Neutral villagers

[PlasticPinkPiggy]

Has anyone had a villager *cough* dreamie *cough* that when you actually get to know them they are not your type so they become neutral to you?

Like for example, I always wanted peanut so badly and then I realised she was too peppy and kept repeating stuff over and over again, so I let her go. No regrets.

 

[Zanessa]

Hamlet.
You know, he just asked me about moving, and I never took so much time to think about it. But I never got his picture, so I made him stay. Also, for some weird reason, it took months before I warmed up to Carmen. >_>

 

[JaeJae]

Marina for me. She was my ultimate dreamie few weeks ago. I finally got her from campsite so she lived in my second town for awhile. She looks pretty plain to me in game. That's why I adopted Skye instead.

 

[monochrom3]

Cranston.

Used to be my dreamie until I saw Erik on my campsite.

 

[Cou]

Tia. :| She was so cute and always caught my attention when I would see her at someone else's town, but when I finally got her... Ehhh

 

[Farobi]

Merengue. I thought I'd like her but she didn't live up my expectations. Got rid of her thankfully.

 

[JellyBeans]

Hmm Deirdre used to be one of my dreamies but she asked to move and i said yes. She was too plain to me tbh

 

[PlasticPinkPiggy]

Merengue. I thought I'd like her but she didn't live up my expectations. Got rid of her thankfully.

Many of those "cute" villagers are like that

 

[Jinglefruit]

Marina for me, I'd never had an octopus villager in all my games, so I was excited for her, then she smashed her way into the middle of my front garden which wasn't a great start and I started noticing she looked awkward when she walked. I ended up getting rid of her as I wanted my garden back. I still quite like her, but she's no longer on my dreamie list.

 

[Yui Z]

This hasn't been the case for me yet... I try and talk to my villagers daily but lately I haven't had time to since I've been super busy redecorating my house and town :S

 

[FireNinja1]

Phoebe. I'm still keeping her though.

 

[Megan.]

Julian, he wasn't exactly a dreamy but I was really excited to have him in my second town.. he wasn't really my cup of tea to be honest. :c

 

[itzafennecfox]

Yup. I thought I wanted Agnes because she was an okay Uchi, and I needed an Uchi, but I really don't like her now that she's in my town.

 

[VioletsTown]

Diana, surprisingly. I loved her, but now, she's slowly losing her charm. It's like she's too pretty. I guess I need some imperfection somewhere.

 

[beffa]

Punchy. Probably because I had 3 lazies when he moved in and it jut got crazy repetitive. Plus he never came out of his house in my town n___n Also Lopez. His design got boring and eh.

 

[oak]

I'd say Marshal or Fauna.. They were over hyped for me, I feel boring with them in my town. Marshal moved in near the beginning of my game from my campsite, so I'd feel sad to lose him though. Mixed feelings.

 

[PandaBerryInSpace]

Penelope. I was so excited to get her, but when I had her, she was just so... Blah.

 

[Dembonez19]

Scoot. This was completely my fault though. When I invited him to stay, I had four jocks already: Rowan, Coach, Boone, and Poncho. It was just the same old stuff from all five of them. Poncho left first, then Scoot who was an actual "dreamie" of mine. Scoot didn't last very long in town, and I never got his pic. I'm okay with it though because I had way too many of one personality. Someone had to go.

 

[Bear_Crossing]

I guess, Monique.
I really like her, but I thought she'd be fiercer and more snooty-like, but she was extremely kind to me.
I still love her, though.
It's just, surprisingly, she's not as mean as I expected.

 

[ceribells]

Tia. :| She was so cute and always caught my attention when I would see her at someone else's town, but when I finally got her... Ehhh

Me too, actually. I still like her and want her in my town, but she's kind of dull. And I've had other normal personalities that I've really loved. Guess she's taking her time to warm up :/