Marshal VS Stitches

[amybear91]

I have Marshal and at first, I didn't think I was going to like him because he just looked like he was one of the grumpy characters, but once I got to know him I really liked him and now he's one of my favourite villagers ^_^

 

[Cinnamoos]

I like Marshal better because I ended up absolutely loving the smug personality. But I had Stitches in my city folk town and he was really adorbs.

 

[Megan.]

I've never had either of them and I don't really see what the fuss is to be honest.
But I guess Stitches.. just because he looks better.​

 

[fletnez]

I'm definitely a Stitches fan ever since I had him in Wild World. Hopefully I can get him again in New Leaf.

 

[Gizmodo]

Thought this would be interesting for new members to vote
Still have Stitches in my town, but no Marshal and i'm still fully in Camp Stitches

 

[Omfa]

I prefer Marshal.

 

[beffa]

Marshal.

 

[Amnesia]

Sorry but Marshal.

 

[Senrab]

Stitches. I have him and he's my favorite.

 

[Cress]

Marshal only because he's the only one I've ever and currently have in my town.

 

[hellFlower]

personally, i don't like either of them! i think their designs are ugly (especially stitches) uwu
if i had to choose though, i'd pick marshall. squirrels are a ton cuter than teddybears

 

[aetherene]

I love Stitches <3

He's one of my original five in NL. And he's so sweet and adorable. <3

But I've never had Marshal so I can't really comment.

 

[xxLollyxx]

I have both in my main town. Lazies are my favorite personality and I love stuffed animals but Stitches and I just didn't click...I don't know why. I don't find him too cute either. Eventually he'll be re-homed. I adore the design of his house though! I like Marshal way more he's a sweet little squirrel.

 

[momayo]

I like Stitches c: At first I didn't get why he was so popular, and his color scheme was rather, er, adventurous for me at the time. But he is adorable when he talks, moves, and projects emotions, and his Lazy personality really suits his look so well. He isn't my super favorite villager, but he's very appealing and I'd like to keep him for a long time at least.

 

[Hype]

I like Marshal more but I have both him and Stitches in my town.

 

[Le Ham]

I find both cute to an extent, but honestly they're not ones I want in my town. They're like celebrities; popular, beautiful, but always so distant. Marshal reminds me of pop singers, and I don't like pop singers. Stitches is just... well, I dunno. He just don't appeal to me.

Also, other populars like Rosie, Cookie, Apple, and Chrissy just look like they have no soul to me with those huge googly eyes of theirs. Apple, in particular, reminds me of Patrick Star's "May I take your hat sir?" face.

 

[Hound00med]

I have Stitches in my town, and he's definitely better than Marshal in my books.. But Marshal's okay

 

[Byngo]

Both of them are so insanely overrated. Marshal looks grumpy and just no. Stitches makes me think of a possessed bear, or something. But if I had to choose, it would be Stitches.

 

[monochrom3]

Marshal is way better than Stitches.

 

[JaeJae]

Have them both.. Marshal looks too sulky for my liking so I voted for Stitches.. that little tummy of his is too cute :3