Marshal VS Stitches

[Claude]

I love Marshal. He's so tiny and he plopped his house right next to mine. He's my first smug villager, and it's cute how it sounds like he flirts with you (even though my mayor is male).

I have Stitches' Amiibo card, but the "X" eyes freak me out so I won't be moving him in. My brain associates "X" eyes with being dead.

 

[buttonfactories]

I have a fondness for villagers that resemble real animals, so I prefer Marshal to Stitches. I've had Marshal in my town for a few years, but I had never really been on ACNL forums until a few months ago so I had no idea he was so popular!

 

[ellsieotter]

I've never cared for marshal. I have stitches in my town and he is soo cute and his house is the best!

 

[Mink777]

Neither, I get sick of seeing them in every signature and dream town.

 

[pocky]

I love both Marshal and Stitches. They're both in my main town and I don't plan on getting rid of either... but I guess I'd be most devastated if Stitches left

 

[sylviabee]

I've had both and prefer Stitches.

 

[Sweetley]

I prefer Stitches. Never liked Marshal so much tbh.

 

[A spooky ghost!]

I prefer Marshall just because Ive had Stitches so much in other towns, I never really got the Stitches hype☺

 

[al-tirah]

Between the two, I'd say Marshal. I like his frowning face and those rosy cheeks.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I've had them both and Marshal is the one I never got bored of. Stitches is cute and I like his colourful design, but there is something about Marshal, maybe his little head and cute expression. He asked to leave me the other week, I've been deciding what to do as there's a lot of new villagers I wanted to move in, so I initially said yes...and he said we have been such good friends that he thought I would have asked him to stay obviously after that I needed to change his mind. Just really need his card now so I can move his house, pretty sure he won't ever be leaving

 

[Gaby]

After having both and sending one away, I will say: Stitches. I never could get to love Marshal. And I think visually, Stitches is cuter lol

 

[namiieco]

Always Marshal. I find Stitches "eyes" to be too small.

 

[Zireael]

I've never had either of them in my town but if I were to choose, I'd pick Marshal. Stitches looks really creepy to me, but Marshal's grumpy face is kind of cute. Still don't think I really like either though.

 

[Bcat]

Stitches. He was one of my starters in cf and one of my fave villagers. Marshall is cute but highly overrated in my book and doesn't have Stitches unique factor

 

[Alyx]

I voted for Stitches because he's like a little teddy baby.

 

[papyrus]

Sorry Stitches but the little fluffy grumpy marshmallow always wins.

 

[clueleaf]

As much as I love Marshal, I'm gonna have to say Stitches. He's much more colorful and brings back tons of childhood nostalgia for me.

 

[Vickie]

♥ i have both of them in my town right now
and i love both of them <3
but i really like marshal better,
he's so cute!! ♥
~♚Vickie​

 

[CatsAreSuperCool]

Definitely Marshal. He's adorable! I used to have him in my town, but he moved out

 

[Flare]

Ehh... I like both of em...
But I voted for Stitches anyway.