is this good colour correction?

[David]

I'm editing a montage for PS3 Comedy and just need some feedback on the colour correction.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bMoYT8RF3mw

the final quality will be better, im just trying out new ways to render things.

 

[Garrett x50 cal]

No.

 

[Hiro]

No

 

[David]

i dont see why not, it makes it more cinematic looking.

 

[Jas0n]

i dont see why not, it makes it more cinematic looking.

Why did you ask for opinions if you're just going to reject every one of them? Just to cause another argument?

 

[Elliot]

Nope.

 

[David]

i dont see why not, it makes it more cinematic looking.

Why did you ask for opinions if you're just going to reject every one of them? Just to cause another argument?

im not trying to make another argument, im just saying, it adds a more cinematic look to it, i might bring the blacks up a bit so its a bit lighter, but i think it looks decent. what would you say would make it look better? besides leaving it on the original. id like some more feedback on what to change, im not gonna base changing it on a few 11-12 year olds who say its bad.

 

[Marcus]

No

 

[Hiro]

i dont see why not, it makes it more cinematic looking.

.__.

Why even ask in the first place then?

 

[Mr. L]

No.

 

[Thunder]

i dont see why not, it makes it more cinematic looking.

If you're not gonna agree with them, why not just use your idea of good color correction.

 

[David]

i dont see why not, it makes it more cinematic looking.

If you're not gonna agree with them, why not just use your idea of good color correction.

probably will, i posted it on the IW forums and people liked it so i guess im gonna use it.

 

[Vex L'Cour]

Yes.

/just2bedifferent

 

[Pear]

Yeah, I'd probably just use a game play segment from a Hardcore playlist, that way the HUD doesn't become discolored.