Rank Your Villagers!

10. Alice ( cute design but all normals are boring personality for me)
9. Reneigh ( cute design but too rude for me)
8. Opal ( snooties no longer sassy, just old aunts but nice design)
7.Pierce ( jock, don't care for him)
6. Drago ( interesting design but we haven't clicked yet)
5. Barold ( I laughed for 10 mins when I saw his design. Hope he stays!)
4. Admiral ( love him, grumpy like real life birds)
3. Zucker (favorite lazy, just love this guy. yesterday he went pretty meta with the game and complained)
2. Chadder (loved in from new leaf, I'm glad he is back here! Favorite and only smug allowed on my island)
1. Nibbles (Favorite peppy villiger, first day she moved in, she had some funny dialogue that gave her backstory)
 
10. Rocket (annoying and ugly)
9. Sheldon (he's okay but I could use his villager spot for someone better)
8. Bluebear
7. Goldie
These 4 I want them to leave so I can get better villagers. From 6 to 1 are all dreamies I bought online from players.
6. Zucker
5. Merengue
4. Marshal
3. Stitches
2. Pietro
1. Julian (love how he's ALWAYS singing, way more than my other smug villagers. His house's furniture is also amazing)
 
1. Sprinkle
2. Midge The cutest of any of my villagers.

3. Butch Toss up between Cherry and Butch. Butch wins slightly because of his personality. A singer and I think that's adorable.
4. Cherry Starting uchi and a singer

5. Jitters Starting jock. A sweetheart who loves to seem to give me presents.

6. Fuchsia I feel like she would be higher up, but she stays inside a lot. I've noticed that she likes to sing by herself when she does go out. Sometimes she walks into fences, so I wonder if she's glitched.
7. Apple So cute, but Sprinkle is my main peppy villager so all others seem kind of... meh. It's adorable when she does yoga though.

8. Mallory Recent move in. I forget she exists.

9. Anicotti She was my first MIT invite, but I feel like it's time for her to go. It does get annoying having so many peppy villagers.
10. Lionel Please leave. (It's not that I -hate- him. I just really want him to leave.)
 
Last edited:
10.) Pietro (don't have anything against him, I just don't feel anything for him)
9. )Graham (similar to Pietro)


8.) Flora (I like the peppy personality more in this game, but still not my favorite)
7.) Midge (I like her, but I have 2 other normals, so I end up talking to them more)
6.) Piper (She's alright. She's really cute, and I would definitely prefer it she was my only peppy. 1 peppy is enough. Also, she seems to love getting in my way when I'm pathing and terraforming)


5.) Nana (Nana's a cutie, though I haven't had the chance to speak to her more)
4.) Zell (hard to decide if he should be 4 or 3, but he's cool. He's house is dope, and I love giving him hipster and hypebeast clothes. He looks cool in it)
3.) Pashmina (She's one of my starters and we're like besties, though she seems to get tired of talking way too easily)

2.) Fauna (Anytime I see her, I have to speak to her. She a cutie and so chill (though she can be anxious at times))

1.) Sherb (honestly it's kinda hard putting Sherb on his own tier, I want to add Fauna, but Sherb is like my best friend and I don't think me a Fauna have gotten there yet. I run to him anytime I see him. He somehow always manages to give me gifts that I actually like. He also always seems to know just what to say. He's just an all-around cutie)
 
10. Annabelle: LEAVE - came from someone's void halfway through trading for Clay and oh my god GET OUT
9. Ozzie: dialogue's kinda meh. I don't want to hear about the bugs in the floor anymore ; = ;
8. Sprinkles: I don't love peppy but I guess she's cute
7. Katt: Nothing bad to say. Her and Wolfgang have really nice dialogue
6. Megan: She's okay.
5. Kyle: I desperately need more instruments to gift to this boy
4. Poncho: SMOL JOCK BOI
3. Wolfgang: I love my crankys
2. Judy: finally friends with her and she's so sweet and shady at the same time I love it
1. Murphy: he's such an old grump I love him
 
10: Bruce (dislike his design and I already have so many cranky villagers)
9: Boyd (Is not Peewee)
8: Maggie (very plain, nothing interesting to say)
7: Stitches (I know he is fan favorite but his eyes weird me out)
6: Sally (just moved in but was my OG back in AN:GC)
5: Graham (a bit weird but he adores the bath towel I gave him)
4: Tipper (pretty nice, seems to have a "thing" for Coach)
3: Coach (disliked him at first but hes grown on me)
2: Sprinkle (looks like ice cream and a penguin? Awesome)
1: Fang (spends all his time eating sandwiches 10/10 can relate)
 
10. Chops - I hate him. I’m planning to replace him with Kyle through amiibo in the next few days
9. Del - Not a fan, I don’t really like most of the crocodiles
8. Ellie - I like Ellie she’s super cute. Won’t be keeping her forever but I do like her
7. Alice - i think Alice is super cute, though she isn’t one of my dreamies I always wanted her in new leaf so when I found her on am island tour I invited her
6. Beau - I like lazy villagers and he’s cute, though his design isn’t my favourite. Got him from an amiibo card
5. Bunnie - she was my third villager, found her on my first nook mile tour
4. Genji - Genji was one of my starter villagers and I love him. I won’t be letting him move at least for a good while
3. Drago - I love drago!! He was one of my first five villagers and I think his design is really cool
2. Zell - just got him today!! Bought a bunch of nook mile tickets to island hop and find a dreamie and he was the first one that showed up!
1. Chief - I love him!! I like cranky villagers and I love wolf villagers, I want fang and lobo too <3
 
Carmen: love her. she is in my pocket camp as well
Cheri: she isnt bad but if she asks to leave she can
Renee: dont mind her really
Rex: he is alright but i like other lazys better
Eunice: not my favorite normal but not bad
o'hare: eh. no opinion really. game forced me to let him move in
 
I'm still cycling but right now:

10. Lily: Cute, but not as cute as Gladys or Flurry, and one of three normals. Just kinda... boring. I know people love her and I'm very lucky to have her as my "worst", but she just doesn't quite mesh well. Got her from a mystery island, will be swapping out for Weber (the single most underrated villager).
9. Gladys: Very cute, but one of three normals and has a redundant aesthetic with Genji. Will be kicking for Bruce. Got her on a mystery island.
8. Genji: No jock was gonna score high for me, but Genji's one of the stronger picks. Might climb after I can change his mochi catchphrase back to his old one: otaku. Card from a pack booted Cousteau (who was nearly as cool but had a crappy starter house).
7. Audie: Up for auction right now. She's great, but I like Tangy a little more personally, and friend whose island I visit every day has her, I have another wolf on the docket (Freya), and since I got her from an early mystery island, she doesn't have her true house for me.
6. Flurry: Sickeningly adorable snow hamster. I love her, but her house is eh. Mystery island get. She's staying but I might have to do some shenanigans to get her good house.
5. Tangy: A total SPAZ, super cute, fruit theme is unique. Card from a pack, booted Tom.
4. Raymond: This guy's been growing on me. Didn't really get the hype after he joined after showing up as my second natural campsite villager, but after someone recontextualized him as Thin White Duke-era Bowie, I can't help but see it: really classy looking while still having his visual eccentricities, and he's SUPER WEIRD. Dude eats sandwiches in front of the bridge at 10PM, naked ass on the terracotta roads. Brilliant.
3. Static: Cranky voice coming out of a squirrel is funny as hell, plus purple and yellow is a sick color combo and I'm a music guy so Static's a bro. Underrated, like this guy WAY more than Marshal. Adopted from a friend after Hugh left.
2. Ankha: Adorable Egytian princess kitty. Got her card in a pack, booted Hazel for her.
1. Julian: The king of Aria Bay. Flamboyant weirdo and the glue that holds all the relationships together. Was my mandatory campsite villager: wicked luck.
 
So far:

6. Lopez only because he's just moved in. forced smug camper so could be much worse
5. Mac starter. don't hate him but nor do I care about his muscles
4. Agnes starter. ehh. she's okay? tied with Mac, placed higher because she's not a jock
3. Jeremiah so sweet when he sings omg
2. Maple lil cutie. also quick to forgive after I accidentally hit her with my net lol
1. Flora FLAMINGO. LOVE HER. won't ever be letting her go
 
10. Axel. One of my original villagers. He's alright, he's cute enough, but man... jocks are annoying. He's also rather boring compared to a lot of my other villagers in my opinion.

9. Yuka. I like her design, I just like the others more. She's pretty cool to me though!

8. Punchy. He was the very first villager I bumped into on my island tours. I love how he's always ninja running around my town

7. Norma. She's super cute and insanely sweet! She's always sending me letters, too!

6. Hamphrey. His angry little eyebrows make me so happy.

5. Shep. He was my first campsite villager. Super lucky, right?? I love how his hair is over his eyes, he's just too cute.

4. Pinky. She was a random move-in and man, I love her. She's so ditzy and cute for such a big bear. She's always telling me she's going to walk enough distance to go to the moon and be a moon-bear, like what?

3. Skye. Skye is alwaaaysss singing, I find it incredibly cute. She's also always the one giving me meds when I get stung by bees, which is very appreciated. I also gave her sheep's clothing and it always makes me laugh when I see her walking around like that ..

2. Flurry. She's so freaking cute. Little snow hamster. I tend to let most of my villagers go when they ask to move out to keep up variety in my town but I just wasn't ready to let her go yet.

1. Bree. Only villager I had the patience to write a letter to! She's great. She is practically my only source of DIYs! Also you all should see her when she puts on those circular glasses while reading, top 10 cutest things ever!
 
I'm not very far in yet and pretty much all of my current villagers are hopefully going to move at one point in the future as I don't like that they don't come with their proper houses, but I want rank them anyway :)

Tabby and Groucho are about to move in and I think that I will like them a lot, but since I haven't really gotten to know them yet, I won't include them here.

6. Graham. Kind of a weird little hamster guy. He only moved in today and hasn't been out about town yet, so maybe he'll surprise me, but if it hadn't been for the fact that he was my first campsite visitor and I had to take him in, I probably wouldn't have.
5. Lily. She has such a pretty design! However, there is nothing really special to her. She wears cute reading glasses, that's it.
4. Prince. By far not as pretty as Lily, but he turned out to be quite charming (no pun inteded.)
3. Kevin. At first I wasn't too fond of him, but he grew on me. Always talking about sports, he seems to secretely be into fashion. No one is changing as often in a day as him and for bunny day he was happily rocking a little dress. Also, he is often seen carrying a flower-patterned purse.
2. Pate. She's just adorable, I don't know what else to say. I'm not looking forward to her leaving, but since Tabby seems to have the same personality type, I hope she'll be able to fill the void Pate is going to leave one day.
1. Hazel. The only one that I might want to try to get again after she left. I love the colors on her, especially the pink and red in that curl of her tail and her hair cut is adorable! She also looks so soft and squishy and I feel like out of all of my villagers she is the one I bonded with the most.
 
There's alot of text that i have to put them in a Spoiler

10th: Hippeux (Personal Tier: C): When i got him in a Campsite i was like "Oh no not a Hippo villager". But since i had no villager who represented Smug personality at that time and i tried to love every kind of villager, i had to let him in. His design started to look fine for me though, but if he wants to move, i'll happily let him go

9th: Walt (Personal Tier: C+): Kangaroo villagers aren't really my personal favorite, but i had to let Walt in because first: My sister liked his design, second: Same reason with Hippeux, i didn't have Cranky villagers at that time. I hope he can help me managing troublesome villagers lol

8th: Cranston (Personal Tier: C+): When i first noticed i got Cranston, i had mixed feelings about him. What i like about him is that he's the only Lazy villager in my island for now, he has nice house, and he's part of the leaked screenshot at the time when ACNH was months away from the release lol. What i don't like about him is that his design isn't really that appealing to me. My sister often talks to him and mistakenly calling his name "Kristen" lol

7th: Winnie (Personal Tier: C+): She started to grow up on me. At first i was kinda disappointed i got her as my first Peppy villager (Previously i mistook her as Snooty villager), but as the time went she's OK to me and i even started to like her. I just don't like that she kinda looks like that "who are you running from?" guy from Gameboy Camera

6th: Mitzi (Personal Tier: B+): I like her because she's a cat, she has nice dress, and her bright smile brights my day. I can rank her up more after she's been around my island for a little while. She lives the closest to my house than any other villagers

5th Lyman (Personal Tier: A-): I was little excited when i got him as one of my starter villagers. Lyman surely is one of the best Koalas for me. My sister often calls him "Lyn" or "Lym"

4th Norma (Personal Tier: A-): She really grew up on me. I found her in NMT island. At first i didn't really want her to move in, but after i let her in and made several conversations with her, i almost love her despite the fact i don't really like cow villagers. Her cute little smile is one of the reasons i want her to stay for a long time

3rd Wendy (Personal Tier: A): Sheep is one of my favorite villager species so i automatically love Wendy. Her house interior is so cute!

2nd Tammy (Personal Tier: A): I can't believe this little cub can actually make me love her i almost considered her my new dream villager. I think it's because cub is also one of my favorite villager species just like Sheep, she's featured in ACNH Trailer, and she's also the villager who makes me laugh the most. Overall she's cute despite being Uchi

1st Dotty (Personal Tier: SS): No doubt the best villager in my island and also one of my dreamies. Personally, she's one of the best Rabbits after Bunnie and Chrissy. I was completely shocked when i found her in NMT island. Also, her house color really matches with my island theme! She's indeed a permanent villager in my island
 
Update!!!!
7. Olaf- My first campsite villager, he's just okay. I like his businessman aesthetic though.
6. Frita- My Sisterly starting villager, she's really grown on me, she gives me free stuff everyday.
5. Nana- My Normal villager from a NMT island, she's pretty cute and I like the Ice Climber reference.
4. Tutu- My Peppy villager from a NMT island, she is so adorable!
3. Hamlet- My starting Jock villager, one of my favorite Jock villagers, he is so cute when he runs!
2. Erik- My Lazy villager from a NMT island, he is my favorite Lazy villager tied with Sherb, he is one of my dreamies, I was so happy when I saw him on an NMT island!
1. Reneigh- While she is another sisterly villager, she is my favorite Sisterly villager and one of my dreamies! I was jumping around the room when I saw her on an island. I can't wait for her to move in!
 
10. Tybalt - Plague upon my land. Talks about muscles an uncomfortable amount.
9. Tex - I don't like his jacket, or his eyes. And when he says "picante" it's weird every time.
8. Agnes - Had her in New Leaf and she was meh then. Didn't want her again this time around, but here we are.
7. Doc - He's okay but he's a little too blue. Also too orange.
6. Dora - She's nice but bland.
5. Apple - Crafts a lot so that's cool. She's pretty cute and always nice.
4. Cherry - I love Cherry, but I had her in my New Leaf town for a long time. I'll keep her for a while, but there are other villagers I'd rather have. For now, she's staying until I can replace the 6 villagers I've ranked lower than her with ones I like better.
3. Chevre - She's adorable, and so sweet. She has a nice house and plays nice music.
2. Marina - She's cute, she's pink, she looks unique. She's got it all. If we were ranking our villagers based on number of legs, she'd be #1.
1. Fauna - I actually didn't have any opinion on Fauna before this game, but I really like her. She's cute without going overboard, has a nice catchphrase, and I love deer both in game and IRL. I can see why she's a top tier villager, but I'd love her even if she wasn't.
 
tsdenizen said:
I'm still cycling but right now:

10. Lily: Cute, but not as cute as Gladys or Flurry, and one of three normals. Just kinda... boring. I know people love her and I'm very lucky to have her as my "worst", but she just doesn't quite mesh well. Got her from a mystery island, will be swapping out for Weber (the single most underrated villager).
9. Gladys: Very cute, but one of three normals and has a redundant aesthetic with Genji. Will be kicking for Bruce. Got her on a mystery island.
8. Genji: No jock was gonna score high for me, but Genji's one of the stronger picks. Might climb after I can change his mochi catchphrase back to his old one: otaku. Card from a pack booted Cousteau (who was nearly as cool but had a crappy starter house).
7. Audie: Up for auction right now. She's great, but I like Tangy a little more personally, and friend whose island I visit every day has her, I have another wolf on the docket (Freya), and since I got her from an early mystery island, she doesn't have her true house for me.
6. Flurry: Sickeningly adorable snow hamster. I love her, but her house is eh. Mystery island get. She's staying but I might have to do some shenanigans to get her good house.
5. Tangy: A total SPAZ, super cute, fruit theme is unique. Card from a pack, booted Tom.
4. Raymond: This guy's been growing on me. Didn't really get the hype after he joined after showing up as my second natural campsite villager, but after someone recontextualized him as Thin White Duke-era Bowie, I can't help but see it: really classy looking while still having his visual eccentricities, and he's SUPER WEIRD. Dude eats sandwiches in front of the bridge at 10PM, naked ass on the terracotta roads. Brilliant.
3. Static: Cranky voice coming out of a squirrel is funny as hell, plus purple and yellow is a sick color combo and I'm a music guy so Static's a bro. Underrated, like this guy WAY more than Marshal. Adopted from a friend after Hugh left.
2. Ankha: Adorable Egytian princess kitty. Got her card in a pack, booted Hazel for her.
1. Julian: The king of Aria Bay. Flamboyant weirdo and the glue that holds all the relationships together. Was my mandatory campsite villager: wicked luck.
Click to expand...
If your looking to give up Gladys I would take her!
 
10. Katt - She's one of my original 2 and I'm just not a fan of her face design.
9. Beau - He's very cute obviously but I also have Eric and they have the same personality.
8. Judy - I only invited her to my island knowing someone else would appreciate being able to adopt her in the future. Her eyes scare me.
7. Lopez - His house and personality are great and I have been enjoying his presence on the island. I do have a lot of deer though.
6. Soleil - I'm happy to have a hamster and I don't imagine I'll let her move away any time soon. I like her colours!
5. Erik - So many deer but I like that he has big antlers and a cabin theme.
4. Bruce - Yes, another deer. All male too I noticed. The grumpy personality is one of my favourites so me & Bruce are great friends so far.
3. Mac - He is totally an under appreciated villager. He's a bulldog/pug type dog so I thought people would be more excited about him. He fills my islands jock role perfectly.
2. Nan - Adorable & sweet! She showed up on my island randomly & not from a NMT island trip like everyone else. She was a nice surprise.
1. Dotty - My only rabbit villager so far. My island is called Usagi so the plan was to get as many rabbits as possible. She is the only rabbit to have popped up on my island trips. She is quite sassy and I vibe with her.
 
Guess I'll join haha

10. open spot atm~
9. Norma - I like her design, but shares way too much dialogue with some of my other villagers (i have too many normals...
8. Yuka - could take her or leave her.
7. Billy - didn't care for him at first but he naruto runs everywhere and it's adorable.
6. Audie - super lucky NMT roll for her, not my favorite, but not my least fave.
5. Stu - lazy, blue, and reads books. literally me.
4. Marina - sings a lot, pink, what's not to love?
3. Pekoe - was one of the 3 villagers that moved in, she's super cute <3
2. Marshal - camper I got while TTing trying to get Raymond. He popped up and i fell for his adorable squirrel-ness
1. Chevre - cute look, cute house, I LOVE HER
 
The ones I'm not sure about although two are recent joiners...

Renee -- She was one of my starters. An interesting design and I like that she's a stargazer but otherwise she seems a bit of a dull character really.
Tom -- Mixed feelings on Tom who is also a recent joiner. I like his old man dialogue (reminds me of Tom from "Goodnight Mr Tom") but then his house is full of cars and looks awful. I also think it's a bit weird that there's another Tom besides Tom Nook.
Willow -- She joined recently. I like her design but she's kinda... just there.

Then there are five I absolutely love:

Deli -- An interesting character who I get a lot of recipes from.
Celia -- Brilliant design and she's so lovely and kind-hearted.
Hamlet -- He's hilarious and has a great design -- brilliant!
Flora -- She's so funny and has a brilliant design. I love watching her charge about!
Quilson -- I wasn't sure I'd like him at first but he's been absolutely hilarious and so much fun. I was shocked to find out that a lot of people don't like him.

Eloise is moving in tomorrow according to the sign... no idea what to expect!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

M
Need Help! Sorting Villagers Between New Leaf and New Horizons
Replies
1
Views
234
Giddy
Giddy
BIOHAZARD IMPACT
Does anyone else feel bad for gulliver?
Replies
14
Views
816
KittenNoir
KittenNoir
evie.pear
What other animals would you like for villagers? or what other designs?
Replies
16
Views
1K
Charcolor
Charcolor
M
Villagers of Mana! Need Helps Selecting!
Replies
1
Views
333
Mimikyu's Shadow
Mimikyu's Shadow
M
Help Decide The Future of Mana
Replies
2
Views
162
-Blue-
-Blue-
Back
Top