Rank Your Villagers!

[Aleigh]

10. Beardo. Why did you have to move in. No one asked you to. You look like you smell
9. Blaire. She bullied Dobie and made him walk around all depressed. Get out of my town we don't stan meanies
8. Lucy. She's alright, but not my favorite.
7. Cheri. She was a random move in, but she called me her bestie one day so she's moved up the list. She also wears a cute little bow sometimes
6. Bam. I feel like he's super basic, but he's got a cool design nonetheless
5. Tucker. I like him a lot. He's different and has a cute name. He's ~prehistoric~
4. Fauna. Alright, so I originally found her on an island tour and invited her with the pure intention of selling her because I know she's a lot of people's dream villager. But she's really grown on me and I now see the hype
3. Julian. He was one of my dream villagers in New Leaf. I love him so so much. His house, his design, everything
2. Tom. Tom is my little cranky baby. I will protect him at all costs. I've loved him in gamecube, and I will love him now. He was my favorite for awhile
1. Cookie. This sweet child gives me so much nostalgia. She was my favorite character from gamecube when I was little. Though she probably wouldn't have caught my eye if I found her now, I can't help the fact that she was my childhood best friend.

 

[rhinoo]

10 - Pekoe. She's got the "I've Moved" glitch, so I haven't spoken to her, making her number 10.

9 - Nate. He was one of the 3 random island villagers that I invited. I decided to invite all of mine and I got him. I thought maybe he'd grow on me but he didn't.

8 - Knox. Newest resident, he's just a chicken with a helmet. I only invited him because he's cranky.

7 - Poncho. He's heckin adorable, but he was kinda rude to me.

6 - Flora. I like Flora. What makes her lower is the fact that she called herself an Ostrich, but she's clearly a flamingo.

5 - Goldie. Goldie is cool, but she's really... basic? Her house is so bland and her design and phrase isn't really anything special. She gets bonus points for being in my first New Leaf town.

4 - Hazel. My starting Uchi villager. I don't care what everyone says, her monobrow is bloody adorable.

3 - Bones. He's a dog. He is lazy. What isn't there to like? His design is very good and he likes to Naruto run.

2 - Stitches. He's a teddy bear! What isn't there to like? Everyone loves Stitches.

1 - Hornsby. Best villager in the game. He was my dreamie since the beginning. I love him!

 

[Fisher]

10. Avery - his personality is just kinda bland to me.

9. Lopez - find him to be kinda weird.

8. Teddy - he’s cool but he just won’t shut up about working out which is obnoxious lol.

7. Puddles - I like puddles but I just don’t really like frog villagers

6. Fauna - she’s cute and seems pretty cool but just moved in so might move up with time.

5. Sandy - She can be a little weird but always gives me stuff so I like her haha

4. Francine - She’s pretty cool and I think it’s cute and funny how she says karat all the time for some reason lol

3. Elvis - I really like Lions and Elvis irl so was really happy when he moved to my island, he’s a really cool villager too.

2. Bob - was one of my villagers on the GameCube AC when I played as a kid. Always been one of my favorite villagers so was really happy when he moved to my island, it seemed like fate.

1. Tammy - Didn’t think I’d like her at first but idk she just really grew on me and now she’s my favorite.

 

[GameFaceClive]

I haven't been trying to get my dream islanders as my main focus was to unlock terraforming. It's been a few days and I'm slowly working on the island, taking frequent breaks because it can feel overwhelming (and discouraging seeing other awesome islands). So far, I've not had any islanders move out, and I've also not decided if I want 10 islanders yet. I'm testing out clothing & accessories on these islanders XD

8th: Apple (random move-in). She's got that bright peppy energy but am not a fan of the hamsters and the way clothes stretch around their bodies.

7th: Shari (starter). She's been nice but hasn't really clicked for me. She stays in her house quite a lot so I often forget she's here.

6th: Phil (forced camper). Was not pleased initially but warming up to him a little and starting to see the versatility in his design. He can wear the most ornate clothes and actually pull it off. Looks good with hats and great home interior too.

5th: Stella (mystery island). I love the floofy sheep villagers in NL and was hoping the new design would grow on me. It hasn't. Stella is adorable and always watering flowers, chatting with islanders but she won't be staying.

4h: Whitney (mystery island). I needed an 8th islander to unlock Island Evaluation. Found her on my first mystery island trip that day. She's never been a dreamie but she and her house are fabulous XD. Still, will let her go if she asks.

3rd: Beau (mystery island). Makes me go 'aww' inside. Constantly gives me stuff and DIYs. Most likely will not stay.

2nd: Kitty (amiibo). Wanted to experience inviting an amiibo camper & going through the steps to making them an islander. Kitty is one of my favs from NL. Will see how familiar or new she feels here.

1st: Leonardo (starter). Did not expect him to grow on me as he has! He bought a hat I designed and always gives me stuff. Plus he always looks so happy to talk to me. Seriously considering keeping him permanently. Also I actually enjoy thinking about how to make his home interior better.

 

[melco]

Still not sure if I should even get a 10th yet, so I'll do this now...

9 Tammy I don't really hate her... She was one of my starters and is pretty cool in this game, but she's also in my New Leaf town and I think she's been there the longest, yet has never given me her pic and sells a lot of fake art... So I'm just a little sick of her.

8 Sprocket He started out as my favorite because he's a robot, but he just keeps bullying others. And the jock shtick got old fast...

7 Flora What I am annoyed by in her personality is made up for by the fact that she is a cute pink flamingo with a heart shaped face.

6 Goldie Okay she just moved in today, so can't really judge too much. But she's a puppy and had a very cute loading screen I remember from Pocket Camp, so...

5 Ozzie Not even a fan of lazy villager types, but he's definitely pure-hearted. Gets fleas almost every day, sometimes twice a day. It's endearing.

4 Raymond Just happened to get this popular lad at my campsite.. he has cute mouf and was overjoyed when I gave him a litterbox. Might not like him so much if I weren't such a furry.

3 Chevre Probably the cutest one. I will never get tired of hearing la baa. She also seems to ping me more than most to give me gifts.. And there's a face she makes when relaxing that cracks me up every time

2 Ike Okay I have a soft spot for the cute bears, especially cranky ones... Classic gentle giant type and he's always sitting by the river very tranquil..

1 Blanche Is it just me or are snooty villagers way nicer in NH? Maybe I just got an especially good one. Her house is beautiful and her voice is like an angel... Also she was the only one outside on Bunny Day who just straight up refused to wear the egg costume for some reason

 

[ayeeprill]

I have new villagers since I last did this, so I'm gonna do it again!


10. Biff. He's still here...he's still fine...he can still leave anytime.
9. Fuchsia. I still like her a lot, but she's starting to bore me. I can't ever find her anywhere.
8. Pippy. I love her! Only reason she's so low is because she's the same personality as Bianca and I like Bianca more.
7. Julian. He's a cutie!
6. Tia - a sweetie!
5. Octavian - the best octopus. fight me about it.
4. Biskit - a GOOD BOY
3. Bianca (Same as last time)
2. Ribbot (Same as last time)
1. Kiki (Same as last time)

 

[axo]

1. Joey! (I love him so much, he's one of my all time faves and he's just too cute)
2. Puddles, (another dreamie of mine, I love frogs and I love her color scheme)
3. Gladys (while I am going to eventually let her move out, she's one of my faves as well, I love cranes and her design is so nice)
4. Marina (she's my favorite octopus, but doesn't fit the theme of my town)
5. Audie (super cute, but I'm not a huge fan of the peppy type and I already have Puddles filling that role)
6. Bill (cute duck boy, not my favorite but I like him)
7. Sprocket (not a huge fan, but his design is pretty cool)
8. Katt (not a fan of her design, but she's grown on me a little bit, I do really like uchi types)
9. Rasher (I love cranky types but his design and his house are just not for me at all)
10. Quilson (I hate smug types, and his design is awful in my opinion. I think he's my only villager that I truly don't like)

 

[theravenboys]

10. Apple...she calls me "subscriber." Idk why I let her do that but I regret it now. And peppy is my least-favorite female villager personality type, they're always turned up on 100 when the situation calls for no more than a solid 6.
9. Goose...he was one of my starters. Nothing really wrong with him, but I'm just kind of meh about him.
8. Rex...like Goose, there's nothing wrong with him either, but I don't feel strongly one way or the other about him. I also have a lazy now who I like much more (Erik) so if Rex asks to move, I'll let him.
7. Sprocket...I actually love his design and think he's really cool. Unless I get Genji, I might keep him as my jock. There are just other villagers on my island I like more.
6. Alice...she's so sweet and cute. I really like her, but I feel like she sometimes gets lost in the shuffle because she's not my only normal or my only koala. So because of that, I feel like she doesn't stand out as much as some of my other villagers, but I do really like her.
5. Chevre...she's ADORABLE. I love her catchphrase. I feel bad about putting her this low tbh lol she really is one of my favorites.
4. Muffy...I love her design and I love how she's always singing! Her house is really cool, too.
3. Canberra...I feel like objectively I should prefer Muffy over Canberra for an uchi, especially since I know a lot of people think Canberra is kind of ugly, but I absolutely love her. I also feel a lot of nostalgia toward her because I've had her in my New Leaf town for 3 years. She was one of my NH starters so it kind of felt like she left the New Leaf town with me and joined me on my island adventure! :O
2. Blaire...SO cute. Probably my favorite snooty besides Whitney. I just love everything about her and I really like her house interior as well. Plus I find her "nutlet" catchphrase really adorable.
1. Erik...what a KING. I love his design and his house interior. I feel like every time I see him outside he's sniffing flowers or getting distracted by a butterfly and I just want to "aww" at him lol. Someone on here gave him to me and I really cannot thank you enough because he's definitely my favorite villager on my island!

 

[Fryd]

10. Annalise - She made her way on my island on her own accord. Not too terrible really... but I wouldn’t mind if she asked to leave.

9. Judy - She’s a lovely cub, she really is... but having 3 snooty villagers is a little bit much for me.

8. Diana - Really pretty. Might be the snooty villager I will keep.

7. Rolf - I was skeptical at first when I met him during a tour but his design looked interesting. Likes to sing for a grump. His baby blue paws make him a keeper hahaha. I also thought it funny that his home was mountain themed when his house is located right by the beach.

6. Beau - He was a surprise move in at the start since I knew I only invited two villagers the previous day before I had to set some land down. Pleasant little dude!

5. Audie - Really fun gal! She’s living like a queen with a waterfall behind her home. She can stay forever.

4. Nan - Another one I was skeptical of but I’m surprised to really like her shy, book-loving personality and simple design! She seems to get along really well with Julian which was really cute. I also watched her jamming on the drumset the other day which was really cool.

3. Julian - Forced his way onto my island. Didn’t disappoint.

2. Muffy - I absolutely adore her. She likes to sing a lot which makes me WEAK.

1. Pierce - I think it’s safe to call this guy my best friend on the island. Was always happy to see me when we were starting out.

 

[Ally000]

Luckily Midge moved out today as she was one of my villagers that I wasn’t too fond of. Found Rex on a NMT today, I’m excited for him to move in tomorrow

9. Drake - was a random move in. I don’t hate him but he doesn’t really do much besides naruto run around and also stays in his house a lot. Don’t really like the look of the duck villagers. Hopefully he wants to move out soon

8.Shari - one of my starters. She was my first friend and she gives me gifts but also throws some rude comments in occasionally. Today she tried to make me buy a face mask off of her. She can leave whenever she wants

7.Kid Cat - other random move in but he has definitely grown on me. Not a huge fan of jocks in general but I do want sports equipment for my house and he has given me the kettlebell recipe. I’ll let him leave when he wants

6. Cheri - thought she was cute after spending a lot of NMT, settled on moving her in. She just moved in yesterday so haven’t gotten to know her yet, might move up in the rankings.

5. Zell - random campsite villager. Wasn’t thrilled at first but again he is growing on me, he has a super cool house!

4. Ellie - very cute elephant, very sweet so far (she was 8th move in NMT)

3. Julian - 9th move in from NMT, only been here a few days but I love his unicorn look and his house is also cool! I like his smug personality so far

2.Patty - unsure of her at first but she is the cutest!!! Always giving me gifts and so sweet

1. Flora - love her flamingo look. Always calls me her bestie and gives me gifts every time she sees me! Definitely want her to stay

I’m probably going to let most of them leave if they want just because I want to get to know as many villagers as possible! I might change my mind when some of them ask though if I get too attached

 

[BluePing]

5.canberra- she’s kinda scary looking until she claps or somet which is why she’s my least favourite villager but she is kinda cute when she claps ngl
4.Gayle- I think Gayle is cute and I invited her so I wouldn’t get a scary looking random villager but she’s not gonna be in my town forever
3.axel- axel is really cute and his smile is unique compared to all the other villages which is so cute and his colour is cute
2.bunnie- bunnie is cute and kinda basic but I think she’s sweet. I won’t keep her in my town forever but I’ll keep her for a while as she’s probably my favourite rabbit villager alongside ruby.
1.punchy- punchy is super cute and I love his personality type. I think he’s sweet and the cats are among my favourite villager types so that’s why he’s my favourite that’s in my town atm. I’ll probably keep him in my town for a while and maybe forever if I get to like him enough

 

[N a t]

In order from my favorite to least favorite and not necessarily like popularity?

1. Cleo, 2. Fuschia, 3. Raymond, 4. Willow, 5. Static, 6. Zucker, 7. Genji, 8. Bones, 9. Lucy, 10. Cheri.

I actually just got Flora's amiibo card in the mail today and will be replacing Cheri with her. I love all of my villagers at least somewhat and some more than others but over time I can definitely start to see who I have an affinity for and that I seem to like a lot of cutsie and pastel or feminine villagers the most maybe. Could also just be whatever day I'm having. Idk.

 

[Rosewater]

1. Rolf - The dad of the town. He gives me bada** vibes. Always crafting. Really cool
2. Gayle - Sweet baby. She is so cute and must be protected. I love how she is always holding a sandwich
3. Pashmina - The chill hipster girl. Her house looks like a 50s diner and the sweater she's wearing is ironically fashionable and thrifty. I like her because she's like the cool friend who's always doing her own thing
4. Drago - Pretty boring but one of my better villagers design-wise.
5. Mira - She reminds me of The Incredibles. I don't really like her but she's better than the below villagers.
6. Bubbles - She looks like an 18 year old who's annoying.
7. Bud - Guy Fieri with the highest pitched voice in the world. Awful.
8. Lionel - Creepy. No old guy should ever be running after me but he does and it's unsettling. I cannot wait to banish him forever.
9. Judy - Scary eyes, weird lips. She gives good gossip but I can't stand her design. I really want her out of my island just as much as Lionel.

 

[poison_mutton]

10.) Graham: He’s a little dork who does nothing but stare at trees with a magnifying glass all day. Gave me a urinal because he said it reminded him of me.

9.) Francine: Nook invited her, I can’t get her to leave. Don’t like her design, and there are so many other snooty villagers I’d prefer.

8.) Bam: One of my first neighbors, I feel bad for ranking him so low because he’s inoffensive, but I wouldn’t beg him to stay if he decided to move.

7.) Olaf: His hair bugs me, and his house exterior is ugly as sin... but Olaf’s kind of grown on me. I like anteaters, so we’re cool.

6.) Ketchup: my favorite villager is Scoot, and I don’t like having two of the same species in my town at once, so if I can get Scoot to come home one day she’s getting ignored. Until that day comes, I like her, she’s cute and friendly and wears an egg hat.

5.) Fauna: Cute, inoffensive, kinda boring. Not really much to say about her.

4.) Monty: I love grumpy villagers. I like his design a lot, his house (interior and exterior) are nice, and he’s been a friendly dude overall. However, he trashed the man-faced stink bug model I gave him, even though it would have looked great with his home decor, so he loses points.

3.) Reneigh: She was my second starting villager. Even though I have equinophobia, and even though her home interior is a train wreck (two beds AND a sleeping bag) I still really like her. Sisterly villagers are another favorite of mine.

2.) Curt: I love this dude, terrible home layout aside. He looks like a mix between a cool grandpa and an ex hitman. The face he makes when reading a book is priceless.

1.) Zucker: I’ve been wanting an octopus to live in my town since City Folk, and Zucker is the first one who has actually moved in. Lazy villagers are super chill, he’s accepted every home gift I’ve given him, and his dialogue is always entertaining. I love him, he’s never allowed to leave.

 

[Yuina]

Oof this is going to be hard because I like all of them:

10: Apple: Sometimes she looks cute, sometimes she looks really scary.
9: Bob: I like Bob, but I only got him because I can sell him later. (sorry Bob :c)
8: Poppy: She's cute. Basic, but really cute.
7: Pekoe: Same lol, but she looks a bit more 'special' than Poppy.
6: Kabuki: I got him because I wanted him to be the caretaker of the zen garden/Japanese garden. His house is at the perfect spot and he looks so weird I love him a lot.
5: Marina: Another cute but normal villager. She gets a lot of points because she's a pink octopus.
4: Merengue: She's a strawberry shortcake rhino, do I need to say more?
3: Sherb: He's a soft cute baby.
2: Reneigh: I looove her dark colors and pastel pink oh god. She loves flowers and she always smells the flowers on the island lol.
1: Raymond: Duh.

 

[PauperSkittles]

10. Lionel This smug lion was forced unto my island as the first camping guest and he has overstayed his welcome.
9. Wolfgang He moved in automatically when I had an empty plot and I am not happy about it. He is a bit too cranky for me and I don't like the wolf designs.
8. Freckles Peppy is not for me, I don't need an idol on my island even though I thought she was cute at first.
7. Hazel UNIWOW - 'nough said. Although she has grown on me a little, she is kind.
6. Celia I don't like her design sadly, I do really like her personality as her hobbies are cool!
5. Zucker He would be my favourite snack mate if he would not eat everything before I visit him every time!
4. Judy She cute
3. Teddy I thought he was meh at first but he is just so cute and kind!
2. Melba I love her design and her chill and simple personality that matches mine a bit.
1. Merengue I love her design, her house and everything, hope she gets a bit more confident though!

 

[AccfSally]

This is going to be hard, because I already have a good bit of dreamies here and I like everyone who's here.

10) Flora, she's ok.
9) Stitches, he's cute but not keeping him.
8) Rudy, I like him. Might keep, but I'm trying to do what I did in my NL towns Vista and Chocolat. (Don't judge me!)
7) Marshal, I really like him..but some of the over hype for him makes me dislike him a little.
6) Poppy, I also really like her..the same problem as Marshal's.
5) Hazel, She's cool and I enjoy having her company like I did back in NL.
4) Francine, I really like her.
3) Static, my favorite since the GC version.
2) Genji, my most favorite rabbit of all.
1) Sally, she's been my best friend since the GC version when she was called 'Hazel'.

 

[Celes]

10. Raddle - He's pretty meh. It's cool that he has a mask but otherwise eh
9. Rocket - Definitely not the most aesthetically pleasing design, but I don't hate her because she gives the best DIY recipes.
8. Deirdre - She pretty ok? Her design is kinda plain but she's cute.
7. Bertha - She's surprisingly pretty cute! Though her hair is questionable lol.
6. Octavian - Octopus! He's pretty chill
5. Julian - Just got him, but I love how he's a unicorn. Fantastic house too.
4. Judy - Super unique and cute design! Gives the best clothing items
3. Sprinkle - I love peppy villagers in this game. I also love penguins.
2. Filbert - First "best friend" according to Nook Miles. Lazy villagers are my favorite, and he is soooo cute. His eyebrows man
1. Cube - Had him as a starter in NL! Penguin and lazy. I'm never letting him leave.

 

[capnport]

8. Freckles Peppy is not for me, I don't need an idol on my island even though I thought she was cute at first.

OMG, Freckles the duck? She's peppy? That's so adorable...

 

[Bk1234]

Update:
5. Frita (Frita is just Frita...)
4. Nana (Cute, and I like the Ice Climber reference)
3. Tutu (So adorable! ❤)
2. Hamlet (One of my favorite Jock villagers)
1. Erik (Favorite Lazy villager tied with Sherb)

First Campsite Villager Coming Today!