I would say my dreamies list is pretty original with that being said I do have about three villagers that are popular but everyone else on my list is considered unpopular and I hardly ever see them being sold or sought after in the community and honestly the unpopular villagers sometimes be the cutest ones.
Jay is probably my most unpopular favorite and Lily my most popular
But I'm actually doing an all cat island right now and they all tend to be pretty popular haha
my dreamie list isn’t all that original lmao. i think the only villagers that i don’t see talked about very often but i know are still sought after are sprinkle, fuchsia and margie lol
I think mine is pretty original! But I don’t have a set 10, just a larger group, and I’m open to adding/changing things depending on who moves in and how well we connect. Right now I’d say:
Antonio
Sydney
Bubbles
Huck
Cashmere
Bones
Shari
Cesar
Broccolo
Savannah
Also considering Curlos, Hornsby, Cookie, Rod, Boots, Cherry, Benedict, Plucky, Alli, Gonzo, Limberg, Anabelle, Tom, and Hopper.
My only true dreamie is Pietro, who is seemingly controversial yet pretty popular nonetheless. I'd also really like Aurora and Punchy. Chevre just moved to my island and has a photo of Nan in her house, so it's tempting to try and find Nan as well.
I have aloooot of dreamies but if I were to only pick ten, it would be this:
- Apollo
- Buck
- Carmen
- Chevre
- Diana
- Erik
- Lily
- Mira
- Raymond
- Wolfgang
So I’d probably saaaaaay probably around 50% (assuming that Lily, Mira, and Chevre aren’t extremely popular)
Hmm well I made a special part of my island for the octopi because they are my absolute favorites. I know they are pretty popular, well maybe not octavian so much Here is my list:
Top priority:
-Marina
-Octavian
-Zucker
-Ketchup
Other Dreamies:
-Genji
-Gladys
-Fushia
-Lopez
-Melba
-Vivian
I'm bad at having dreamies because I get emotionally attached to certain villagers as they come, so I don't think I'll ever be able to pick 10 favorites and have a town full of them. The only villagers I'm gonna have on my island that I planned out are Scoot, Roald, and Julian. So kind of middle of the road in popularity except for Julian. I also sometimes have themed towns, so sometimes the villagers I have will be based on a theme rather than just being the villagers I like the most.
My final town is New Horizons is gonna be:
Roald
Scoot
Julian
June
Colton
Renee
Savannah
Stu
Rodeo
Cookie
Only one I don't have yet is Roald! Waiting for Camofrog to go.
I think people tends to have similar dreamies just because some villagers design are simply either more creative or more beautiful/cute than others, so it's kinda logic. But everyone has his own tastes so the lists will necessarily differ in some ways.
For my concerns I don't care if a villager is popular or not, if they're appealing to me then I want them.
My dreamies that are popular :
Zucker
Coco
Marshal
Audie
A bit popular :
Kabuki
Flora
Tucker
Not popular I think :
Deirdre
Cyd
Tiffany
Olivia
Eugene
Scoot
And maybe I'll discover more dreamies by playing the game