Kid Cat or Rudy?

[Ceres]

I'm actually really curious as to which villager people prefer and why!

I thought that Kid Cat would be more popular than Rudy but it doesn't seem that way (at least on TBT). I had Rudy in a previous town and I was considering having him in my new one since he was a nice villager but to me he doesn't really fit the jock personality? Maybe its his looks or his house (his house makes me think he should be a lazy tbh). Hes really sweet though, I loved having him!

I've seen Kid Cat in dream towns and I actually think he'd be great in my town as well! But for some reason he doesn't seem as popular as I thought he would be? He's pretty cute and imo he makes a great jock (and I'm not too much a fan of the jock villagers!) Do people just not like him as much since hes a superhero villager?

Even though I say that I'm actually torn between the two, I'd like a jock cat in my town so I'd love to hear your opinions about the two!

(I know I'm leaving out Stinky but... he doesn't really seem too appealing to me :/ )

 

[Slowpoke]

Hello~!
I'd say I prefer Kid Cat more. Rudy seems kind of bland to me. ∩(︶▽︶)∩

 

[Seastar]

I like Kid Cat more.

 

[LuigiDM]

should pick who you like and not what everyone likes. I chose kid cat cause I like his helmet.

just noticed that poll thingy.

 

[JeanGiraffe]

I have never had Kid Cat, but I have Rudy in my reset town and have gotten to know and love him. <33

 

[Ceres]

should pick who you like and not what everyone likes. I chose kid cat cause I like his helmet.

I know what you mean and I'm definitely not going to choose on popularity alone, but I'm having a hard time deciding since I've only had Rudy and Kid Cat seems equally appealing atm! Just thought it would be nice to hear peoples' reasons for liking one or the other before I have to decide :3

 

[harvington]

Kid Cat! I have Rudy in my town right now and his face freaks me out. He looks satanic lol. But his house is right next to Bob's, so its funny to see them hang out together.

 

[twerkstrider]

i've only had rudy and he's one of the very few jock villagers i like, haha ;u; lil rudy-rudy-attitudey

 

[Zeiro]

I like Rudy.

 

[feminist]

Kid cat 100% he's super radical

 

[TheEliteEmpoleon]

I like Kid Cat better. I really like the super hero villagers.

 

[saarahsuper]

Rudy he is my boy dreamie that I have go Rudy yeah!!!

 

[Mary]

Kid cat. Rudy's nose is scary. It's creepy!

 

[fl0ra]

kid cat for sure! i have him. he's a good villager!
sorry but i kinda think that rudy's face is creepy.
not a fan of his yellow eyes either :l

 

[Neriifur]

Whoa.. Rudy's a jock? He looks like a normal or lazy villager..

Well I think Rudy's cuter, but Kid Cat really fits the look of the Jock is super awesome because of that.

 

[Ceres]

Thanks for everyones input so far!! I am seriously considering trying Kid Cat now...

Whoa.. Rudy's a jock? He looks like a normal or lazy villager..

Well I think Rudy's cuter, but Kid Cat really fits the look of the Jock is super awesome because of that.

Yeah my thoughts exactly! Rudy is really cute but its a little weird to me that hes a jock? Kid Cat really suits a jock though!

 

[Halycon]

Kid Cat! Rudy is overrated in my opinion.

 

[Lennox]

Rudy moved into my town and I thought he was a creep. But every day he's grown on me. Jock is probably my least favorite personality, idk why, I just get tired of hearing their jargon haha. I also have Agent S in my town, not as good as Kid Cat for sure, but I just don't like the superheroes that much. I like to see my villagers faces!

I was going to get rid of Rudy ASAP but... now I'm thinking of keeping him...

 

[Farobi]

Kid Cat. Rudy's nose really is a big turn-off in my opinion. But once Kid Cat changes his default attire, then i'd say Rudy is better.

 

[monochrom3]

Kid Cat by a long shot.