Phoebe or Muffy?

[Cutesy]

I have them in my town and think they are both reasonably cute, but... I really can?t stand the Uchi personality so I want to get rid of one.
Who do you guys think I should keep?

 

[Khaelis]

I personally like Phoebe more. Granted this is a biased opinion, due to the fact I like birds and she's based off a Phoenix which are pretty cool. But as someone who's also not a huge fan of the Uchi personality, and has had Muffy as a villager in the past I think I like Phoebe more.

Edit: basically I think you should keep Phoebe.

 

[primandimproper]

Me being a Harry Potter fangirl, I'm gonna go ahead and vote Team Phoebe.

 

[Moon Witch]

muffy is one of my all time favourite villagers so i say keep her.

 

[mountaintear]

Why don't you like uchis? Cranky and Uchi villagers are less repetitive than the others. Also, my vote is for Muffy all the way~! I prefer the sheep's designs in-game. Muffy is unique with a great house and is the only villager who wears gothic lolita fashion as well.

 

[Darby]

Which one fits in better with your other villagers, both in looks and house exterior... Muffy’s house is really pretty and I used to have Phoebe so can’t say anything bad about her... Right now I have Muffy and just love it when she gives shirts to Wolfgang because I always laugh and think, oh, look, a wolf in sheeps clothing... Sad I’m so easily amused. Yours is a good tough choice to have, can’t lose either way.

 

[Tsukuri_Yukimura]

I prefer Phoebe. I like her Zen kinda feel and Muffy was just weird when I had her. But that is just my opinion. Right now the Uchi I have is Deirdre. I only like her and Phoebe as Uchi's go.

 

[Cutesy]

Why don't you like uchis?

I like talking to villagers, and for some reason I feel like Uchis talk in a way that makes them seem annoyed you’re talking to them. Maybe I just need to become better friends with them first?
Also that’s a super cute screenshot btw!

 

[John Wick]

It's a tough one.

I love Muffy, but her house exterior sucks.
So does Pheobe's.

I would pick Muffy though.

 

[Ghostkid]

Id go pheobe just because muffys design creeps me out a little...

 

[mountaintear]

I like talking to villagers, and for some reason I feel like Uchis talk in a way that makes them seem annoyed you?re talking to them. Maybe I just need to become better friends with them first?
Also that?s a super cute screenshot btw!

Thank you! Muffy is one of my all-time faves <3
But I love all of my villagers.

 

[Lullaby]

I really like Muffy (she's cute and has a great interior), but I think Phoebe is really cool since she's one of those mythical villagers. A phoenix in your town sounds pretty snazzy!
If I had to pick another uchi in my town it would be Muffy because she fits in better and MORE SHEEP. It's all dependent on your tastes in the end.

Uchis are one of my favorite villager types. While it may seem like they're a bit hard to talk to, they have a soft spot inside and it's great when you see it. They're sweethearts. and it's totally okay if you don't like them, everyone has a right to their own opinion!

 

[CaramelCookie]

I'm also not a fan of the uchi personality ...
I personally like Phoebe's design the best. I love sheep, but Muffy's face is a bit creepy... works really well in scary towns, gothic ones and such though, so if that's your town theme, Muffy's a better choice

 

[Gashlycrumb]

Muffy, because sheep are the best villager species and her house is prettier(to me) than Phoebe.

 

[Mayor Kera]

Muffy has a fun design.

 

[Sweetley]

Both are nice villagers, but I prefer Phoebe a little bit more then Muffy because of her design and house.

 

[Flare]

I'd personally get rid of Muffy for Phoebe.

 

[ElderPlops]

Muffy, because sheep are the best villager species and her house is prettier(to me) than Phoebe.

Basically this. Sheep are the best villager species.
I have her in my town, and I agree, Uchis can sound mean. But after you hang out with them and talk to them a lot, they soften up.

 

[Lippysue]

I would go for Phoebe, she is one of my favourite villagers. I love the Uchis, they are so different and come out with the funniest lines once you get to know them better.

 

[Verecund]

I like Muffy better! She was the first uchi villager than moved into both of my towns and she's always been really nice so she has a special spot in my heart.