Making the hardest decision! Advice please! [CLOSED]

[senbeiiscool]

Help me make a decision please! I've been thinking about this for hours and I can't come up with a decision!

I'm getting Audie from my sister and I'm stuck between kicking Raymond, Julian, Fang, Merengue or Lily from my island that is at full capacity.

The reasons:
- Raymond doesn't really fit my island, I don't really know if I would really miss him. But if I kicked him, I would never get another one if I regretted my decision
- Julian was an unexpected move in, I wasn't planning on keeping him but my island is full of singers so the moment he sang, I wanted him to stay.
- Fang, I love him! I won him in an auction but I have 3 crankies (incl him) and my other two (Chief and Roscoe) have been with me longer and I love them too
- Merengue, I really like her! But her auctions are so frequent I could probably get another one if I really wanted her back
- Lily, really grew on me. She pissed off my other villagers initially but they're now friends and she's adorable
- The smug personality type is really wearing down on me so I would ideally like to cap it to 2 (and I have Marshal already who is staying)
- Cranky is my favourite personality type

Knowing this, who would you pick to kick out? I'm so tired of this I don't know what to do.

Please don't use this thread as a way to kick out your favourites so I can put them to auction! I just want a logical vote between the villagers if it were up to you!

 

[Fridaynightcatlady]

I’d narrow it down to: Fang (bc of too many cranky villagers) and Raymond. You cleary don’t want Raymond. Yojr other smugs are already great!

 

[brockbrock]

If you’re not appreciating Raymond in your town then I’d say give him to someone who has him as a dreamie.

Otherwise I vote to kick out Julian!

 

[senbeiiscool]

Thanks for the input! This really helps!

 

[axo]

I would kick Raymond. It seems like you know you don't want him, but he's super valuable which kinda clouds all of our judgement a little bit. You could gift him to someone who has him as a dreamie or make a ton of money if you auctioned him.

 

[Khaelis]

Honestly, between the three and what you've said about them, Raymond seems like the most obvious choice. Bonus is you can get a lot for him once you remove him as well.

 

[ayeeprill]

Raymond, no contest.

 

[pinkfawn]

Agree with Raymond. Like others said, it sounds like you don't want him as much as the others. You would make someone who wants him really happy, and you'd get your space for Audie.

 

[brockbrock]

For the record, I am not recommending you kick Raymond because I have a hidden agenda or anything... I already have him.

Just wanted to clarify so it doesn’t look shady!

But yeah or you could kick out Julian the white-eyed weirdo.

 

[Pickler]

Kick Raymond my way, I need a good smug villager.

 

[Mayorpanda]

Yeah I agree with everyone saying Raymond. And after he’s out of your void pool he can eventually pop up in your campsite or on a random island if you can set down a plot. If you’re still not willing to give him up, you’d have to let go of a cranky villager. I know exactly what that’s like I used to have so many lazy villagers but they were my ultimate favorites TT-TT now in my island, I have 4 normal villagers who all grew on me differently but had to let one go for Vivian. At the end of the day, what are you willing to sacrifice?

 

[senbeiiscool]

For the record, I am not recommending you kick Raymond because I have a hidden agenda or anything... I already have him.

Just wanted to clarify so it doesn’t look shady!

But yeah or you could kick out Julian the white-eyed weirdo.

No worries! I'm planning on probably giving him away to one of my friends who has done a lot for me anyways if I decided to kick him

Thanks for your input!

Post automatically merged: Apr 14, 2020

I think my decision has been made! Goodbye Raymond! Thanks for all of your help!

 

[thelonewanderer]

Yeah I agree with everyone saying Raymond. And after he’s out of your void pool he can eventually pop up in your campsite or on a random island if you can set down a plot. If you’re still not willing to give him up, you’d have to let go of a cranky villager. I know exactly what that’s like I used to have so many lazy villagers but they were my ultimate favorites TT-TT now in my island, I have 4 normal villagers who all grew on me differently but had to let one go for Vivian. At the end of the day, what are you willing to sacrifice?

Vivian is so snooty, I love her! She never leaving my island.

 

[senbeiiscool]

Vivian is so snooty, I love her! She never leaving my island.

I love Vivian too! I initially got her because I was missing a snooty and really wanted a wolf villager, now I can't imagine her gone!

 

[thelonewanderer]

I love Vivian too! I initially got her because I was missing a snooty and really wanted a wolf villager, now I can't imagine her gone!

I imagine Whitney is the same... but Vivian is definitely different from Wild World Whitney. Vivian give so many underhanded compliment it like everytime she say something nice, you wonder what she really up to. Meanwhile Whitney on the other hand is very upfront and snooty and mean at times. Changing Whitney was funner though but at least snooty villagers aren't as bad as New Leaf.

Not sure why Vivian aren't as popular as the other female wolves? The way their tail sway back and forth is also sooo cute. Wolves are my spirit animal. I like the Lion Kings but give me Alpha and Omega over them anyday.

 

[Eirrinn]

Oh I emember you! We traded Chief and kabuki lol
I’d gladly buy fang off of you if you get rid of him

 

[senbeiiscool]

I imagine Whitney is the same... but Vivian is definitely different from Wild World Whitney. Vivian give so many underhanded compliment it like everytime she say something nice, you wonder what she really up to. Meanwhile Whitney on the other hand is very upfront and snooty and mean at times. Changing Whitney was funner though but at least snooty villagers aren't as bad as New Leaf.

Not sure why Vivian aren't as popular as the other female wolves? The way their tail sway back and forth is also sooo cute. Wolves are my spirit animal. I like the Lion Kings but give me Alpha and Omega over them anyday.

I've always thought the wolves were pretty popular but in any case i think they're super cute as well! My island unexpectedly became wolf island with the addition of Audie hahaha not complaining tho!

Post automatically merged: Apr 15, 2020

Oh I emember you! We traded Chief and kabuki lol
I’d gladly buy fang off of you if you get rid of him

Hahahaha I don't think he'll be leaving my place anytime soon but if he does, I'll let you know haha

 

[thelonewanderer]

I've always thought the wolves were pretty popular but in any case i think they're super cute as well! My island unexpectedly became wolf island with the addition of Audie hahaha not complaining tho!

Post automatically merged: Apr 15, 2020

Hahahaha I don't think he'll be leaving my place anytime soon but if he does, I'll let you know haha

I'm disappointed he a male, I thought he was another female like Whitney, another white female wolf. Though my biggest disappointment was finding my beautiful dreamy Beau is a male....

 

[projectx1991]

Senbiiscool, when kicking out Raymond how did you do it? Did you just ignore and then TT until he left?

 

[Heartcore]

I would personally get rid of Raymond or Julian. But probably Julian if you're not totally sure about Raymond yet. Especially if you are feeling like not super happy with the smugs. Cranky is my favorite too so I've personally been debating bringing in a third one also. To be honest, I've been struggling with a similar situation with Judy. I'm just not super into her and I'm not sure if I'll be keeping her forever but I'm worried if I let her go that I'll regret it and never get her again. So maybe give Raymond some time and if you still don't find yourself liking him down the road let him go and then get Julian again?