I cant choose!

[smolnoodle]

So I've been island hopping and I really like the design of Pierce but I also really love Rudy's design and I cant decide which jock villager I want, please help!! I'm planning to only have 1 jock villager since I have the rest of my lineup figured out but I dont know who to get

 

[Rosch]

I had Pierce in my town before. But had to let him leave because I was cycling villagers. He's cool and feels more like a Cranky than a Jock. Will definitely get him back.

Rudy is my current villager and he likes to run around. His face is cute and funny.

If you prefer a mature jock, pick Pierce. Otherwise, pick Rudy. They're both awesome.

 

[smolnoodle]

I had Pierce in my town before. But had to let him leave because I was cycling. He's cool and feels more like a Cranky than a Jock. Will definitely get him back.

Rudy is my current villager and he likes to run around. His face is cute and funny.

If these are your only options, I'd pick Pierce.

Thanks! I really just like the design of both of them and I had Rudy before he asked to leave so I could start my hunt for Raymond again and I do miss him but I kind of just want to experiment with different villagers I guess

 

[Dude_Skillz]

Well, it's literally down to opinion, and if you like diversity in your village, like no repeat species, then pick the one who's species you don't have

 

[peachmilke]

Personally, I like Rudy more and I think he is an underrated jock design! HOWEVER, at the end of the day it comes down to your preference and Pierce is not bad by any means either! I also know I tend not to like too many of the same species on my island unless I’m doing a monotype island so maybe that may play a hand at who you choose?