It's so hard to choose! All of the villager are nice
I really love Genji and Maple on your BF's list <3 but I also adore Mira, Julian, Cheri, Rudy and Marshal on you and your girlfriend's list
this is kind of silly bc like...each list has villagers i love but also villagers i hate so i'm like so true neutral on this. also a silly argument to begin with hah