Is there any dialogue advantage of having 2x of the same personality?

[lykkelille]

For example if you have 2 crankies living next to each other? Is there a higher chance of a fun interaction if I have two villagers on the same type together?

 

[Zireael]

I'm not sure if this happens in any other instances, but one time I caught Pekoe and Flurry in a conversation and I had never seen this particular dialogue before. I can't remember the exact subject matter but they ended up going back and forth with a lot of "ah, please, after you!", "oh no, after YOU!", "nono, I insist, after you!" etc etc. It was the cutest thing I have ever seen, but it's only happened once. I don't know if that's exclusive to two normals but it was definitely the first time I had seen it.

 

[Dewy]

Yeah, villager dialogues depend on the combination of villagers. Two of the same kind will pretty much always get along well and say things to each other that they don't say to other villagers.

 

[TheMisaMisa]

I have 4 crankies rn and they hardly ever have conversations with each other...

 

[Lethalia]

The likeliness of certain villagers talking to each other is very random. I never noticed two of the same personality speaking to each other more frequently. But when they do speak, they're usually really compatible with each other since they're so similar. Back when I still had Mitzi, I caught a conversation between her & Celia. They were just talking about food & swapping cooking recipes and ****. They were all pleasant and friendly. Which was an incredibly boring convo to eavesdrop on lmao

 

[GreenLeaf]

in ww the villagers speek to each other more often than in this game sadly (at least in my copy is that way)

 

[NinelivesBobcat]

I miss how in the older games, the villagers communicated with each other much more (especially in Doubutsu no Mori e+ / Animal Forest e+). They need to make conversations much more common in the next game. I know it would be hard for people to maintain a villager's default shirt but even if they don't communicate they would eventually change their shirt anyway.

 

[Red Cat]

You might get more interesting conversations between two villagers of the same personality, but it will be a lot more boring when you're talking to those repeat personalities over and over again.

 

[ethergaunts]

idk if this is exclusive to cranky villagers, but i love stumbling upon two of them having what seems like a heated and threatening argument only to find out that they were just being extremely competitive playing a game to see who could think up the most saccharinely sweet dessert concoction. warms the cockles of my heart.

 

[Buster Bunny]

I recall that Amelia and Ankha were talking to each other and Ankha made Amelia depressed and went singing the town tune.
I could not hear the dialogue, but seems that two snooty villagers can get conflicts just like any other personality.

 

[lykkelille]

The thing is... I am having 2 peppies, 1 smug, 1 cranky, 1 uchi, 1 lazy and 3 normals in my town. All the 3 normals are villagers i REALLY LIKE, but I dont want to loose villager conversations between 2 crankies just because i have 3 normals... :/ I have Dobie but there is no other cranky i REALLY want. What to do?:/