I found Cole on ticket 11, and Tabby on ticket 8. Great luck in both cases but actually a bit earlier than I would have liked to end my searches.
i donāt remember how many tickets I spent finding Bangle (maybe 5-10?). She was my original peppy, so I didnāt have many. I didnāt know if I would like her at the time, but she ended up becoming a favorite! (Not sure if that one counts)
my longest adventure ever was 80 tickets, which was pretty exhausting. I found Graham in the end, which was great, because I love him and heās my favorite smug, but there were quite a few villagers I could have been happy with before that (like Timbra, Bitty, Paula, Bree or Fuchsia - who I ended up inviting from my campsite two days later), I just was feeling too indecisive/ perfectionist, and it was just luck that it ended up working out in the end (cause I was totally out of tickets and had to borrow from friends)
Like other people have said, I donāt go out island hopping for one or two specific villagers. I also have realized I am not in a rush to fill my island up with permanent villagers, in fact I am happier not doing so yet, because I like getting to experience a variety of villagers and I love island hopping. Like
@TheSillyPuppy said, seeing a villager while island hoping often piques my interest in that villager, or affirms my interest. At the same time, I am always hoping to come across an elusive favorite (from my constantly evolving potential favorites list)
very impressed by the people who can do hundreds of tickets for a search, I donāt think I could do it!