My villagers are ugly!

faceburn

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2016
Posts
312
Bells
863
It took me a while to find a good town layout where the ramp from the dock goes straight up vertically to retail and the new camp ground. I also wanted a bridge in the middle with the town plaza in the middle and next to the town hall.

So I got a decent town layout, not the best but good enough. Everything went good so far or so I thought..... Ugly villagers and cherry of all fruit. I had cherry in 3 play through of Wild World. Why do the gods only bestow cherry for me?

None of my villagers are memorable and are all mostly ugly except Marshall who is short. I have two of the ugliest villagers in any of my town. A lion name Bud (dark skin tan) that doesn't have eyes, a dog name Benjamin that need to be shot like Old Yeller (cause he a golden retriever too). Another animal with no eyes in Peaches the horse or donkey which I can' tell. i have old Hamphrey who is old. I have Puddles, a pink frog and I hate frog. I have Noami an Asian cow.

In short, here are my New leaf villagers: Hamphrey, Noami, Bud, Benjamin, Marshal, Peaches, and Puddles. None are memorable, two don't have eyes, and the rest of them are either old or ugly.

I really wish you could either A: copy your town layout and keep resetting until you get your perfect starting five villagers or B: Let you have multiple save files (you can play the game longer per session).


So those are my villagers. What are you guys thoughts on them and if you have a town full of uglies, please share them as well.

Also while my town is practical for money making and convenient, it not a pretty town layout in the real world (not looking at the map).
 
marshal is incredibly popular, so even if you don't like him you could trade or sell him on here, hahah.

i never mind whoever i start with, because i know i'll end up replacing them with my dreamies eventually anyway. the amount of people on the forums with sets of cards willing to sell villagers makes it easier than ever. if you got your perfect map, just grin and bear it until you can move out your less than stellar buddies.
 
There are so many villagers in the game it's hard to get villagers you actually like. It's fine tbh, getting a good layout is the hard part. And personally, I prefer when my starting villagers are meh so that I can move them out and place my actual dreamies perfectly instead of having to work with the initial placements the game gives me.
 
There are so many villagers, the game picks them randomly. At least you know that they will all eventually move out! :) I started with some villagers I didn't like or thought were ugly lol I got rid of them eventually.
 
There is a Villager for anybody. I like the mice and frog Villagers, which appear to not be very popular in general. But I have also noticed people that do really like them, so they have their niches. At one point, there were more Villagers than Pokemon so of course there will be some you find ugly.

As others said, people in the trading sub-forums may be willing to trade for the Villagers you do not like.
 
is marshal being short a bad thing? for me I don't care much for big villager like giant bears, elephants, julian and rhinos.
 
is marshal being short a bad thing? for me I don't care much for big villager like giant bears, elephants, julian and rhinos.

I sort of like it when everybody was the same size. I know it cool that you can see a height differences but I like the old way better. On the other hand, height differences are super cool with Pokemon Sun and Moon. I guess it varies by games for me.

Marshal being short makes me think I have a town full of midgets. Puddles, Marshal, and Hamphrey. Half of my neighbors are midgets.
 
Peaches! Omg, she's so ugly. Why are her eyes + marks? And I really dislike her color scheme.
 
Peaches! Omg, she's so ugly. Why are her eyes + marks? And I really dislike her color scheme.

Yeah I thought she was suppose to be pretty cause of her name but her eyes.... I have 5 ugly villagers and then I got Marshall so I was like "okay, as long as the remaining 4 villagers are not ugly, I think this will be okay" but nope I keep getting ugly villagers. Peaches is my 7th villagers and unless Whitney is in my last three villagers, this is by far the ugliest town I ever had.
 
I like Puddles, I have a soft spot for her from AC:WW. Marshal is annoying and Naomi is beyond nasty. However you can probably trade Marshal for any villager you want since he's so popular. But I guess all you can do is cycle them out via TTing or amiibo cards, move in new villagers via the campsite and adoption, or just wait it out. Maybe they'll grow on you.
 
I like Puddles, I have a soft spot for her from AC:WW. Marshal is annoying and Naomi is beyond nasty. However you can probably trade Marshal for any villager you want since he's so popular. But I guess all you can do is cycle them out via TTing or amiibo cards, move in new villagers via the campsite and adoption, or just wait it out. Maybe they'll grow on you.

Puddles is a darl but I just don't like frog. There is like 35 types of animal species as neighbor and so I don't need a frog. Puddles has grown on me because of her personality but I have never forced any of my villagers to move out in any of my past WW towns. I'm anxiously waiting for the remaining 3 villagers I have left to show up. Finger-cross one of them is Whitney. Yeah she was mean to me but she so pretty that it okay.

Why is Marshal so popular?
 
Why is Marshal so popular?

I fail to see his appeal. He was in my campsite and I let him move in so I could sell him for a lot of money or sought-after items. This backfired on me when I didn't wanna be rude and ask for too much so I sold him off for a million bells and a small handful of pink flowers and a golden rose.
 
Back
Top