How many villagers would you like to have on your island?

[JKDOS]

8 is what I keep on my second island, and it works for me. That allows me to have 1 of each personality, and since the Island is very small, it easier to place the houses without feeling like you're running out of space.

 

[Halloqueen]

I agree with the seemingly general trend of the thread that I'd like 16, or like mentioned by rocketspruggs a couple posts ago, 15 like in the GameCube game. The current 10 just feels a bit too constrained and I'd like to have more. Admittedly, like oath2order hinted at, the island itself isn't that large, so I could even go for 12. There are a few more villagers who fit my island's theme but who either just didn't make the cut or have been replaced over time, so any additional plots would've been appreciated.

 

[DaCoSim]

I sooooo wish we could have 12!!!!!

 

[LambdaDelta]

if they somehow increased the map size, I think I'd be down for the old cube crossing cap of 15. as is though, I think 10 is fine, if somewhat unfortunately small

 

[Sharksheep]

Given the island size, I think 12 would be best. If they increase the island size I would like up to 15.

 

[oak]

12 would be good. There's not enough different personalities for 16 villagers tbh.

 

[Venn]

2 per personality type seems best. If they add a new personality, then Two more. I think 14-16 would be the best amount.

 

[corlee1289]

10 seems to be a reasonable amount for me to be able to keep and track my villagers.

Quality is better than quantity, I feel like I would be overwhelmed if there was more

 

[g u a v a]

it'd be nice if we could have 12. i have large voids in my map currently that i'm struggling to fill. a few extra houses would go a long way.