Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[FinalArcadia]

im pretty interested in this read here. i found dino to be genuinely confused what to do and would imagine them being more reserved as a wolf. they dont seem to be forcing anything out, other than the over joking in the beginning. i dont think any of us have reliable meta on them though

That's kind of what I mean, the questions they've had have been casual enough that I do think they're serious questions about the game, but they stood out to me in my up-to-page 12 readthrough because I didn't see many actual stances from Dino even though I was seeing him posting quite a bit. It's hard for me to get a read for because I'm used to seeing this kind of thing from a variety of alignments and playstyles; I was kind of hoping in mentioning it that there was some meta here that someone might mention like Dino does this kind of D1 posting usually as town or not

I'll have to go back a little to try to remember why exactly MyLifeIsCake gave me a good impression, it was a gut feel but there must've been something that triggered it

 

[Dinosaurz]

Geoni hosted the last game I played but idk who else was there

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Talking about geoni where tf is he

 

[FinalArcadia]

^^ I always try to start D1 with a joke or some less serious conversation, there is little to contribute when there hasn't been any deaths, especially for this style of game. Voting ealry D1 is always a shot in the dark and I don't know if its worth just voting someone on a hunch esp if they haven't posted yet. I'd like to hear from everybody before I make a decision yet. Imo D1 is the worst day for gathering info and I feel bad for whoever gets chopped without getting to contribute much to the game
(that was me a few games ago :<)

turns out I didn't have to look very far because this is MyLifeIsCake's only post so far? weird, I thought I remembered reading more but I may be mixing up avatars with someone else

Not sure why it's so bad to vote on a hunch right away when there's plenty of time for votes to shift as the phase progresses, and it does at least give everyone something to talk about to get the ball rolling. but it's consistent with wanting to start the game with casual conversation and wanting to give everyone a chance to speak first before deciding things, so I think it was the consistency there that gave me a good feeling, though this being their only post means we haven't been able to see what they actually think of anyone so far

 

[dedenne]

Geoni hosted the last game I played but idk who else was there

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Talking about geoni where tf is he

about to launch a geoni search party

 

[Dinosaurz]

about to launch a geoni search party

does anyone have discord w him lmao tag him

 

[voltairenism]

ping me when glow answers zzzz

 

[epona]

does anyone have discord w him lmao tag him

he's probably at work

 

[Damniel]

i tried pinging geo on the mafia chat but he didn't respond : (

i doubt glow will respond and who cares if she does tbh. it really shouldn't change much and dont find it AI for her

 

[voltairenism]

i tried pinging geo on the mafia chat but he didn't respond : (

i doubt glow will respond and who cares if she does tbh. it really shouldn't change much and dont find it AI for her

yeah i just wished antonio would say what he was thinking abt bc we are stucked again

who want to speculate roles with me

That's kind of what I mean, the questions they've had have been casual enough that I do think they're serious questions about the game, but they stood out to me in my up-to-page 12 readthrough because I didn't see many actual stances from Dino even though I was seeing him posting quite a bit. It's hard for me to get a read for because I'm used to seeing this kind of thing from a variety of alignments and playstyles; I was kind of hoping in mentioning it that there was some meta here that someone might mention like Dino does this kind of D1 posting usually as town or not

I'll have to go back a little to try to remember why exactly MyLifeIsCake gave me a good impression, it was a gut feel but there must've been something that triggered it

thats true, I think they just have a sus on dan and that's it. but i feel like dino is live tweeting within the thread so thats why their thoughts are just spread in a lot of posts

 

[glow]

Something recently did come to mind but I don't know if it's worth anything, either due to me doubting myself or that's it's not actually worth anything.

Before I go into it, I have a question if anyone wishes to answer. Aren't mafia usually like super aware of their town meta or have a town meta in mind that they follow to be perceived as town?

the answer to this is definitely subjective. so as much it will be unsatisfying, it'll be one of those where "it depends."

you could say it's more likely that most people will try to mimic their town behavior, but i find this to be unreliable because in the context it can come off as stiff/unnatural

personally when i'm mafia i try to respond the same way i would as if i was town, it's not exactly the same as sticking to my meta since i try to vary playstyles

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

ping me when glow answers zzzz

was it the one i just answered......or was there a diff one

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

i doubt glow will respond and who cares if she does tbh. it really shouldn't change much and dont find it AI for her

v____v

 

[Dinosaurz]

thats true, I think they just have a sus on dan and that's it. but i feel like dino is live tweeting within the thread so thats why their thoughts are just spread in a lot of posts

oops is that bad

 

[voltairenism]

oops is that bad

i mean people have different opinions abt this lol i do that so I dont mind

the answer to this is definitely subjective. so as much it will be unsatisfying, it'll be one of those where "it depends."

you could say it's more likely that most people will try to mimic their town behavior, but i find this to be unreliable because in the context it can come off as stiff/unnatural

personally when i'm mafia i try to respond the same way i would as if i was town, it's not exactly the same as sticking to my meta since i try to vary playstyles

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

was it the one i just answered......or was there a diff one

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

v____v

yes it's the one :O

ok @Alek come here

 

[Ace Marvel]

@Alek we need you!

 

[Damniel]

i think its possible for volt to be mafia here and ace has become a drifting voice here

 

[Dinosaurz]

@Alek we need you!

And when the world needed him the most, he vanished.

 

[Ace Marvel]

i think its possible for volt to be mafia here and ace has become a drifting voice here

I am my own voice, I am Colton! it was just a coincidence, did not see Volt message when I posted.

 

[voltairenism]

i think its possible for volt to be mafia here and ace has become a drifting voice here

u got me

 

[Damniel]

not joking here btw. out of everyone who's responded so far i just dont see much drive to solve from volt yet, talking mechanics is just an easy way to talk without making any firm stance. i found final's entry post to be pretty thoughtful which is a good sign

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

the two aren't related just commenting on both separately

 

[Antonio]

Yes, thank you glow. I'm can't find a post guys, so i need your help. I can't find the post that stated "Town would most likely ask questions" or provide statements.

 

[Damniel]

I am my own voice, I am Colton! it was just a coincidence, did not see Volt message when I posted.

ace hasn't said much besides the early sus on me in game start. would like to see more from him