One more time: Villager Advice

[Majora Moon]

I have decided to make my town male heavy in villagers and make the town female heavy in humans. This way I can keep Hans and Ken, but that leaves me with a new dilemma. You see, I have two Tomboy (Uchi) villagers, and to have one of each personality type, I have to lose one of the two so I can move in Wolf Link

Should I keep Shari, one of the stars of Chuggaaconroy's Let's Play of the game and infamous supervillain, or should I keep Cherry the dawg who loves to rock out to hard metal? Or should I keep both and just not get a normal villager (Medli) and not have the complete Zelda set of villagers? I have the amiibo needed, so getting her is no problem.

I know I asked for this yesterday, but I would like advice on this one. Both sides gave good reasons as to why I should keep both Hans or Ken depending on who they said, so I decided to keep both, and get Wolf Link in the town too.

(As you can see I HATE the 10 villager limit)

 

[Euphy]

Shari. The design is pretty meh and I don't see it being a youtuber's villager as a good reason to not keep a villager you chose with your personal tastes or miss out on a personality type

 

[Sweetley]

Voted for Shari. Even if I know her from Chuggaaconroy's Let's Plays, I still find her boring to
be honest and I'm also not a big fan of the monkey villagers. I would keep Cherry at this point.

 

[Majora Moon]

Voted for Shari. Even if I know her from Chuggaaconroy's Let's Plays, I still find her boring to be honest and I'm also not a big fan of the monkey villagers. I would keep Cherry at this point.

Honestly, Monkeys are one of my favorite types of villager. That is one of the reasons I like her. If I am being honest a lot of the popular villager types like Squirrels all but one of the Dogs (Cherry) are mediocre to me. I much preffer things like Lions and Monkeys and even Hippos.

 

[maple22]

I voted for Shari.

 

[Sweetley]

Honestly, Monkeys are one of my favorite types of villager. That is one of the reasons I like her. If I am being honest a lot of the popular villager types like Squirrels all but one of the Dogs (Cherry) are mediocre to me. I much preffer things like Lions and Monkeys and even Hippos.

Hm, maybe at this point you should think about it which one you like more or which of the both
is more important to you. If monkeys are your favorites, maybe you should keep Shari then and
let Cherry go? (Also nice to see another person who likes the hippo villagers). I mean, it's up to
you of course!

 

[LadyDestani]

I voted to let Cherry go. I like the idea of having all the personality types and, since you're going that route, all the Legend of Zelda villagers.

I was torn between Shari and Cherry because they both have their pluses in my opinion, but Shari feels like a better fit with the rest of your villagers to me. The fact that you love monkey villagers is another point in her favor.

 

[Nougat]

I agree with what LadyDestani wrote, I think Shari will fit in better with your other villagers I'd definitely get the complete Zelda set of villagers, it's too cool not to do it! Good luck with your choice

 

[Kirbyz]

Please don't have Shari. She's so weird and creepy, not an enjoyable villager at all.

 

[AlyssaAC]

Like everyone else said, you should go for all Legend of Zelda villagers, as I think it would be pretty cool to have. So I voted to get rid of Cherry, since you like Shari a lot. I like her too by the way. Shari's pretty cool.

 

[Wallows]

This is biased because I've had Shari before so I think you should keep her if you think dogs are mediocre then give Cherry the boot! your choice though!

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Wow I don’t understand the hate for Shari, she’s one of the better Uchis! I vote Cherry!