Don't have much of an opinion of him yet other than agreeing with his suspicion of Sid a little.
Mafia Mini Mafia XI: Frozen [End Game]
- Thread starter Cariad
- Start date
Don't have much of an opinion of him yet other than agreeing with his suspicion of Sid a little.
Gingersnap
World's Best Dad
Phew, came home from work to get a nice chunk of detail for Mafia!
I really want to say the mistake Sid made was just a newbie mistake but that happened in another Mafia and they ended up scum. (That other Mafia being Mean Girls.)
I've only played Mafia with SP once and even though I don't quite agree with the way they phrase certain posts, they are still a good player. They played this way in MG Mafia and ended up town. From other posts, this is apparently their play style in other Mafia games as well. So in short, I do agree with SP regarding his suspicion of Sid.
However I would like to see more posts from Sid bringing up defense against herself.
I really want to say the mistake Sid made was just a newbie mistake but that happened in another Mafia and they ended up scum. (That other Mafia being Mean Girls.)
I've only played Mafia with SP once and even though I don't quite agree with the way they phrase certain posts, they are still a good player. They played this way in MG Mafia and ended up town. From other posts, this is apparently their play style in other Mafia games as well. So in short, I do agree with SP regarding his suspicion of Sid.
However I would like to see more posts from Sid bringing up defense against herself.
tinytaylor
baby blue sedan
I've kind of given up on sid.. anyway did anyone notice for this game
death notes are in play instead of wills?
death notes are in play instead of wills?
Gingersnap
World's Best Dad
Honestly, any defense is better than no defense at all.
I also just checked to see if they were online anywhere and they were viewing a Mini Mafia thread, the one that was Game Over'ed. I don't know if they participated in it though.
I also just checked to see if they were online anywhere and they were viewing a Mini Mafia thread, the one that was Game Over'ed. I don't know if they participated in it though.
tinytaylor
baby blue sedan
they said they watched it but it didn't help.
i did not participate in that game in any way. i thought if i read through it i could understand how this game works better.
PurplPanda
not at disneyworld
In my book, Sid2125 is suspicious as hell. They're relying on their newbishness, they essentially gave up, said they didn't give up, and as Nick said they had an idea and discredited it. If nothing else comes up, I'm voting for her.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
#LynchPurpl2k14
Agreed. If no one else is a blatantly obvious suspect of being scum and she is unable to put up a half-decent fight, I'm voting Sid.
Yes i may be new. i used that as an excuse in the beginning. I gave up on that because its a poor excuse and does not help with suspiciousness. i didnt know that stating an idea and discrediting it was a scummy move. i dont want to give up at ALL. i was just overwhelmed with how quick everybody became suspicious of me and how they thought so deep into what i said. I was just a little overloaded.
I literally have no idea what you being a girl has to do with anything. Many people are misgendered on this site (especially in mafia). Give some evidence that you're not sus because you sure as hell sound like it.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
Today is Monday.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
Well thank you 
[18:33:26] 18<Elise-> hey scum
[18:37:04] 6<Cory6> what
[18:37:20] 18<Elise-> u heard me
[18:37:32] 6<Cory6> well im not scum
[18:38:10] 18<Elise-> whats townies role then
[18:38:10] 18<Elise-> v.v
[18:38:24] 6<Cory6> did i say im townie?
[18:38:39] 6<Cory6> I'm not telling you my role
[18:38:44] 6<Cory6> I don't trust you
[18:38:56] 18<Elise-> hehehehehe
[18:38:58] 18<Elise-> u dont know townies role
[18:39:01] 18<Elise->
[18:39:23] 6<Cory6> oh pls
[18:39:32] 6<Cory6> your scum tricks
[18:39:37] 18<Elise-> cory pls
[18:39:41] 6<Cory6> only scum approaches others
[18:39:41] 18<Elise-> i am vanilla town
[18:39:45] 18<Elise-> whats the role name
[18:39:47] 18<Elise-> ?
[18:39:57] 6<Cory6> I don't trust me
[18:40:06] 6<Cory6> I bet you just want to know it for yourself
[18:40:07] 18<Elise-> wOW
[18:40:10] 18<Elise-> no
[18:40:15] 18<Elise-> im not falling for that
[18:40:43] 6<Cory6> go ask someone else what it's called if you want to know
[18:40:51] 18<Elise-> no
[18:44:10] 18<Elise-> i know what ur doing cory \\evil laughter
[18:44:20] 18<Elise-> no but really whats vanilla towns role name if you claimed town
[18:45:30] 6<Cory6> I didn't claim townie
[18:47:33] 18<Elise-> yea u did
[18:47:34] 18<Elise->
[18:47:44] 18<Elise-> ur lying
[18:47:46] 6<Cory6> where?
Alise came up to me and pmed me. When has she ever done that? Also she is asking me for the townie name she is probably to claim to other as because she is scum, that is why I didn't give it to her. She has not responded after I said where, because I didn't say it anywhere and probably going to the scum chat for help. She is acting very scummy.
[18:37:04] 6<Cory6> what
[18:37:20] 18<Elise-> u heard me
[18:37:32] 6<Cory6> well im not scum
[18:38:10] 18<Elise-> whats townies role then
[18:38:10] 18<Elise-> v.v
[18:38:24] 6<Cory6> did i say im townie?
[18:38:39] 6<Cory6> I'm not telling you my role
[18:38:44] 6<Cory6> I don't trust you
[18:38:56] 18<Elise-> hehehehehe
[18:38:58] 18<Elise-> u dont know townies role
[18:39:01] 18<Elise->
[18:39:23] 6<Cory6> oh pls
[18:39:32] 6<Cory6> your scum tricks
[18:39:37] 18<Elise-> cory pls
[18:39:41] 6<Cory6> only scum approaches others
[18:39:41] 18<Elise-> i am vanilla town
[18:39:45] 18<Elise-> whats the role name
[18:39:47] 18<Elise-> ?
[18:39:57] 6<Cory6> I don't trust me
[18:40:06] 6<Cory6> I bet you just want to know it for yourself
[18:40:07] 18<Elise-> wOW
[18:40:10] 18<Elise-> no
[18:40:15] 18<Elise-> im not falling for that
[18:40:43] 6<Cory6> go ask someone else what it's called if you want to know
[18:40:51] 18<Elise-> no
[18:44:10] 18<Elise-> i know what ur doing cory \\evil laughter
[18:44:20] 18<Elise-> no but really whats vanilla towns role name if you claimed town
[18:45:30] 6<Cory6> I didn't claim townie
[18:47:33] 18<Elise-> yea u did
[18:47:34] 18<Elise->
[18:47:44] 18<Elise-> ur lying
[18:47:46] 6<Cory6> where?
Alise came up to me and pmed me. When has she ever done that? Also she is asking me for the townie name she is probably to claim to other as because she is scum, that is why I didn't give it to her. She has not responded after I said where, because I didn't say it anywhere and probably going to the scum chat for help. She is acting very scummy.
Ok so with SuperPenguin, like I said, he's literally doing a me when I'm town. Throwing his opinions out without a second thought for the consequences. SuperPenguin has played enough games to know YOU DON'T FLASH YOUR ARSE ON DAY ONE, closed game or not. I know full well he won't slip up this early in the game. He could use this as a tactic but this is not how he's played scum in the past.
Now, Sid2125.
The first highlighted section, I am glad you picked this up, you're new yes but that's the worst excuse ever, don't ever use it. The second highlighted bit, welcome to mafia, chew others before they chew you up and spit you out.
Collect your thoughts, quick, time is very much ticking. You need to defend yourself as soon as you can, if and I said IF lightly, you're not mafia, you're wasting our time by not defending yourself correctly. People will have PM circles going any time soon and if you're not part of one or have even spoken to someone else then you're in trouble.
Stop getting fired up, its a game, and everyone is trying to do the same as you, I hope and find out who mafia is.
So in a nut shell, I'm tired and I've had one role claim already, I will not tell you who or what but I have and if this person is who they say they are, then it is helpful.
Similar threads
- Poll
