Perfect Town is so weird...

[HopeForHyrule]

Isabelle kept telling me that my villagers wanted more PWPs, so I wasted a TON of bells to build a pyramid, Stonehenge, a sphinx, and a couple fairytale benches. Then there wasn't enough greenery apparently so I planted a few extra cedars and shrubs. Bam! Perfect town. Kept it for the fifteen days and got the gold watering can, and then I went day by day and demolished all the PWPs I built. Just got rid of the last one, and guess what?

I still have perfect town. Vurt de furk?

Or is this a game mechanic I've never been aware of, and you keep perfect town once achieved?

 

[namiieco]

Yeah Isabelle can be like that, it's annoying :/

 

[NeonxVandal]

Oh wow. I didn't know that. Does it really stay after you've achieved it?

 

[namiieco]

Oh wow. I didn't know that. Does it really stay after you've achieved it?

No it doesn't.

 

[ChillyKio]

Yeah, that function is really finicky. Congrats on perfect town, nonetheless!

 

[Paxx]

Yeaaah, Isabelle is weird like that. She tells me my place is a landfill just because I have a TON of flowers. REALLY?! Flowers are a good thing!

 

[HopeForHyrule]

This game can be so weird...lol. I really wasn't expecting her to say I still have a perfect town after I destroyed all of the new PWPs...the trees are still there, though. So maybe that was the deciding factor.

But if that's the case, Isabelle shouldn't have been telling me the town needed more PWPs.

 

[earthquake]

Yeaaah, Isabelle is weird like that. She tells me my place is a landfill just because I have a TON of flowers. REALLY?! Flowers are a good thing!

its not the flowers. i had the same problem.
i was decorating with beehives and fossils and gemstones and i also had some coins laying around since id shaken them out of trees.
that combined with the saplings i left on the ground apparently made it a landfill, and my proof is that as soon as i removed the items i just mentioned, the landfill message disappeared.

 

[NeonxVandal]

No it doesn't.

Thanks! :>