Well, if you want a Madden game, then get the newest one. But I heard that Amazing Island wasn't really good... I reccomend gettin' Mario Baseball, or waiting for the JAWESOME Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance, which comes out October 17th.
If you like football, Madden. However, I enjoyed Amazing Island... RIP Persophina, the giant orange block with no feet, no arms, and just a head and tail.
Yeah, like 4 months ago. Well, anyways if I was here to tell that person I would've told them Madden 03. It's a great game, so I don't know what they're talking about.