I Need Help Deciding My Villagers Again

[Hay]

Hello!

I don’t know what sparked in my brain last night at 1am but now I don’t like my villager line up once again haha.

So my current Villagers are:
-Tia
-Ellie
-Stitches
-Hopkins (just moved in)
-Punchy
-Chief
-Maple
-Whitney
-Beau
-Marshal

I want switch up a villager and kick a lazy out. What I’m thinking is:

Tia kicked out for: (Tangy OR Merry OR Diana) Who should I pick?

Hopkins or Punchy kicked out for Pashmina (I just found Hopkins in my campsite and he’s so cute but I love Punchy and he’s an OG of mine so I need help picking who to say bye to!) Eek!

What do y’all think? Anything I’m not thinking of that works? Let me know <3​

 

[Fye]

I'd go Tia -> Tangy, since you already have another normal elephant, and normally I'd go with Diana but you already have a deer and a snootie with a similar color scheme. So my vote's with Tangy since you don't have a female cat yet and she's just so cute (or Diana cause she's an actual princess)

 

[Hay]

I'd go Tia -> Tangy, since you already have another normal elephant, and normally I'd go with Diana but you already have a deer and a snootie with a similar color scheme. So my vote's with Tangy since you don't have a female cat yet and she's just so cute (or Diana cause she's an actual princess)

Thank you!!! My native fruit is orange so I feel like she would just be great on my island haha!

 

[N a t]

Okay so it looks like you kinda have a 2 and 2 thing starting to go one so maybe continue that pattern. I see two wolves, two bears, two elephants. If you do kick out Tia, maybe go with Diana since you have Beau. If you kick out Tia and also a lazy of yours I would kick out Hopkins maybe since you're attached to Punchy, and maybe pick up another cat, squirrel, or a male elephant. Just my 2 cents!

Post automatically merged: May 24, 2020

The other person's recommendation for Tangy is also very good but if you take in Tangy I definitely think you need to hang on to Punchy!

 

[Hay]

Okay so it looks like you kinda have a 2 and 2 thing starting to go one so maybe continue that pattern. I see two wolves, two bears, two elephants. If you do kick out Tia, maybe go with Diana since you have Beau. If you kick out Tia and also a lazy of yours I would kick out Hopkins maybe since you're attached to Punchy, and maybe pick up another cat, squirrel, or a male elephant. Just my 2 cents! The other person's recommendation for Tangy is also very good but if you take in Tangy I definitely think you need to hang on to Punchy!

Omg I didn’t even notice the 2 trend wow! Thanks for pointing this out! I’ll keep your opinion in mind!! <3

 

[Xara]

i’d pick merry or diana over tia and i’d boot out hopkins ;;

 

[Hay]

i’d pick merry or diana over tia and i’d boot out hopkins ;;

So far it looks like Hopkins is gotta hop out of here (I hate myself lmfao). Thank you!! <3

 

[EmperorGandhi]

If it matters to you, Beau and Hopkins both have the same personality subtype (nature), so I'd also give Hopkins the boot for the sake of variety. I have both on my island as well and while I love Hopkins, I intend to let him leave once I get his picture since I already have Beau to fill that niche and he's not going anywhere.

 

[Hay]

If it matters to you, Beau and Hopkins both have the same personality subtype (nature), so I'd also give Hopkins the boot for the sake of variety. I have both on my island as well and while I love Hopkins, I intend to let him leave once I get his picture since I already have Beau to fill that niche and he's not going anywhere.

I love Beau so much ahah!!! Thank you for the advice <3