Muffy or Cherry? Who's spookier?

[salem_]

Ok after the cranky poll im now doing the uchi one!
I do like them both, I currently have Muffy, which is one of my starter and has basic interiors. I'm trying to figure out who could be better for a spooky island. Any advice?

 

[Manah]

Cherry if you want a spooky house, Muffy if you want a spooky villager (but get her back with her real interior)

 

[brockbrock]

If you are planning to get Lucky as well, for the sake of villager diversity I would say stick with Muffy, otherwise I’d go for Cherry!

 

[rubyy]

definitely muffy!! something about her make up and eyes is creepy mysterious (it’s like she’s seen a ghost)


she was one of my starters too ^^

 

[Mosshead]

Muffy for sure, Cherry doesn't really evoke spookiness to me.

 

[Blueskyy]

Muffy is spookier. Cherry is cooler. Look into Roscoe and Mathilda too

 

[Ciary]

Cherry is a goth
Muffy is possessed

Definitely Muffy

 

[Orieii]

Muffy for sure! She was one of my starter villagers Cherry seems more punk rock to me

 

[daisyy]

muffy by far! the eye makeup, the dark clothes, she spooks me more. cherry looks like another rock band groupie hahaha.

 

[Iced_Holly]

I have Cherry and to me she envokes punk rock far more than 'spooky'. Muffy would be the better choice in this situation

 

[Arckaniel]

Muffy for sure, I won't consider Cherry spooky actually, I agree on the above posts, more punk rock band kind of vibes

 

[Alicia]

I'd say Muffy has a spookier appearance than Cherry does. I don't really consider Cherry spooky and agree with the posts above mine.
I prefer Cherry's design to Muffy's, but I don't think she's spooky!