Lolly or poppy

[Xara]

i’ve only ever had poppy in new horizons, but i personally would choose lolly! i’m biased, but she’s one of my top 10 favourite villagers and i adore her with all my heart. you honestly can’t go wrong with either of them, though! ^~^

 

[Mialina]

Lolly. She is way too cute.

 

[Crowsie]

Can't pick. Neither are my dreamies but I consider both of them super precious and huggable and I'd be friends with them both.

 

[Stikki]

I like both but Poppy just has the edge for me as I like the squirrels more than the cats of AC.

 

[Akeath]

I've had both, and I like Lolly a bit more. Her expressions are just so adorable. Poppy has a pretty awesome house interior, though. Agree with the others that it might depend on which one goes with your island theme or colors more.

 

[maria110]

I've had them both on my islands and earned their photos and they are both lovely. I think it depends on the aesthetic of your island. Poppy has that lovely autumn theme home and Lolly's home is a more normal cat-next-door kind of place. Ditto for the exteriors--Poppy's is fancier and more elegant while Lolly's is more basic. Lolly's name in Japanese is Ramune, a popular soda. When I had Lolly on my island, Raymond was also there, and once in awhile they'd do yoga in the plaza together. It was very cute.

 

[QueenCobra]

I prefer Poppy due to her coloring and cuteness. I also drew a gijinka (as human) fanart of her that I was proud of, so maybe I’m biased that way.

 

[eeveelovee]

Such a tough decision.. I have had both cuties in my towns... however since I am a cat lover I am going to have to go with Lolly on this one. She's the perfect little tabby!

 

[KidCatAcnh]

I think I have to choose, poppy, its All depending on peoples tastes on villagers

 

[rocketspruggs]

Both of them are cute, even though I prefer Lolly. I got along with her after I decided to invite her to one of my towns in the campsite.