Me vs Girlfriend vs Best Friend! Dreamie battle!

[Taj]

So the 3 of us have been arguing who has the best dreamies. None of us can make up our minds so I want your opinions!
My dreamies:
Stitches
Molly
Ankha
Marshal
Zucker
Chief
Apollo
Cheri
Rudy
Phoebe

Girlfriend's dreamies:
Diana
Phoebe
Sprinkle
Tia
Coco
Pietro
Ribbot
Mira
Julian
Flora

Best Friend's Dreamies:
Chief
Bunnie
Bob
Mitzi
Rosie
Olivia
Genji
Wolfgang
Lucky
Maple

 

[Serif]

None of you have the best. You all got villagers you wanted and that's what matters. There's no argument here.

 

[misspiggy95]

None of you have the best. You all got villagers you wanted and that's what matters. There's no argument here.

this^

 

[mitzi_crossing]

None of you have the best. You all got villagers you wanted and that's what matters. There's no argument here.

Yeah I kind of have to agree with this. You all have great dreamies and what matters is that the person likes them. Other peoples opinions shouldnt matter

 

[moonford]

I agree with Serif.
^.^

 

[Rasha]

BF dreamies because of Wolfgang and Bob <3

 

[Paperboy012305]

Aww come on now! It doesn't matter! Who you like is who you like. Tell that to your GF and BFF and maybe they'll stop fighting over it.

 

[Taj]

Aww come on now! It doesn't matter! Who you like is who you like. Tell that to your GF and BFF and maybe they'll stop fighting over it.

Um that's not gonna happen. I think I need to reword myself, it was 5am when I made this post. If you had a town, which of the lists has your favorite villagers? Ot which list would you want in your town?

 

[Paperboy012305]

Um that's not gonna happen. I think I need to reword myself, it was 5am when I made this post. If you had a town, which of the lists has your favorite villagers? Ot which list would you want in your town?

Yeah... You're totally not seeing this...

All of them are great! And the tier list on any AC related site doesn't cut this.

I can't believe you don't agree with this. Serif, misspiggy95, mitzi_crossing, Whiteflamingo and I do. I do not know why you don't. So just deal with it?

 

[Mick]

Your best friend obviously has the best dreamies, since I don't see any I dislike. Their town is therefore superior, and much more fun to play in than the other two.

Tell them I think they won the argument!

 

[Red Cat]

Come on everyone! Enough with the political correctness. The best friend clearly has the best dreamies. neester14 has too many tier 1s which suggests he caves too much to peer pressure. The girlfriend is trying too hard to be girly with Diana, Sprinkle, Tia, and Flora. The best friend has a nice balance of male and female villagers and most importantly has a lot of cats

 

[TheGreatBrain]

That's a tough one. You all have some great villagers, but I have to pick your girlfriends. She has quite a few that I really like.

 

[ams]

Based on how many I like from each list I'd have to go with:

1: yours (Molly, Cheri, Rudy)
2: your friend's (Mitzi, Maple)
3: your girlfriend's (I only like Sprinkle from that list)

 

[snowblizzard24]

Technically if we are going with the tier system, yours would be "better" since you have so many tier ones and I've seen them so many times before in dream towns and dreamie lists. However, each list has its own merit just as yours does. Your girlfriend seems to really like the cutesy characters, which would fit into any fairytale and fun theme, and your best friend has lots of cat and wolf characters which are pretty popular species many people want in their town. It really shouldn't be a competition since people like who they like. Serif has the right opinion in that manner. However, I do like your girlfriend's list a little more since I've had the majority of her villagers in my own town before.

 

[Serif]

Come on everyone! Enough with the political correctness. The best friend clearly has the best dreamies. neester14 has too many tier 1s which suggests he caves too much to peer pressure. The girlfriend is trying too hard to be girly with Diana, Sprinkle, Tia, and Flora. The best friend has a nice balance of male and female villagers and most importantly has a lot of cats

It's not really political correctness. I truly don't believe there's an argument lol.
Also didn't expect so much agreement .-.

 

[mitzi_crossing]

Come on everyone! Enough with the political correctness. The best friend clearly has the best dreamies. neester14 has too many tier 1s which suggests he caves too much to peer pressure. The girlfriend is trying too hard to be girly with Diana, Sprinkle, Tia, and Flora. The best friend has a nice balance of male and female villagers and most importantly has a lot of cats

Umm, maybe their girlfriend just simply likes those villagers. Way to categorize and stereotype them as 'girly' I know lots of males that like those 4 you mentioned.

 

[Red Cat]

Umm, maybe their girlfriend just simply likes those villagers. Way to categorize and stereotype them as 'girly' I know lots of males that like those 4 you mentioned.

I was half joking there. There's nothing wrong with having those villagers; I just feel like people who have that many of those really feminine looking villagers in their towns kind of reinforce those stereotypes. Those villagers are not as extreme compared to the people who have Diana, Merengue, and Marina all in the same town, but I like the best friend's town more because it has a better mix of masculine and feminine villagers while the girlfriend just has mostly feminine looking villagers.

 

[Mega_Cabbage]

Yeah it's definitely Best Friend.

 

[Awesomeness1230]

None of you have the best. You all got villagers you wanted and that's what matters. There's no argument here.

I agree. No villager is better than the other. It's all just personal preference. But if I had to choose,
I would go yours.

 

[Elation]

I'd say your gf dreamies.