melba or agnes (´•̥ ᵔ •̥`)

[seularin]

ahhh agnes is in my campsite--really want her to replace simon and shes pretty cute also want her to piss off my sister
though i've been trying for ages to kick out simon for melba (´•̥ ᵔ •̥`) i really don't wanna resort to kicking out one of my other 9 villagers ( they're all my dreamies :c ) to have both of them >< --OR should i drop both of them

 

[Fendi]

I would pick Melba, her little hat in her poster is so adorable.
Agnes is cute, but that's where it ends for me.

 

[Le Ham]

They're both solid choices! Maybe you could let Agnes replace Simon for a little while and then switch her out for Melba later on if you want, unless you think you'd become too attached to Agnes in that time?

 

[Hedgehugs]

Personally, I would go for Melba. She's pretty cute and I don't see enough people have her. I honestly think I would allow her on my island if I came across her.

I would only take Agnes If I needed an Uchi (Even though I prefer like 5 other uchi's first)

edit: Though I find the amusing option of dropping them both if you really can't pick. No one's a winner when everyone's a winner.

 

[cheezu]

Both the villagers have different personality types so it would kind of depend on whether I'm missing a personality (I like to have all personalities on my Island and I'm currently missing a jock which is driving me bonkers).

 

[Aliya]

I'd only pick Agnes if you need an uchi since it sounds like you prefer Melba. Your 10th villager doesn't ping often to move out so I'd go for someone you really want.

 

[moonbox]

her

 

[MelodyRivers]

Melba is so sweet. I love having her on my island. Her house is cute too. I vote melba

 

[Clock]

Melba since you like her more than Agnes. I like both, but Agnes should move in if you lack an uchi villager.

 

[Xara]

hhng i personally would pick agnes; she’s a cutie ;;

 

[N a t]

I really like Agnes but Melba is just

 

[Blueskyy]

I just like Melba too much not too vote her over a pig I have no feelings for.