Nan or Sally?

[Minimasher]

So recently I've discovered a love for Nan and am starting to wonder whether I want to replace Sally on my dreamies list. Part of the reason I want her is because she is underrated and I really want to make sure I have some underrated villagers on my island. I was wondering what other people think about me swapping Nan with Sally and I would also like to know whether other people like Nan or Sally more as I want to know which one is more underrated. Anyways who do you like more and who do you think I should keep?

 

[Clock]

Nan seems nice for a underrated villager, go for it, since you have a bit of interest for her. If you end up not liking her, you can also move Sally in as a replacement for Nan as well.

 

[seularin]

as chevre's former mother i must choose her bffie

 

[TheodoreCottontail]

Both are not very popular but I am bias and chose Nan. She lives on my island and has been great to have around. I like the exterior & interior of her house too.

 

[Minimasher]

For anyone wondering, this is Sally

And this is Nan

 

[Pyoopi]

I never had Sally but I did have Nan on my island for a short time.

I kind of like what Nan is based or referenced on, the whole japanese story about the black and white goat. I mean, it's really up to you, lol.

 

[Xara]

i personally like nan more - she’s so cute!

 

[BluebearL]

Nan is up there as one of my favourite goats! She is very sweet and has a shy look about her. Definitely very underrated, I also like having some underrated villagers on my island and nan would be perfect for that. Sally while still underrated is more popular from what I've seen. I don't like sally quiet as much myself but in the end it's up to you.

 

[Opal]

Sally! I have her and she is so cute <3

 

[sfelix]

I choose Nan but I can't have Nan without also having Chevre.

 

[Scrafty]

they're both good but i like sally's chill vibe more

 

[wolfie1]

I'm not personally fond of either but Nan reminds me of Chevre, so I'll vote for her.

 

[Manon_Despoina]

It seems you like Nan more - since you mention Sally only in the context of her being an underrated villager (though I am sure you like her as well ). Though, personally, I like Sally way more (she will end up on my island some time and I am debating with myself over having the possibility of three normal villagers over all character types. Or sacrificing Fauna or Poppy on my dreamy list).

 

[Bk1234]

I had Sally in New Leaf, and she really grew on me. My pick, stick with Sally. Nan just doesn't compare.

 

[Hats002]

I adore sally, she's really sweet and friendly! she always makes me smile : )

 

[Aliya]

Nan is one of my favorites! She is super sweet and I love having both her and Chevre on my island. If you're on the fence about her, you're more than welcome to visit my island and talk to her/see her house.