Help pick my villagers

Azura

Show no Mercy
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Posts
287
Bells
282
Warning there may by spelling errors I typed this all on my phone.

So I need help deciding on how to get these cuties in my village, but I already love all my villagers, but I also love these villagers. I'm very conflicted.
I would like to decided soon so I can plan out Pwp's, house placement, paths, and get a signature eventually. There's too many villagers to love and not enough room. I do want change though from what I have but I can't seem to let myself let them go.
In helping me decided which I do really need help in deciding, and I can't not stress this enough, please don't purposely decided against a villager I want for being Tier one, I know everyone and their next born child has them in their village but my village isn't everyone's village and if I want all the top 10 in tier one in my village, I will have all the top 10 in tier one in my village. This also applies for tier 5.
Current villagers and why I love them-
Julian- A dreamie of mine from Sophomore years, I loved his design and I was so happy when I got him, brings back some good memories. I love his house design, the reference to Julius Caesar seals the deal. His space theme is great, and he's great. Plus his eye shadow is on point.

Zucker- Worked hard to get him, has a cute unique design, I love his house and his little bow. Plus, I love sea creatures so he's a perfect fit. I love this cutie so much. Plus he has though cute little octopus legs, and his house is really cute. Though, I am a sucker for his cute design and all the octopus look so great in this game but Zucker is my favorite of them. Also low key I payed tbt for him.

Lucky- My neighbor in the game, again a cute unique design, loved him since I first saw him in my village, he is also one of my original villagers. He's one of my favorites in my town as well. <3 I made him a cute little garden outside his house to let him know he's appreciated such a cutie. Plus I don't know if it's the lazy personality but he gives me free stuff all the time.

Phoebe- When I saw her during the hide and seek game I knew I had to get her. She's very cute, and she reminds me of my Marching show. I am a sucker for the Uchi personality and something about Phoebe I fell in love with her at first sight I mean she's a Phoenix! That design is killer with the perfect color scheme and a rad shirt she's super cool as well.

Whitney- It took some work getting her with the whole Zucker ordeal (Though inviting someone from a town and campsite on the same day does make you get both of them)* though she's grown on me considerably and has such an adorable design she's the first female wolf I've had and has yet to disappoint, she's been great and I love the snooty personality, plus she was in my campsite and is a real cutie.

Vladimir- He's a Russian cub that's pink I shouldn't have to say more but I will, he's really cute and his house is really unique I mean it's a construction zone. He's pretty funny and really nice, one of my favorite crankies. Plus he's best friends with Chrissy, he had her over several times, he has her catch phrase and outfit now, and they had this really cute convo I should've screenshotted but Chrissy has proclaimed him the prince of black tea and I can't simply ask the Prince of Black Tea to move man, he has already asked but I hadn't the heart to let him move. Plus he's a Russian cub that's pink I mean

Chrissy- The reason the Beautiful cinnamon roll meme exists, she's a beautiful cinnamon roll to pure to good. She's super cute and came across her when plot resetting she has an adorable design (dem eyes)* I'm tempted to get Francine because I've been so happy with Chrissy. She's just really cute and all peppys are really cute, but not all peppys have that cute pink bunny ears.

Bettina- Non negotiable she's staying, she's so sweet, cute, and when she walks in flowers they go up to her head and that's really really adorable. Plus, she has a cutie design, and a super sweet heart I know 90% of all my descriptions are gushing on everyone's cuteness but have you seen Bettina? Plus, she's the heart of Sodosopa (Everyone has that one character)I can't ask her to move.
Baabara- One of the people I am debating on but I love sheep so much and the longer she's here to more I love her, she's adorable, cute design, cute house with instruments, and has this green scarf now that looks great on her. I love her too much.

I also have Bill but I've, as mayor, have claimed eminent domain on his property (He's in the way of my path) and therefore he's got to go.
These are villagers I would love in my town. They're all my dreamies, but everyone in my town is dreamie material why does the villager limit exist.
Ankha- Replacing Bill definitely, the Shakespeare quote was enough to seal the deal but she has a killer design reminds me of Cleopatra. Plus, she is sassy and looks so cute and having Lucky I of course need her in my town. I would like to visit a dream town with her to seal the deal and maybe any dream towns with the other characters on the list.

Flora- Flamingo, I know I said how much I love everyone's designs but Flora by far has my favorite in the entire game. She's also really cute, sweet, and a flamingo. She also has an amazing house, and I just love her.

Gladys- Between her, Flora and Phoebe they really nailed it with the Ostrich villagers. They nailed her design I love the color scheme and the green shirt with it looks great, but she can still pull off other shirts. Very friendly and sweet like all normals but she's really cute.

Muffy- Her and Ankha tie for my second favorite after Bettina and honestly she's just great, Gothic lolita, sheep, amazing house, super cute, Uchi, she's like the entire package. Probably my second favorite design in the game, she has this unique charm to her that makes me want her in my village.

Gabi- She was in my town last time before I restarted, a super cute peppy rabbit, I love her design and she's so sweet how is she not tier 0 again? Honestly tied with Chrissy for my favorite rabbit I love this cutie. Also cute freckles.

Kiki- I really want her, she's adorable with these cute big eyes, a reference to Kiki's Delivery Service and really pretty I love her simple design. I really want to visit her via a Dream town.

Aurora- I miss this penguin, when she moved into my second town before I restarted I was iffy but I love her and she became my favorite from that town I'd talk to her everyday.

Francine- Would complete my Chrissy, she has a cute design like her sister and I love snootys, love Chrissy, best of both worlds. Plus her interactions with her sister are cute from what I've seen.

Olivia- she was in my GameCube town one of the very few villagers I remember from that game geez, and she is probably the most appealing looking cat next to Kiki. She is really cute and I love the color scheme she has, she just looks really pretty and so cute.

Diana- Like Julian she was a dreamie of mine from sophomore year, and I loved her. She's super punk rock too and as well as being really adorably designed with a beautiful house she is pretty cute and funny in my opinion the most deserving of her popularity. (Even if I love Ankha and Zucker and Whitney and Marshal and okay yeah you get the point-)

Lopez- I love his design blue with the brown and orange I don't know why but I am loving it all of the male deer designs look killer but Lopez is definitely my favorite and one of the more unique looking villagers. He's really cool and chill, and his room looks nice. The more I see of him the more I want him in my town!

Zell- Same as above, a really nice looking smug deer my third favorite deer. I really love the antelope look though and he is very appealing in character as smugs are great, design, and house look. I would love to have in my village with like everyone else.

Genji- He's one of my favorite jocks with Bill and Rudy. Though low key Genji is my number one favorite, I love the fact jocks are seen as obsessive with sports and working about but he's usually depicted with art or Anime ish I don't know why but I love the irony in that. He's really cute and my favorite male rabbit, his expression is Also really adorable and the color scheme is nice and simple. He's really lovable.

Rudy- My other favorite jock. He's a real cutie and so tiny and adorable like Bill but he's a jock and I really want to talk to him through the dream Suite so I can know more about him.

Ed- He reminds me of someone I know irl, and I had him in my GameCube town and is one of the very few I remember. He has a nice design and he is pretty cool I'd love to have him back in my town. ;~; I love him a lot.

Ken- Ninja. Chicken. Do I need to say more? Great design, absolute cutie, great color scheme, nice house and I like the look of the Chickens and Ostriches and I haven't seen any Eagles but I'm sure I'd love them too.

Marshal- I want to be basic. But really, I never had a squirrel and he's really cute with an appealing design and I love his adorableness and he has pretty cute dialogue from what I've seen in screenshots.

Kyle- He was the first to move in in my very first town I had. He was my absolute favorite in that and when people began to ask about moving out I was scared he would as well. He's my favorite wolf and has a nice design, though I loved him when I had him I remember he sent this heartbreaking letter and I thought he was going to move and talked his head off that entire day.

Wolfgang- Odd Future. His name just reminds me of the rap group Odd Future. Though he's my favorite Cranky with Vladimir and one of my favorite wolves with Kyle and Whitney. I love his design and he's really cool, I really want to talk to him through dream Suite as well, but he'd be great in my town.
I love all these villagers and would love help in picking 10 to have. I would also love to visit dream towns with them and see the houses outside of screenshots and just to see them in general. Also* does anyone else have problems like this where you love pretty much all villagers and want them in your town?
 
I have Rudy here: Rhubarb DA-5000-5558-1449
I also have Marshal and Olivia here: Fonebone DA-4000-5679-0051
And,I have Kiki here: Harp DA-5900-5853-0214
For what it's worth,I've enjoyed having all of these villagers in my towns.Good luck with your villager quest.
 
I have Rudy here: Rhubarb DA-5000-5558-1449
I also have Marshal and Olivia here: Fonebone DA-4000-5679-0051
And,I have Kiki here: Harp DA-5900-5853-0214
For what it's worth,I've enjoyed having all of these villagers in my towns.Good luck with your villager quest.

Thank you! My dream Suite will be payed off today so I'll visit be visiting tomorrow to meet these cuties.

Thank you for the luck I need it, so hard to just pick 10 villagers.
 
YES. I have to exact same problem. There are so many villagers that I really want to keep in my town.

Alright, I've read through the villagers you love and your current villagers... here's what I've kinda picked out for you? This is unbelievably hard. ;v;
I'm also gonna try to pick villagers so that there would be an even blend with male/female and personality types. I'm adding the types by their names, due to the fact it would make it easier for me to keep track of them. ^^;

Julian (Male) (Smug)- I would keep him if he brought back some good memories for you. I actually have Walt in my town, just for that nostalgic feel. And the eye-shadow. You definitely can't go wrong with the eye-shadow.

Ankha (Female) (Snooty)- If you've already made up your mind that she's replacing Bill, the she goes on the list. No question about it. :)
I do not know of any dream towns with her in it, but if I find one, I'll be sure to let you know.

Muffy (Female) (Uchi)- Since you stated Muffy has your second favorite design in the game, I would go for her! Ahah, I actually love how sassy she looks. xD

Lucky (Male) (Lazy)- You know, I had Lucky in one of my old towns. I absolutely loved him. But that's not the reason I added him to this list. You gave him a cute little flower garden in front of his house, he's always giving you gifts, and he was one of your original villagers? He's a keeper, if you ask me!

Aurora (Female) (Normal)- It's funny how you can "miss" villagers, huh? I mean, in the back of my mind, I always think, "It's only a game..." but I always end up getting back a missed villager. xD Aurora is such a cutie. If you miss her, I think you should spring for her. :)

Bettina (Female) (Normal)- If she's stay'n. She's stay'n. No arguments. ;)

Ed- (Male) (Smug)- Since he reminds you of someone, I would try to get him. I have a villager or two that remind me of people. It just kinda makes me feel better, you know? Especially since those people have moved away from me since. And, of course, you love him a lot, so ... yeah.

Genji/Rudy (Male) (Jock)- I'm not sure why either, but I find Genji kinda ironic also. If you think he'll bring some fun into your town, go for him. Rudy's pretty cool too. It sounds like you're a little indecisive on a jock, though. If you were to decide on these two, I would find some dream towns first, and think about it a little more. (Again, I'll let you know if I find any with either of these two.)

Chrissy (Female) (Peppy)- She's a fluffy pink cinnamon roll. x'D You sound like you've enjoyed her in your town quite a bit, so I would keep her.

Vladimir (Male) (Cranky)- Not having the heart to let him go, means that he's going to stay in your town. ^^ He seems pretty much a pink buddy with Chrissy too. x'D

Hopefully everything makes sense, I'm kinda sleepy right now.

It was really hard to pick just 10, from all of the villagers you listed. And there were a few that I would have liked to put on this list, especially with some of the reasons you listed.
Ultimately, this is up for you to decide, though! With some of the villagers that you couldn't part with in your current town, I would have a back up list. In case if a certain villager moves out, you could be ready with the next of your wanted villagers on your list.

Good luck on picking though! ^^
 
I think you should replace Bettina the mound for Kiki the cat. I personally love Kiki!
 
It sounds...like you need two towns. ;) I have Genji and he is ADORABLE. Also, Marshal is so short compared to the flowers like Bettina. It does make them extra cute. =)

Edit to add: My random list of recommendations is:
Lucky/Ankha, Genji/Chrissy, Whitney/Wolfgang, Julian/Phoebe, Bettina/(whichever villager left from the list that you "can't possibly live without!"

This takes into account all personalities and everyone has a buddy they can relate to... ;)
 
Last edited:
@Blueskies

Thank you for the well thought out suggestions. As for the jock I'm incredibly indecisive, I've even considered doing a 16th villager cycle for cute Bill but that's too much, I wish he started with better house placement. :( I'll definitely need a jock they're so cute, I am just torn. This is a really nice balanced list though!

@Luckypinch

I love Kiki to death and really want to see her in my town, though I can't replace Bettina she's just too sweet and my favorite animal crossing villager.

@Dewdrops
Wow that's cute, the pairing thing, I like that! Thank you for the suggestion, oh picking that last slot will be tough.

I'm seeing a lot of Genji love so he's probably going to find his way into my town. No complaints from me.
 
I have Wolfgang and Genji in my other town and they're both awesome! I don't have a dream address, but I hope you can meet them in someone's dream. If not, you're welcome to visit them in my town. : D Otherwise I have no idea how to help you, there are so many great villagers in your lists!
 
I have Wolfgang and Genji in my other town and they're both awesome! I don't have a dream address, but I hope you can meet them in someone's dream. If not, you're welcome to visit them in my town. : D Otherwise I have no idea how to help you, there are so many great villagers in your lists!
Ugh I missed this.
I'll gladly visit your town we should set up a time. I especially want to communicate with Wolfgang,though it seems Genji will make a welcomed presence so that's two for one!
 
I love Aurora

- - - Post Merge - - -

She's the only one on your list I have in town and I think you said you've had her? But she's my favorite..as much as I love Maple.
 
I love Aurora

- - - Post Merge - - -

She's the only one on your list I have in town and I think you said you've had her? But she's my favorite..as much as I love Maple.

Yes she was in my second town, I really do want her in your one and I loved her so much, honestly Normal villagers are so great I wish all of them could be in my town.

Though I'm glad to see another Aurora fan! I'll have to check out your dream address to see her again.
 
Feel free I've only had 24 visitors. I haven't been playing for more than about 2 1/2 months so my town isn't perfect by any means! Please visit her though. I had her back in 2002 and loved her and she was my starter in New Leaf. I actually let her move the first time and I got her back the other night after realizing she's probably not in my 16 villager cycle anymore. I was a fool for letting her move and I won't again.
 
I still really need help picking my villagers I'm so conflicted,if anyone has anymore suggestions or can provide me with dream addresses with these villagers that'd be a big help!
 
Back
Top