love with his earnest love for working out and his adorable facial expressions. he’s so cute no matter what face he makes?? i don’t understand?? and when he’s lifting weights it’s actually the cutest thing. i find myself spamming his dialogue just to see his eyes move istg. would 10/10 die for this sheep

if maple moves out lmk we can trade something!

 

[Daisies]

10) Soleil - I don’t really dislike her but she doesn’t really bring anything to my island other that being my only snooty personality type (I’d rather have Portia or Opal aha)

9) Gladys - she was my first nook Miles islander and I invited her because I liked the idea of having an ostrich, she’s ok but not my favourite and I wouldn’t be devastated if she moved out.

8) Kevin - I’m very conflicted about Kevin’s placement as he’s my only remaining original, he’s my most frequent naruto runner which never fails to amuse me- I still like him but once again, not one of my favourites

7) Fuschia - I like her design (I love pink villagers and I love her piercings) however I don’t really have a connection with her tbh. As uchi villagers go (I find the personality type bland) she’s probably one of the best though

6) Flurry - SUCH a cute hamster honestly, I scanned her in via amiibo but if I come across Kiki she’ll probably be replaced (IM SORRY)- Kiki Is my preferred normal villager

5) Marina - She absolutley adorable and so unique and we’ve got on well, I don’t seem to have the same connected that others seem to have with her though

4) Filbert - I love squirrels and he has the cutest design, he’s also a lazy villager type which is my favourite male personality and he just fits so well with my other villagers!

3) Henry - Frogs are my favourite animal species and he’s always really friendly- he was my first camper and I was so relived when I saw him- I’ve moved him next to my other frog villager and they are such a cute duo!

2) Pinky - a pink, peppy villager! What a surprise! I saw her on a nook Miles tour and invited her thinking it would be temporary! But I’ve grown so attached to her and she was my first ‘best friend’ status on the island so I don’t think I’ll be replacing her with peanut (who i originally planned to have) after all

1) Puddles! - I haven’t seen much love for this adorable frog but she’s just so friendly and My absolute favourite villager ever! I’ve had her since wild world in every game and an animal crossing game just wouldn’t feel the same without her!