Overated villagers?

[milkyi]

Marshal and Ankha.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Beau is over rated as heck...really he costs an arm and a leg for what seems like no reason.

Wanna know the funny thing? When I was new to ACNL I had him in my town. I thought he was such a lame villager. Now that I know this im like, danggg, I'm so stupid.

 

[-Apples-]

Yeah! Marshal is so popular because he outright MANIPULATES people into liking him! He also made Biskit "kill" himself and made Pit (Biskit's best friend) believe the poor guy was a dead dog! He's also skilled in making false romance (See 3700-2069-4814 for this awful town, governed by such a victim [Mello])! Someone, PLEASE take this psychotic son of a plork off Tier 1, or I'm calling the Administrators!

The mods and admins aren't in charge of the tier system. That was a regular user. Besides, the community decides what Tier each animal is, not the staff. This is similar to the TBT exchange rate and price of collectibles.

 

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

OK, OliverFan4Ever, I get the point of Marshal's Overratedness.

 

[PlasmaPower]

I think all deer in general are overrated. The only two I actually like are Fauna and Bam.

 

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

Oh. Deers. [apple2012]I was talking about Diana, who happens to share the name of my favorite character in Oliver And Company! I love Oliver![/apple2012]

 

[-Apples-]

You're confusing me.

 

[Nimega]

I think that Punchy is a really overrated character. I mean, he's cool and nice and everything else, but I find him a bit meh.

 

[Jarrad]

..can we stop making these absolutely stupid threads about villager popularity...

we already have like 50 (and I'm not exaggerating)


learn how to use the search bar, people.

 

[spCrossing]

I think that Punchy is a really overrated character. I mean, he's cool and nice and everything else, but I find him a bit meh.

But he has such a cute design!

He's basically a cat that I would have.

- - - Post Merge - - -

..can we stop making these absolutely stupid threads about villager popularity...

we already have like 50 (and I'm not exaggerating)


learn how to use the search bar, people.

I know, but these threads aren't disappearing anytime soon.

Honestly, I just want to say that Rooney should be tier 3 and then go home.

 

[Jarrad]

But he has such a cute design!

He's basically a cat that I would have.

- - - Post Merge - - -


I know, but these threads aren't disappearing anytime soon.

Honestly, I just want to say that Rooney should be tier 3 and then go home.

I don't care about the thread's discussion

I care regarding the fact that this is like the 400532523rd duplicate thread about "overrated villagers"

 

[X2k5a7y]

..can we stop making these absolutely stupid threads about villager popularity...

we already have like 50 (and I'm not exaggerating)


learn how to use the search bar, people.

No, no no no no.
If you post in those, it's against the rules.
You're just supposed to make a new one.
I already got in trouble once, for "bumping" old threads.
If they're more than a few weeks old, they're irrelevant, and you have to make a new one.
This is the information, as it has been given to me.

 

[-Apples-]

I don't care about the thread's discussion

I care regarding the fact that this is like the 400532523rd duplicate thread about "overrated villagers"

I was about to say that, but I don't think the mods are as serious as LBPC is when it comes to multiple threads over the same controversy. However, the reason why we keep seeing 10^6 (a million) threads on overrated villagers is because of another rule - don't bump old threads. Would you rather see old and irrelevant threads hitting the first page again, or would you rather see multiple threads on the same subject?

- - - Post Merge - - -

No, no no no no.
If you post in those, it's against the rules.
You're just supposed to make a new one.
I already got in trouble once, for "bumping" old threads.
If they're more than a few weeks old, they're irrelevant, and you have to make a new one.
This is the information, as it has been given to me.

Not to mention, but I think it's worth getting an infraction for trying to infringe on someone's freedom of speech if you're not a mod. This is what Jarrad is doing. Telling us on not what to talk about when the rules have nothing against this subject.

 

[X2k5a7y]

I was about to say that, but I don't think the mods are as serious as LBPC is when it comes to multiple threads over the same controversy. However, the reason why we keep seeing 10^6 (a million) threads on overrated villagers is because of another rule - don't bump old threads. Would you rather see old and irrelevant threads hitting the first page again, or would you rather see multiple threads on the same subject?

- - - Post Merge - - -



Not to mention, but I think it's worth getting an infraction for trying to infringe on someone's freedom of speech if you're not a mod. This is what Jarrad is doing. Telling us on not what to talk about when the rules have nothing against this subject.

Well, it's not like Jarrad can make us stop posting threads about certain subjects. So, it really doesn't matter what they're opinion on the thread subject is. I, honestly, don't think the old threads are irrelevant. I wouldn't mind them being bumped. Like I said, I bumped some, once...But I also don't mind multiple threads on the same subject, because there are different people with different opinions than the ones in the old threads.

 

[PlasmaPower]

Like I said, there should be a pinned thread about this.

 

[X2k5a7y]

Like I said, there should be a pinned thread about this.

I guess there would be, if it was actually important.

 

[-Apples-]

Like I said, there should be a pinned thread about this.

This thread doesn't sound potential enough to be stickied.

 

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

A musical number about a certain flying mammal would represent this debate PERFECTLY!

Just replace the words "Vampire Bats" with "Overrated Villagers", and the part about apple-eating with taking residence in your village, and you're set!

 

[MeghanNewLeaf]

Pretty much every villager in Tier 1. I just don't think that any villager should be worth millions. D:

 

[turtlewigs]

I dont really care about tiers at all honestly, a lot of my favorites are all the way at the bottom of the barrel
but for some reason in this own ive been getting a lot of sought after villagers! Fang, Whitney, MARSHAL.
I have taken a kin to Fang, but I usually do to crankies anyways and i know I want t o keep marshal just in case i need something but whitney is eh ok. i dont get why shes that popular but i still enjoy her.

 

[CR33P]

this marks the millionth overrated/underrated villager thread

basically only marshal imo

- - - Post Merge - - -

No, no no no no.
If you post in those, it's against the rules.
You're just supposed to make a new one.
I already got in trouble once, for "bumping" old threads.
If they're more than a few weeks old, they're irrelevant, and you have to make a new one.
This is the information, as it has been given to me.

bumping threads is only not allowed when the topic is no longer relevant.