Overrated and Underrated villagers

[cannedcommunism]

There are a lot of popular villagers on this website. But I think some receive too much credit for nothing, like Julian the Unicorn. Sure, he's a unicorn. But he's UGLY! I mean, there could be a girl unicorn instead of HIM. But there are some that don't get a lot of attention that I really like. For example, I like Mint. But I barely hear ANYTHING about her on this website. Personally, I think she's cute.

Now, what's your opinion? What villagers do you think are to overrated, or you think need more praise?

 

[ayeeprill]

Overrated: Marshal. He's cute I guess...but I don't get the fuss? Also I don't find most of the hamsters that cute.


Underrated: CHERI!!!! I've wanted her since GC and I FINALLY got her in NL! She's basically Bluebear in red, but Bluebear gets way more attention. Also most of the Ostriches (except Phoebe and Flora) are super cute. And Big Top, who people seem to hate for his species

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Overrated: Julian, Marshal, Kyle, Marina, Zucker, etc.

Underrated: Poor Big Top, he never gets any love. I think he's uber cute!

 

[Hound00med]

Julian, Beau and Lolly are far too overrated..

Julian's a HORSE with a horn, get over it
Beau has creepy eyes, go find Erik, he's better <3
Lolly is cute, but she's so ordinary.. Kiki or Mitzi's better.. Or, maybe a better Normal like Sydney, Molly or even Merengue

Bangle, Sydney, Ren?e, Rocket, Simon and Ozzie are all extremely underrated

 

[Silversea]

I think Gladys and Freya are rather underrated.

 

[brooklyn9]

Overrated... I'll list a few. Ankha, Punchy, most of the cats..
Underrated: Hmm, what a hard question.. I think i'd go with Chester and Filbert.

 

[Chu]

Aw I don't think Julian is ugly :x Some people just really like unicorns?

Overrated: I really don't get the Marshall hype, no offense to anyone that likes him. None of the other squirrels seem to be popular, just him. And I much prefer Julian, Shep, or Pietro for my smug.

Underrated: Marcel & Gala. Marcel is just such an adorable puppy to me. I think his facepaint makes his expressions more exciting too (same for the popular Pietro).
And I never see anyone want Gala and I don't understand why. I love the painted flowers on her face, reminds me of ganguro girls. Though I do understand that she has a lot of competition in the normal category.

 

[Zanessa]

Overrated: Marshal. Ew.
Underrated: Phoebe

 

[ayeeprill]

I feel like a lot of villages are looked over just because of their species, in particular Rhinos (Merengue aside), Ducks, and Frogs. Not a fan of hippos but Bertha is adorbs.

 

[Farobi]

Overrated... I'll list a few. Ankha, Punchy, most of the cats..
Underrated: Hmm, what a hard question.. I think i'd go with Chester and Filbert.

I probably overrate Punchy but i luff him <3
Overrated: Julian, Fauna, and Marshal.

 

[Hound00med]

I probably overrate Punchy but i luff him <3
Overrated: Julian, Fauna, and Marshal.

I'd say Fauna is actually pretty underrated, deer wise.. She's probably one of the least popular deer, alongside the two uchis

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

I'd say Fauna is actually pretty underrated, deer wise.. She's probably one of the least popular deer, alongside the two uchis

Actually, that's not true. Fauna is fairly popular.

 

[Hound00med]

Actually, that's not true. Fauna is fairly popular.

Yeah, generally speaking, she's pretty dayum popular.. But as I said, deer wise, she really isn't too popular when compared to the likes of Beau, Erik and Diana, I see Bam and Bruce get traded more often than Fauna

 

[keybug55]

Overrated: Marshal, Zucker, Julian, Ahnkah, ect. ect.

Underrated: Tucker, Alli, Bangle, Rasher, Gala, Flip, Rod, Lyman, Ozzie, and so many more to name

 

[Pixlplume]

Overrated: Julian, Marshal, Fauna, Whitney, Merengue, Zucker, Stitches
Underrated: Biskit (Basically Dog-Stitches), Frobert, Lucy, and Renee?

 

[Mookie]

I have Marshal in one of my towns, and actually prefer Mint and Cally in the other town. I would be devastated if either of them wanted to move, where Marshal is expendable.

 

[Laurina]

Overrated: Julian. Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't mind if he decided to camp or move to my town, but nothing about him screams dream villager!
Underrrated: Rolf, Walt, Peewee, Hamphrey, Hopper. I love Cranky villagers. Once they warm up to you, they really are the sweetest.

 

[Soot Sprite]

I've always loved butch the cranky dog and goldie:3

 

[Bread Kennedys]

Overrated: Marshal,Julian,R?nee
Underrated: Rooney,Dizzy,Lyman

I really feel like I'm the only one here that likes Rooney. I like him so much because he was so awesome back in one of my old towns,And I really feel like he deserves more attention than anyone else.

 

[Anampses]

Julian is overrated for sure.
I don't think Chester gets as much attention as he oughtta IMO