Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

How hard is it to answer a simple question. I don't see why town aligned people wouldn't?
 
okay I give up, I got to page 12 but every time I refresh it felt like a new page was added, so just gonna roll with what I read

epona is gut town, maybe just because I agree with what they've been saying for the most part and I get the frustration with all the mechanics/setup talk when it can feel like everyone just spinning their wheels. Probably the person I'd least want to vote as of now

for some reason, MyLifeIsCake immediately gave me town vibes, but I can't remember specifically WHY anymore by the time I got to making this post lmao

Ace felt jumpy in the early part of the phase? maybe "jumpy" isn't the right word since it wasn't like they were under suspicion, but the stuff about Geoni seemed odd to me, though tbf, D1 where I'm from has a lot of that kind of voting people even if they haven't posted yet (it sucks there, but isn't really a mafia tell)

agree with the people saying that dan/Alek seems more like a town/town disagreement going on them town/mafia

Dinosaurz is really hard for me to get a feel for; most of their posts are just kinda "there" or about the now-forbidden words and could be some sort of CWAC posts when there are some other topics at-hand, but it's casual enough that it isn't really striking me as forced. This is another case where having meta on players here might help but alas

And I think it was Alek asking something about if players are conscious of their town meta and what others expect of them as town when mafia or something? I think that's absolutely true for most people, and the other big thing is trying to pretend like you don't know more than you do when giving reads and stuff
 
epona said:
like i said it's a tentative townlean and definitely subject to change, but i followed daniel's champs games pretty closely and i think he's adapting a lot of the different playstyles and tactics that he picked up at MU and applying them to this game (specifically random and unprovoked voting early in the game)

my gut says he does that as town to be more productive and solve-oriented, and to genuinely play to town's advantage and wincon, but doesn't do it as wolf bc he'd know that it would stick out bc it's not the convention here, and if he's a wolf he's also on a team and i just don't rlly feel like he'd go rogue in that way

also i wouldn't expect him to dig his heels into alek's response as sus but immediately townreading him for it as opposed to just leaving it feels townie to me

you're definitely right about him being a strong player which is why my townlean on alek is a lot stronger, but my general feeling atm is that they're town/town
Click to expand...
this seems like you have a very thorough reason to TL me despite saying im likely town. but to be fair, wolfing in my semis game taught me alot of the bold plays people can get away with
 
Alek said:
For **** sakes, don't downplay me like I'm some idiot.

I have an thought in mind but I need everyone's opinion to answer in order to go with it.
Click to expand...

i'm not downplaying you and i apologise if it came across that way but i think daniel has made it clear he's not going to answer so i don't know if it's worth continuing to ask him
 
Alek said:
Something recently did come to mind but I don't know if it's worth anything, either due to me doubting myself or that's it's not actually worth anything.

Before I go into it, I have a question if anyone wishes to answer. Aren't mafia usually like super aware of their town meta or have a town meta in mind that they follow to be perceived as town?
Click to expand...
this depends on the player and how familiar others are with them. but yes most maf generally tend to over follow their perceived town play and dont end up wolfing all that well for trying to be too town
 
Ty Damniel, all I need is Glow response and ill be ready to go.
Post automatically merged:

@glow u here?
 
FinalArcadia said:
Dinosaurz is really hard for me to get a feel for; most of their posts are just kinda "there" or about the now-forbidden words and could be some sort of CWAC posts when there are some other topics at-hand, but it's casual enough that it isn't really striking me as forced. This is another case where having meta on players here might help but alas
Click to expand...
im pretty interested in this read here. i found dino to be genuinely confused what to do and would imagine them being more reserved as a wolf. they dont seem to be forcing anything out, other than the over joking in the beginning. i dont think any of us have reliable meta on them though
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

voltairenism
Mafia Zelda Mountainous Mafia
Replies
4
Views
875
Wiisp
Wiisp
Fridaynightcatlady
My pitch for Animal Crossing for the Switch 2 - Animal Crossing: Let's Go Exploring!
Replies
0
Views
278
Fridaynightcatlady
Fridaynightcatlady
Awesome Gamer 2009
Funny game challenges you made up?
Replies
0
Views
90
Awesome Gamer 2009
Awesome Gamer 2009
iocatio
Hello!
Replies
2
Views
274
Mimi Cheems
Mimi Cheems
M
Giveaway ✨How It's Done The Island Watch Party✨
Replies
1
Views
1K
Phoenix45
P
Back
Top