Lunar Legends: Peaches vs. Reneigh (Round 1, Match 2)

[~Kilza~]

Welcome to Round 1, Match 2 of Lunar Legends, a showdown of the horses to see who will be named The Bell Tree's representative for the Year of the Horse and become our next character collectible!

In this poll, you will vote between Peaches & Reneigh to see who will advance to the Quarter-Finals!

This poll closes at Friday, February 20, 2026 at 7 PM EST. May the best horse win!

 

[Rio_]

Let's go Peaches!!!! Or at least, let's not lose by an embarrassing margin!!!

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

I like Reneigh but I think Peaches would make for a better collectible!

 

[-Apples-]

So why is Reneigh more popular than Peaches?

 

[-Blue-]

So why is Reneigh more popular than Peaches?

No disrespect to those who like her, but she just feels a bit bland. One of those popular villagers. I think Peach's design looks more endearing.

I kind of already knew what the outcome was going to be before I even voted.

 

[Aerith]

My theory is that more people have been exposed to Reneigh, since you start with both a jock and a sisterly villager in New Horizons. I think they're both cute! I'm fond of most of the horse villagers. I think it's because I was a horse girl growing up before I turned into a bird teen/woman

 

[Ginny Potter]

So why is Reneigh more popular than Peaches?

Honestly I voted for Reneigh due to her design.

 

[toxapex]

Peach heads we NEED to lock in.

She's so pink. and her eyes look like this + + HOW can she be losing

 

[-Blue-]

Peach heads we NEED to lock in.

She's so pink. and her eyes look like this + + HOW can she be losing

Take solace in that she is at least putting up way better of a fight than poor Clyde. I do love her design and I think she would look so cute as a collectible!

 

[Giddy]

It least Peaches will have a forever home on my food island - once I make it of course, and she will look after the peaches :3

I love her look, she gives me retired clown vibes.

 

[Mutti]

I had to choose peaches, she just screams cute loveable villager, plus her name is perfect

 

[Dunquixote]

I voted for Reneigh! This one was easier to vote for since I’ve had her and I really like her design .

 

[Rykertimee]

Peach heads we NEED to lock in.

She's so pink. and her eyes look like this + + HOW can she be losing

They look more like x x

I voted Reneigh since I don't really want a collectable that looks like a dead horse head.

 

[Aniko]

I had both on my island, very sweet. I voted for Reneigh, because she's still my villager and will be upset if I vote for another horse.