Most loved/Most hated Sonic Game?
- Thread starter Redsonic
- Start date
Earth Wolf-Howl
The Dreamer
My favourite would probably be Unleashed, whereas my least favourite would be Sonic and the Secret Rings. Thankfully I haven't had the misfortune to play Boom...
Sonic and secret wrongs was originally a port of Sonic 06, ofcourse it's going to suck arse.
To be honest, I hate Sonic 4 Part 1 and 2, just came out too late compared to the classics and just plays meh.
Honorable (bad) mentions being: Sonic Rush Adventure (1st was decent) Sonic Colors (DS) Sonic Boom and the various "Gems" collections.
However Sonic Adventure is muh fave, 2 was good but it just kinda lacked an adventure, it was just level -> cutscene -> level -> cutscene -> cutscene -> level (and so on)
Needed more of a hub world, Chao garden wasn't enough to be a hub tbh.
To be honest, I hate Sonic 4 Part 1 and 2, just came out too late compared to the classics and just plays meh.
Honorable (bad) mentions being: Sonic Rush Adventure (1st was decent) Sonic Colors (DS) Sonic Boom and the various "Gems" collections.
However Sonic Adventure is muh fave, 2 was good but it just kinda lacked an adventure, it was just level -> cutscene -> level -> cutscene -> cutscene -> level (and so on)
Needed more of a hub world, Chao garden wasn't enough to be a hub tbh.
Last edited:
DarkDesertFox
Your Typical Trickster
As a big Sonic fan it breaks my heart to see how bad the games have been doing lately. I've enjoyed them up to Unleashed (with the Sochi Winter Olympics being an exception). My all time favorite Sonic game will always be Sonic Adventure 2 Battle. I love so many of the games; Sonic Riders, Sonic R, Sonic the Fighters, Sonic Shuffle, you name it. I would have to agree with you though that Boom is the worst. I had high hopes when I first heard about it, but the game's difficulty and level of fun is at an all time low for Sonic.
spCrossing
80s anime is cool
Most loved: Sonic 3 & Knuckles.
Most Hated: Shadow the Hedgehog
Most Hated: Shadow the Hedgehog
Last edited:
Mega_Cabbage
Meh
Sonic Adventure is my favorite. Like Hyogo said, the hub world won me over. I thought Sonic Boom was going to be good compared to the more recent Sonic games, but it just doesn't seem like a Sonic game anymore.
spCrossing
80s anime is cool
Generations is also an amazing game.
I'm surprised that not many people played it. :c
I'm surprised that not many people played it. :c
RainbowCherry
Bus Thanker
I hate every single game before Sonic Adventure. It (Sonic Adventure) was decent, I HATED Sonic Adventure 2 except for story, music and Sonic and Shadow stages, Everything past Heroes was amazing bar Secret Rings, Lost World, Sonic Boom and Runners. My favourite is either Sonic and the Black Knight or Sonic Generations (Mainly the 3D stages.).
Last edited:
Thievius Raccoonus
The True Master Thief
Loved: Sonic Heroes, SA1, SA2, ShTH
Hated: Secret Rings, Fighters, Labyrinth
Hated: Secret Rings, Fighters, Labyrinth
My favorite is easily Sonic 2. Partially because of nostalgia, partially because it was still in the period where Sonic still really focused on lots of platforming rather than running forwards whilst the game plays itself...
Worst? Sonic Adventure 1. I didn't like it that much to begin with but it's also aged horribly, making it worse than it already was. Sonic Adventure 2 wasn't much better but at least it didn't have Big the Cat.
I just generally don't like many of the 3D Sonic games. The controls always feel like it's a bad Steam game.
Worst? Sonic Adventure 1. I didn't like it that much to begin with but it's also aged horribly, making it worse than it already was. Sonic Adventure 2 wasn't much better but at least it didn't have Big the Cat.
I just generally don't like many of the 3D Sonic games. The controls always feel like it's a bad Steam game.
PlasmaPower
I'm watching you nerds
I like Generations, if only because you can give the game mods on the PC version.
As for what I don't like, Lost World on the 3DS. The areas past the second area drag on forever, and there's the traditional Dimps level designs, such as bottomless pits and dash pads everywhere, and the cutscenes are horribly compressed; and don't get me started on the special stages...
As for what I don't like, Lost World on the 3DS. The areas past the second area drag on forever, and there's the traditional Dimps level designs, such as bottomless pits and dash pads everywhere, and the cutscenes are horribly compressed; and don't get me started on the special stages...
Last edited:
Most loved is probably SA2B, or the original one for the genesis. Nostalgia is a big part of that ^^
Most hated is the infamous Sonic 06? But the most broken, unplayable game in the series is Sonic Free Riders. I heard it gave people physical pain when they played it and it was impossible to control.
Most hated is the infamous Sonic 06? But the most broken, unplayable game in the series is Sonic Free Riders. I heard it gave people physical pain when they played it and it was impossible to control.
PlasmaPower
I'm watching you nerds
Then you must've played the GameCube version, because Big The Cat had cameos everywhere in the Dreamcast, and HD versions of the game.
Shadow the Hedgehog was also pretty awful. The story made no sense and what is even the purpose of the guns and the slow vehicles when Shadow can run at super sanic speed, use chaos blast/control/spear and carry ten times his weight naturally
Last edited:
Thievius Raccoonus
The True Master Thief
To me, I liked ShTH cause of all of the different storylines you have because it allowed you to piece together your own thoughts on who/what is Shadow. Yes, I understand that they all converged into one story at the end, but I still liked the idea that everything you did shaped what happened until that point. However, for the guns unless they were a key part of the challenge, I left them alone for the most part, same with the vehicles. Though, you can't really say much about the Chaos Spear as he doesn't get a chance to use it until The Final Way.
I did. Thank Zeus they took him out of that version!
I have the HD version on Steam (well, what I assume is the HD version). I wouldn't know if he's there or not though since I couldn't put up with the controls long enough to find out.
I liked the game and enjoyed the game, but honestly.. It seemed like SEGA tried too hard to make Shadow a badass when everyone knew he was one already.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I have Sonic Free Riders on my shelf and I've been too nervous to play it. The Angry Joe video about it was like a huge warning not to. XD
- - - Post Merge - - -
I have Sonic Free Riders on my shelf and I've been too nervous to play it. The Angry Joe video about it was like a huge warning not to. XD
Thievius Raccoonus
The True Master Thief
Okay, I will agree with that comment 100%. They did try to overdo Shadow's personality a little bit too much. However, it sounds like you'd agree with me on this: if they didn't put in the extra weaponry and vehicles, or at least put some MEANING behind them, it would be at least 50% better.
