poppy, mitzi, or marina?

[lilyplaysacnh]

hey, my bday is coming up and i have three spots open for new villigers, i am getting 3 amibo cards for my bday and i for sure want octavian and bob, BUT i have one spot left open and i was going to get mitzi but seeing some other villigers kinda changed my mind and now i don’t know what i want! i wanted mitzi because i wanted a cute cat to be friends with bob but i didn’t rlly have a big reason to wanting her, i wanted poppy because she’s sooo cute! and i like the little squirrel villigers, i also like marina because her and octavian should be besties and she’s very cute! so i don’t know what to do!! (i also wanted nan but i will always feel bad because i can’t get cherave so i can’t do it) so please tell me your thoughts!


okay right now the votes are either mitzi or poppy so i still don’t know

 

[InstantNoodles]

I personally would choose Mitzi since she is one of my favourite normal villagers though design wise she is nowhere near as interesting as Poppy or Marina. I also wanted to pair Mitzi with Bob

 

[saucySheep]

Personally I find Marina to be disgusting, but if you want Octavian to not feel left out for being the rarest species in the game then go ham with Marina..

or maybe Bob and Mitzi could date. I like Mitzi a lot she's a sweetie.

Poppy is cute too. Maybe get her if you want some diversity rather than having two of the same species

 

[Caitlin00091]

I would also choose Mitzi. I have her amiibo card and she is one of my favorite cat villagers!

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

All 3 are adorable! Personally, I would get Poppy so either Octavian or Bob doesn't feel left out (and you get the bonus of having different species). ^_^

 

[Your Local Wild Child]

IMO poppy is my favorite pick because I like her more woodsy design.

 

[Uffe]

I love Poppy and Mitzi! I had Mitzi in the first Animal Crossing game and I currently have Poppy. But I'd choose Poppy. I'm most likely being bias because I have her on my island.

 

[Marshmallows]

I would get Poppy since she seems to be the one you really want and like. If you get one of the others just for matching, you may not like them as much.

 

[Nunnafinga]

Yeah,I'd go with Poppy too.If you got Marina to go with Octavian,then you'd need Zucker to complete the octopus family and I think Rosie goes better with Bob even though I like Mitzi.

 

[Bk1234]

I would choose Poppy. She’s such an underrated squirrel! I really like her classy style too. Go with whatever your heart decides though!

 

[Jas]

i really like poppy! i have the octopi and they're also very cute, but i feel like marina is very common and lots of people have her haha

 

[Spunki]

All of them are good choices, but I would probably go for either Mitzi or Poppy, because Marina feels like she is everywhere. Poppy is probably one of the rare Squirrels almost no one has. I had her in City Folk and I never wanted her to leave ... ever.

 

[Etown20]

I have Marina and Poppy and you really can't go wrong with either.

I wouldn't necessarily let popularity or who other people have affect your choice. A lot of people do have Marina, but Poppy is very popular (no pun intended) as well, particularly in the cottagecore subsection of the AC community.

The main difference (besides species obviously) between Marina and Poppy are their hobbies. Marina has the music hobby, so you will find her randomly singing and dancing around the island, which is very endearing. Poppy has the education hobby, so you will find her with her big reading glasses and a book, which is really cute.

Anyway, here's a couple videos and screenshots I have of each!

https://twitter.com/x/status/1291509771699290112

https://twitter.com/x/status/1292490667982110720

 

[NyattaSama]

Poppy is the cutest babe! I vote for Poppy because I'm biased lol but she is so freakin cute! She sleeps wherever and whenever on my island non stop you can never go wrong with Poppy she will win your heart!

 

[mitfy]

i have poppy, and she's so cute! the inside of her house is gorgeous, too, and i love her pie-eyes

 

[CrestFallen]

Poppy! I have her on my island and honestly she’s such a sweetie! Here design is cute and it might just be me I tend to find her more ‘expressive’ that most other villagers

 

[eggie_]

i think marina would fit in so well with octavian! you could make lil beach spots for their houses, it would be super cute.

poppy is cool but i feel like she doesn’t fit as well as mitzi or marina. so yeah my vote is either mitzi to match bob or marina to match octavian (but if it were me i’d totally go for marina!)

 

[Larsi]

I would say Mitzi because she's a cat, she looks cute, she's a cat, I really wanted her too, she's a cat, she's not an octopus and did I mention she's a cat?

Ok and Poppy on the 2nd place. She looks cute too

 

[Serabee]

Poppy and Marina would be my choices. Personally, I love Marina- she was one of my dreamies and I bought her off here and love her. BUT you're already getting a cat and an octopus so, for diversity's sake, I think I might go with Poppy.

 

[marshallows]

not sure if you've already made a decision but poppy has my vote! it's already a bonus that you personally find her cute ^^
mitzi's eyes kinda scare me in an unexplainable manner but that's definitely just me.

hope you'll be able to settle on one of them!