I have too many Peppy villagers, which one should I keep?

[davidlblack]

So I have three Peppys:
Cheri, Cub
Cookie, Dog
Merry, Cat

I need to get rid of 2 so I can make room for a new uchi and snooty because I lost Cherry and Portia recently :-(

What do you guys think? Also, If someone could show me how to change this into a poll that could help!

 

[Kirbystarship]

I think you should keep Merry I really like her because she always has a smile on her face.

 

[Chelsaurus]

You should keep cookie orrrr give me cookie :') hahaha

 

[ZebraQueen]

Keep cheri I like her better

 

[Jay363]

I say keep Cookie. She's so cute.

 

[Becca617]

Keep cheri I like her better

Agreed. From personal experience, Cheri is a sweetheart and I wish I didn't accidently TT her out at one point.

 

[LambdaDelta]

Cheri a best

and if you can't edit in a poll then you're probably screwed (idr if its possible after you posted a thread but it should be in full edit options down below the textbox if so)

 

[Fresco3332]

Cheri is probably the cutest but I think Merry fits your town best.... She goes with Stinky!

 

[chocopug]

If I were you, I'd keep Cookie. She's such a cutie.

 

[Spooky.]

Keep Merry. Merry is the biggest angel cat on earth and she must say forever

 

[MayorJudyOfZootopia]

Merry because CATS RULE

 

[Kalhyna]

If I were you I 'd keep Merry !

 

[cornimer]

I like Cookie the best out of those three. She's friendly and really cute. c:

 

[Rabirin]

In my opinion and experience of having Cookie in my town, i'd say keep Cookie she's a cutie. Although i'd say go for the one you honestly feel like you like the most. Also, wouldn't you need to do the 16 villager cycle to get Cherry and Portia back? if that's the case, i'm pretty sure you can keep all three until you need to switch them out, haha.

 

[mermaidshelf]

Cheri is really cute but I like them all.

 

[pandapples]

Out of the 3 I prefer Cookie.

 

[Brooke_the_Phoenix]

You should keep Cookie. She's a dog, so maybe she can be how you remember Cherry and Portia.

 

[Fenix]

Even though Cookie is very cute, Cheri is cuter.

 

[HungryForCereal]

tbh cheri is kinda dull compared to the other two and ugly imo. so if im you, id keep cookie and merry because they're cute.

 

[Monsoon]

I would keep Cheri. Personally as a Snooty villager enthusiast, I never liked Peppy villagers much due to their obsession with them self and overexcitement over everything so it's best to have one for the projects and diversity. Cookie is really creepy in my opinion, mostly due to her eyes and Merry is highly overrated to me. Merry's facial expression is a like a poorly sewn doll. Keep Cheri, she's the most decent looking out of the three.

Best of luck.