Marshal VS Stitches

[GalacticGhost]

.

 

[HungryForCereal]

I once had stitches in my town but he moved away. Now i have marshal. But seriously, i like them both and its impossible to choose between them. Maybe marshal a little more over stitches.

 

[Vanilly Lilly]

I dont know their personality but just from the look i like Marshal more.They look both pretty cool though

 

[PaperCat]

I prefer Marshal over Stitches. I have Marshal in my town, not because I wanted him (tho he is a squirrel and fits my theme), but he was in my campsite. I might get rid of him, but I kinda like him, so maybe I'll keep him.

 

[HopeForHyrule]

Stitches is love; Stitches is life.

 

[tealseer]

the ultimate showdown lmao

 

[derezzed]

Both are pretty overrated, and I'm not fond of either, but I voted for Stitches because I personally prefer lazy villagers over smug villagers.

 

[Yumei]

Aiya, I have them both & adore them to pieces. & yet I voted Marshal. There are quite a few cute & bizarre villagers but Marshal is a mini. tsundere. smug. cute. fluffy poof of a squirrel. <3

 

[Bloobloop]

Marshal~ He's pretty darn adorable!

 

[Lucizzle]

Stitches is masterrace. I've had Stitches in two towns, and he is the single most adorable villager ever. I like Marshall, but I've never had him in a town before, so I can't have a legit opinion on him.

 

[Astro Cake]

Marshal, because I think Stitches' appearance is a little unsettling.

 

[HungryForCereal]

theres a reason why marshal is a the top of tier 1 ya know?

 

[Dorian]

Gotta go with Marshal

 

[Uly]

Stitches definitely~

 

[RiceBunny]

I have both. Marshal I got myself and Sitches was given to me. I prefer Marshal.

 

[Balam Ajaw]

Where is the option "I don't like them"?

 

[Sansa]

That's a hard choice, they're both super cute!

I've never had either in my villages, but if I had to pick one that I like slightly better, it's Marshal.

 

[Selky]

Eh, I'm not really a huge fan of either...but I actually do really love albino squirrels from an animal standpoint...so I would say Marshal's design/species appeals more to me from the two.
I'm not really a fan of Stitches coloring...I can see why people find him cute though.

 

[Crash]

Stitches! I had him in a previous cycling town and my first thought was that he was creepy with his lack of eyes, but I grew to love him. Now I'm trying to get him for my main town. He's a cute lil teddy <3
I think Marshal is super overrated. I always have. He's cute, but nothing special in my opinion, I think other villagers are cuter.​

 

[Halloqueen]

Stitches wins this for me with no contest. I love his design and would totally add him to my horror movie town if you were able to have more than 10 villagers.

I don't understand the popularity Marshal has attained. I rather dislike his design, especially because he lacks a nose. It just looks sort of lazily thrown together. He also has an ugly cow rug in his house. The only positive I can see is that apparently he has a bunch of the sloppy furniture in his house.