I reset 15 times to start with Reneigh, got lucky and got Raymond in my campsite, and I'm currently working on moving Audie out of my spare town and into my main town. I found Audie on a mystery island.
I found Megan as my first encounter as my first move in. Sherb after going to island 40+ times looking for him I traded someone 45 nook tickets for him lol.
I got Sherb on a mystery hybrid island.
Don't really care much for the other new villagers - if I were to get them, I'd make them move in just to trade.
I got Marshal while I was trying to get a cranky villager. I ended up inviting him because he's cute and I know a lot of people would appreciate him when he eventually decide to move.