If you had 5 more open spots on your island, who would you pick?

Apollo, Rosie, Alfonso, Sherb, and Julia. I love these guys but sadly have to give them up to the dreamies I have.
 
I'm not entirely sure, but if I had to name them off the top of my head I guess I'd go with the following:
  • Bill
  • Peewee
  • Mott
  • Ike
  • Jeremiah
 
Thank you for offering! :giggle:
I’ll be able to get most of my stuff back. I don’t want to have to restart, but it’ll be worth it.
 
In order of who I would want the most;

Mint (Had her on my island; Replaced with Pecan. Was a tough choice.)
Nibbles (Also had her on my island. No current replacement.)
Caroline (I already have like 3 normals but her interior would make her worth it. Not my fault normals are the best designed in this game but have the weakest dialogue.)
Sylvana (Same above.)
Tasha. (I just prefer Mint and Pecan. Sorry.)

Honestly want all the squirrels on my island. Nintendo give me more plots (and if you want to put in the effort; More personality types) please. 👏😩
 
I think I would probably pick
-Julia
-Julian
-Ankha
-Dobie
-And maybe Cube
It'd probably be moved around a lot until I found ones I felt I could see a lot.
 
It would be so great to have 5 more plots ! 🤩
Still hard to choose though lol, I would definitely have a goat and a wolf....
I think :
AudiePicACNH.png
KylePicACNH.png
BillyPicACNH.png
GladysPicACNH.png
Ren%C3%A9ePicACNH.png

Audie
Kyle
Billy
Gladys
Renée


Villagers I'll consider if I ended not liking someone of the 5 :
Dobie
Sherb
Beau
Snake
Octavian
Lobo
Roscoe
Fauna
Coco
Chevre
Freya
Olivia
Naomi
 
I'd invite Paolo, Broccolo, Gayle, Lily, and Roald :) I really really wish we could have more villagers, or have our past villagers visit our island sometimes :( the island feels so empty sometimes
 
My current list of dreamies is so long that it'd be difficult to choose. Though

Drago
Julian
Butch
Stitches
O'Hare

All stick out. Especially Drago and Julian, as I already have Phoebe. Those three are the mythical creatures of the game- Phoebe is a phoenix, Drago is a dragon, and Julian is a unicorn- so I'd like to have all three. Currently my island has villagers I love. I guess I wouldn't be opposed to Rooney or Apple moving out? But everyone else- Phoebe, Kabuki, Rodeo, Clay, Lily, Flurry, Skye, and Leonardo are staying. Kabuki and Leonardo I actually used Amiibo cards to get, Phoebe was one of my starting villagers, and the rest I just love.
 
I think I'd definitely feel more inclined to add more cat villagers to my island. I created my own ark style 2 of each species only rule. But I love Punchy, Tom and Bob....its not fair... :rolleyes:
 
Sprocket, Kiki, Sylvana, Sherb and Frank - As this would give me 2 of all personalities other than Sisterly.
 
I currently don’t have all of my dreamies, but if I had to pick five more who aren’t on my island at the moment then I’d say Kiki, Poppy, Benjamin, Drake, and Rudy
 
Back
Top